WeRead Powered by ReaderPub
A Beginner's History of Philosophy, Vol. 2: Modern Philosophy cover

A Beginner's History of Philosophy, Vol. 2: Modern Philosophy

Chapter 2: PREFACE
Open in WeRead

About This Book

The volume offers a concise textbook-style survey of modern philosophy from the Renaissance onward, arranged for beginners with pedagogical features such as maps, summaries, and comparative tables. It analyzes causes of medieval decline, distinguishes humanistic and natural-science phases of the Renaissance, and traces the decentralization and technical development of modern thought. The work examines methods and aims of scientific and philosophical movements, contrasts national and intellectual differences across periods, and provides sketches of leading thinkers and schools while emphasizing historical context, methodological critique, and classroom utility.

The Project Gutenberg eBook of A Beginner's History of Philosophy, Vol. 2: Modern Philosophy

This ebook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this ebook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this eBook.

Title: A Beginner's History of Philosophy, Vol. 2: Modern Philosophy

Author: Herbert Ernest Cushman

Release date: July 16, 2020 [eBook #62663]
Most recently updated: October 18, 2024

Language: English

Credits: Produced by Richard Hulse and the Online Distributed
Proofreading Team at https://www.pgdp.net (This file was
produced from images generously made available by The
Internet Archive)

*** START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK A BEGINNER'S HISTORY OF PHILOSOPHY, VOL. 2: MODERN PHILOSOPHY ***

A BEGINNER’S HISTORY OF PHILOSOPHY

Transcriber’s Notes

The cover image was provided by the transcriber and is placed in the public domain.

Punctuation has been standardized.

Most abbreviations have been expanded in tool-tips for screen-readers and may be seen by hovering the mouse over the abbreviation.

This book was written in a period when many words had not become standardized in their spelling. Words may have multiple spelling variations or inconsistent hyphenation in the text. These have been left unchanged unless indicated with a Transcriber’s Note.

Index references have not been checked for accuracy.

Footnotes are identified in the text with a superscript number and have been accumulated in a table at the end of the text.

Transcriber’s Notes are used when making corrections to the text or to provide additional information for the modern reader. These notes have been accumulated in a table at the end of the book and are identified in the text by a dotted underline and may be seen in a tool-tip by hovering the mouse over the underline.

IMMANUEL KANT

(The Puttrich’sche Portrait of Kant was printed in the Kant-Studien in 1906 and is said by Professor Vaihinger to be one of the best likenesses of the Königsberg philosopher. The name of the artist was Puttrich, and the original painting goes back before 1798. It is interesting to note that this portrait of Kant was used by the sculptor, Rauch, as his model for the statue of Kant upon the memorial monument of Frederick the Great.)

A BEGINNER’S HISTORY OF PHILOSOPHY

BY

HERBERT ERNEST CUSHMAN, LL.D., Ph.D.

Sometime Professor of Philosophy in Tufts College
Lecturer of Philosophy in Harvard College
Lecturer of Philosophy in Dartmouth College

VOL. II

MODERN PHILOSOPHY

BOSTON   NEW YORK   CHICAGO

HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY

The Riverside Press Cambridge

COPYRIGHT, 1911, BY HERBERT ERNEST CUSHMAN

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED


PREFACE

The pedagogical purpose of this history of philosophy is stated in the Preface to the first volume. It may be desirable in this place to restate what that purpose is.

This book is intended as a text-book for sketch-courses in the history of philosophy. It is written for the student rather than for the teacher. It is a history of philosophy upon the background of geography and of literary and political history. Since the book is intended for the student, it makes the teacher all the more necessary; for it puts into the hands of the student an outline of the history of philosophy and into the hands of the teacher the class-room time for inspiring the student with his own interpretations. In making use of geographical maps, contemporary literature, and political history, this book is merely employing for pedagogical reasons the stock of information with which the student is furnished, when he begins the history of philosophy. The summaries, tables, and other generalizations are employed, as in text-books in other subjects, as helps to the memory. Therefore the book has the single purpose of arranging and organizing the material of the history of philosophy for the beginner.

The student will be impressed with the short time-length of the modern period compared with the tremendously long stretches of the periods of antiquity. The modern period is only four hundred and fifty years in length, if we take the date 1453 as its beginning. Compared to the twenty-two hundred years of ancient and mediæval life, the period of modern life seems very short. Furthermore the student who has followed the philosophy of antiquity must have observed how often philosophy arose out of ethnic situations in which whole civilizations were involved. He will find that modern philosophy in this respect stands in contrast with the philosophy of ancient times. With the decentralizing of modern Europe, philosophy has also become decentralized. This does not mean that philosophical movements have included fewer people in their sweep, but that the movements have had shorter life, the transitions have been quicker, and the epochs have been briefer. Modern civilization is subjective; and its philosophy is thereby more technical, and more difficult to understand and to interpret than the philosophy of antiquity.

There are many helpful books in English on the history of modern philosophy, and the student should have them at hand. I call attention especially to Rand, Modern Classical Philosophers, for its judicious selection from the original sources; to Royce, Spirit of Modern Philosophy, chapters iii to x; to Eucken, The Problem of Human Life, pp. 303 to 518; and to the Summaries in Windelband, History of Philosophy, Parts IV to VII. Besides these there are valuable histories of modern philosophy by Falckenberg, Höffding (2 vols.), Weber, Ueberweg (vol. ii), Calkins, Dewing, and Rogers.

To friends who have read parts of the manuscript, I desire to acknowledge my indebtedness for many wise criticisms and suggestions; especially to Professor W. A. Neilson, Professor R. B. Perry, Dr. B. A. G. Fuller, and Dr. J. H. Woods of Harvard University; to Professor Mary W. Calkins of Wellesley College; to Professor W. P. Montague of Columbia University; and to Professor S. P. Capen of Clark College.

Tufts College, December, 1910.


CONTENTS

VOLUME II. MODERN PHILOSOPHY
(1453 to the Present Time)

CHAPTER I. The Characteristics and Divisions of the Modern Period 1
  The Difficulty in the Study of Modern Philosophy 1
  The Periods of Modern Philosophy 2
  The Causes of the Decay of the Civilization of the Middle Ages 4
    (a) The Internal Causes 4
      (1) The Intellectual Methods were Self-Destructive 4
      (2) The Standard of Truth became a Double Standard 5
      (3) The Development of Mysticism 5
      (4) The Doctrine of Nominalism 5
    (b) The External Causes 6
CHAPTER II. The Renaissance (14531690) 8
  The General Character of the Renaissance 8
    (a) The New Man of the Renaissance 8
    (b) The New Universe of the Renaissance 9
      (1) The Transformation of the Physical Universe 9
      (2) The Restoration of the World of Antiquity 10
  The Significance of the Renaissance in History 11
  Map showing the Decentralization of Europe 13
  The Two Periods of the Renaissance: The Humanistic (14531600); The Natural Science (16001690) 15
    (a) The Similarities of the Two Periods 16
    (b) The Differences of the Two Periods 16
      (1) The Countries which participate in the Renaissance differ in the Two Periods 16
      (2) The Intellectual Standards differ in the Two Periods 17
      (3) The Scientific Methods in the Two Periods were Different 18
      (4) The Attitude of the Church toward Science differs in the Two Periods 19
  A Brief Contrast of the Two Periods—A Summary of the Discussion above 21
CHAPTER III. The Humanistic Period of the Renaissance (14531600) 22
  The Long List of Representatives of the Humanistic Period 22
  Nicolas of Cusa (14011464) 24
  Paracelsus (14931541) 25
  Giordano Bruno (15481600) 27
  Map showing the Birthplaces of the Chief Philosophers of the Renaissance 30
CHAPTER IV. The Natural Science Period of the Renaissance (16001690) 31
  The Philosophers of the Natural Science Period 31
  The Mathematical Astronomers 32
  Galileo Galilei (15641641) 36
  The Life of Francis Bacon, Baron Verulam (15611626) 39
  The Position of Bacon in Philosophy 39
  The Aim of Bacon 42
  The Method of Bacon 43
    (a) Bacon’s Criticism of the Past 44
    (b) Bacon’s Positive Construction 45
  The English Natural Science Movement 46
  Thomas Hobbes and his Contemporaries 47
  The Life and Writings of Hobbes (15881679) 49
    1. As a Classical Scholar (15881628) 49
    2. As Mathematician (16281638) 49
    3. As Philosopher (16381651) 50
    4. As Controversialist (16511668) 50
    5. As Classical Scholar (16681679) 50
  The Influences upon the Thought of Hobbes 50
    1. His Premature Birth 50
    2. His Father 51
    3. The New Mathematical Science 52
  The Fundamental Principle in the Teaching of Hobbes 52
  The Method of Hobbes 54
  The Kinds of Bodies 55
  Hobbes’s Application of the Mathematical Theory to Psychology 56
  Hobbes’s Application of the Mathematical Theory to Politics 58
  The Renaissance in England after Hobbes 61
CHAPTER V. The Rationalism of the Natural Science Period of the Renaissance 62
  The Nature of Rationalism 62
  The Mental Conflict in Descartes 65
  The Life and Philosophical Writings of Descartes (15961650) 66
    1. As Child and Student (15961613) 66
    2. As Traveler (16131628) 66
    3. As Writer (16291650) 67
    4. In Stockholm (16491650) 67
  The Two Conflicting Influences upon the Thought of Descartes 67
  The Method of Descartes 69
  Induction—Provisional Doubt—The Ultimate Certainty of Consciousness 70
  Deduction—The Implications of Consciousness 72
  The Existence of God 73
  The Reality of Matter 75
  God and the World 77
  The Relation of God to Matter 77
  The Relation of God to Minds 78
  The Relation of Mind and Body 78
  The Influence of Descartes 80
  The Relation of the Occasionalists and Spinoza to Descartes 81
  Portrait of Spinoza 84
  The Historical Place of Spinoza 84
  The Influences upon Spinoza 86
    1. His Jewish Training 86
    2. His Impulse from the New Science—Descartes’ Influence 86
    3. His Acquaintance with the Collegiants 87
  The Life and Philosophical Writings of Spinoza (16321677) 88
    1. In Israel (16321656) 89
    2. In Retirement (16561663) 89
    3. In the Public Eye (16631677) 90
  The Method of Spinoza 90
  The Fundamental Principle of Spinoza’s Philosophy 91
  Three Central Problems in Spinoza’s Teaching 93
  The Pantheism of Spinoza—The All-Inclusiveness of God 94
  The Mysticism of Spinoza 98
  Spinoza’s Doctrine of Salvation 102
  Summary of Spinoza’s Teaching 106
  Leibnitz as the Finisher of the Renaissance and the Forerunner of the Enlightenment 107
  The Life and Writings of Leibnitz (16461716) 108
    1. Leipsic and University Life (16461666) 111
    2. Mainz and Diplomacy (16661672) 111
    3. Paris and Science (16721676) 111
    4. Hanover and Philosophy (16761716) 112
  The Three Influences upon the Thought of Leibnitz 112
    (1) His Early Classical Studies 112
    (2) The New Science and his own Discoveries 113
    (3) Political Pressure for Religious Reconciliation 114
  The Method of Leibnitz 115
  The Immediate Problem for Leibnitz 118
  The Result of Leibnitz’s Examination of the Principles of Science—A Plurality of Metaphysical Substances 119
    1. Leibnitz first scrutinized the Scientific Conception of Motion 119
    2. Leibnitz next examined the Scientific Conception of the Atom 120
    3. Leibnitz then identified Force with the Metaphysical Atom 121
  The Double Nature of the Monads 122
  The Two Forms of Leibnitz’s Conception of the Unity of Substances 125
  The Intrinsic Unity of the Monads—The Philosophical Unity 125
  The Superimposed Unity of the Monads—The Theological Unity 129
CHAPTER VI. The Enlightenment (16901781) 132
  The Emergence of the “New Man”—Individualism 132
  The Practical Presupposition of the Enlightenment—The Independence of the Individual 134
  The Metaphysical Presupposition of the Enlightenment 135
  The Problems of the Enlightenment 135
    (a) Utilitarian Problems 136
    (b) Questions of Criticism 138
  A Comparison of the Enlightenment in England, France, and Germany 140
  The Many Groups of Philosophers of the Enlightenment 140
  Map showing the Birthplaces of some of the Influential Thinkers of the Enlightenment 144
CHAPTER VII. John Locke 145
  The Enlightenment in Great Britain 145
  John Locke, Life and Writings (16321704) 147
    1. Student Life (16321666) 147
    2. As Politician (16661683) 148
    3. As Philosophical Author (16831691) 149
    4. As Controversialist (16911704) 149
  The Sources of Locke’s Thought 150
    1. His Puritan Ancestry 150
    2. His Training in Tolerance 150
    3. The Scientific Influence 151
    4. The Political Influence 152
  Summary 153
  The Purpose of Locke 153
  Two Sides of Locke’s Philosophy 155
    (a) The Negative Side—Locke and Scholasticism 156
    (b) The Positive Side—The New Psychology and Epistemology 157
  Locke’s Psychology 158
  Locke’s Theory of Knowledge 160
  Locke’s Practical Philosophy 162
  The Influence of Locke 163
  The English Deists 164
  The English Moralists 166
  Chronological Table of the English Moralists 168
CHAPTER VIII. Berkeley and Hume 169
  The Life and Writings of George Berkeley (16851753) 169
    1. His Early Training (16851707) 169
    2. As Author (17071721) 170
    3. As Priest and Missionary (17211753) 171
  The Influences upon the Thought of Berkeley 172
  The Purpose of Berkeley 173
  Berkeley’s General Relation to Locke and Hume 174
  Berkeley’s Points of Agreement with Locke 175
  The Negative Side of Berkeley’s Philosophy 176
    1. As shown in General in his Analysis of Abstract Ideas 177
    2. As shown in Particular in his Analysis of Matter 177
  The Positive Side of Berkeley’s Philosophy 179
    1. Esse est Percipi 179
    2. The Existence of Mind is assumed by Berkeley 180
    3. Spiritual Substances are Sufficient to explain all Ideas 181
  The Life and Writings of David Hume (17111776) 183
    1. Period of Training (17111734) 184
    2. Period of Philosopher (17341752) 185
    3. Period of Politician (17521776) 185
  Influences upon the Thought of Hume 186
  Dogmatism, Phenomenalism, and Skepticism 187
  The Origin of Ideas 189
  The Association of Ideas 191
  The Association of Contiguity 193
  The Association of Resemblance 194
    1. Mathematics 194
    2. The Conception of Substance: Hume’s Attack on Theology 195
  The Association of Causation: Hume’s Attack on Science 196
  The Extent and Limits of Human Knowledge 199
  Hume’s Theory of Religion and Ethics 200
  The Scottish School 201
CHAPTER IX. The Enlightenment in France and Germany 203
  The Situation in France in the Enlightenment 203
  The English Influence in France 206
  The Two Periods of the French Enlightenment 207
  The Intellectual Enlightenment (17291762)—Voltaire, Montesquieu, and the Encyclopædists 208
  Voltaire (16941778) 209
  The Encyclopædists 211
  The Social Enlightenment (17621789) 213
  Rousseau (17121778) 213
  The German Enlightenment (17401781) 216
  The Introductory Period (16481740). Absolutism 217
    1. The Rise of Prussia 218
    2. The Early German Literature 219
    3. The Pietistic Movement 219
    4. The Transformation of Leibnitz’s Rationalism 220
  Summary of the Literary Enlightenment of Germany (17401781) 223
  The Political Enlightenment of Germany—Frederick the Great 224
  The Course of the German Enlightenment 226
  Lessing 228
CHAPTER X. Kant 230
  The Convergence of Philosophical Influences in Germany 230
  The Three Characteristics of German Philosophy 231
  The Two Periods of German Philosophy 232
  The Influences upon Kant 233
    1. Pietism 233
    2. The Leibnitz-Wolffian Philosophy 233
    3. The Physics of Newton 234
    4. The Humanitarianism of Rousseau 234
    5. The Skepticism of Hume 235
  The Life and Writings of Kant (17241804) 235
  The Problem of Kant 238
  The Method of Kant 239
  The Threefold World of Kant—Subjective States, Things-in-Themselves, and Phenomena 240
  The World of Knowledge 243
  The Place of Synthesis in Knowledge 245
  The Judgments Indispensable to Human Knowledge 248
  The Proof of the Validity of Human Knowledge 252
    1. In what does the Validity of Sense-Perception consist? 253
    2. In what does the Validity of the Understanding consist? 255
  Has the Reason by itself any Validity? 260
  The Idea of the Soul 262
  The Idea of the Universe 264
  The Idea of God 265
  Conclusion 268
  The Problem of the Critique of Practical Reason: The Ethics of Kant 269
  The Moral Law and the Two Questions concerning it 271
    1. The First Question concerning the Moral Law 272
    2. The Second Question concerning the Moral Law 273
  The Moral Postulates 275
    1. The Postulate of Freedom 276
    2. The Postulate of the Immortality of the Soul 276
    3. The Postulate of the Existence of God 276
CHAPTER XI. The German Idealists 278
  Idealism after Kant 278
  Fichte, Schelling, and Hegel 279
  Map showing the University Towns and other Important Places connected with the German Idealists 280
  The Life and Writings of Fichte (17621814) 282
    1. His Education (17621790) 283
    2. Discipleship of Kant (17901794) 283
    3. His Life at Jena (17941799) 284
    4. His Life at Berlin (17991814) 284
  The Influences upon Fichte’s Teaching 285
  Why we Philosophize 286
  The Moral Awakening 287
  The Central Principle in Fichte’s Philosophy 288
  The Moral World 290
  God and Man 292
  What a Moral Reality involves 293
    1. It involves the Consciousness of Something Else 293
    2. It involves a Contradiction 294
  Romanticism 295
  Goethe as a Romanticist 297
  Romanticism in Philosophy 299
  The Life and Writings of Schelling (17751854) 300
    1. Earlier Period (17751797) 302
    2. The Philosophy of Nature (17971800) 302
    3. The Transcendental Philosophy (18001801) 302
    4. The Philosophy of Identity (18011804) 303
    5. The Philosophy of Freedom and God (18041809) 303
    6. The Philosophy of Mythology and Revelation (18091854) 303
  A Brief Comparison of Fichte and Schelling as Philosophers 303
  Schelling’s Philosophy of Nature 305
  Schelling’s Transcendental Philosophy 307
  The System of Identity 310
  Schelling’s Religious Philosophy 311
  Hegel and the Culmination of Idealism 312
  Why Hegel remains to-day the Representative of Kant 314
  The Life and Writings of Hegel (17701831) 315
    1. Formative Period (17701796) 317
    2. Formulation of his Philosophy (17961806) 317
    3. Development of his Philosophy (18061831) 317
  Realism, Mysticism, and Idealism 318
  The Fundamental Principles of Hegel’s Idealism 321
  The Cosmic Unity 322
  The Cosmic Law 326
  Hegel’s Application of his Theory 328
CHAPTER XII. The Philosophy of the Thing-in-Itself 330
  Herbart and Schopenhauer 330
  Johann Friedrich Herbart 332
  The Life and Writings of Herbart (17761841) 333
  The Contradictions of Experience 334
  The Argument for Realism 334
  The Many Reals and Nature Phenomena 337
  The Soul and Mental Phenomena 338
  Arthur Schopenhauer and his Philosophical Relations 340
  The Life and Writings of Schopenhauer (17881860) 342
    1. Period of Education (17881813) 343
    2. Period of Literary Production (18131831) 343
    3. Period of Retirement (18311860) 343
  The Influences upon Schopenhauer’s Thought 343
  The World as Will and the World as Idea 345
  The Will as Irrational Reality 347
  The Misery of the World as Idea—Pessimism 348
  The Way of Deliverance 349
CHAPTER XIII. The Philosophy of the Nineteenth Century 352
  The Return to Realism 352
  The Character of the Realism of the Nineteenth Century 353
  Modern Philosophy and German Idealism 355
  The Philosophical Problems of the Nineteenth Century 356
    1. The Problem of the Functioning of the Soul 357
    2. The Problem of the Conception of History 360
INDEX 365

ILLUSTRATIONS

Immanuel Kant Frontispiece
Map showing the Decentralization of Europe 13
Map showing the Birthplaces of the Chief Philosophers of the Renaissance 30
Baruch de Spinoza 84
Map showing the Birthplaces of some of the Influential Thinkers of the Enlightenment 144
Map showing the University Towns and other Important Places connected with the German Idealists 280