[xxxi]
CASES DECIDED IN THE UNITED STATES
| Amberg File v. Shea | 1897 | 53 U. S. App., 449 | 242 |
| American Trotting v. Gocher | 1895 | 70 Fed. Rep., 237 | 239, 267 |
| Aronson v. Fleckenstein | 1886 | 28 Fed. Rep., 75 | 240, 241, 263, 270, 275, 297 |
| Atwill v. Ferrett | 1846 | 2 Blatchf., 39 | 270, 271, 290 |
| Backers v. Gould | 1849 | 7 How., 798 | 290 |
| Baker v. Selden | 1879 | 101 U. S. Rep., 99 | 237, 238, 239, 242 |
| Baker v. Taylor | 1848 | 2 Blatchf., 82 | 251, 257, 261, 262 |
| Banks v. M'Divitt | 1875 | 13 Blatchf., 163 | 241, 258, 278, 281, 282 |
| Banks v. Manchester | 1888 | 128 U. S. Rep., 244 | 241, 251, 272, 296 |
| Bartlett v. Crittenden | 1847 | 4 M'Lean, 301 | 262, 263, 299 |
| Belford v. Scribner | 1892 | 144 U. S. Rep., 488 | 253, 289, 291 |
| Bennett v. Boston | 1900 | 101 Fed Rep., 445 | 288 |
| Bennett v. Carr | 1899 | 96 Fed. Rep., 213 | 253 |
| Binns v. Woodruff | 1821 | 4 Wash. C. Ct., 48 | 245 |
| Black v. Allen | 1890 | 42 Fed. Rep., 618 | 260, 262, 273, 291 |
| "" | 1893 | 56 Fed. Rep., 764 | 241, 244, 252, 253, 270, 271, 274, 292 |
| Black v. Ehrich | 1891 | 44 Fed. Rep., 793 | 298 |
| Bleistein v. Donaldson | 1899 | 98 Fed. Rep., 608 | 246 |
| Blume v. Spear | 1887 | 30 Fed. Rep., 629 | 253, 281 |
| Blunt v. Patten | 1828 | 2 Paine, 397 | 262, 278 |
| Bolles v. Outing | 1899 | 175 U. S. Rep., 262 | 245, 256, 257 |
| "" | — | 77 Fed. Rep., 966 | 290 |
| Boucicault v. Fox | 1862 | 5 Blatchf., 87 | 241, 263, 271, 296 |
| Boucicault v. Hart | 1875 | 13 Blatchf., 47 | 251, 260, 263, 296 |
| Boucicault v. Wood | 1867 | 2 Biss., 34 | 249, 260, 264, 293, 296 |
| Brady v. Daly | 1899 | 175 U. S. Rep., 148 | 287, 292 |
| "" | 1897 | 83 Fed. Rep., 1007 | 277, 280 |
| Brightley v. Littleton | 1888 | 37 Fed. Rep., 103 | 236, 237, 239, 241, 242, 243, 283 |
| Broder v. Zeno | 1898 | 88 Fed. Rep., 74 | 266, 281 |
| Bullinger v. MacKay | 1879 | 15 Blatchf., 550 | 236, 239, 243, 270, 278, 283 |
| Burnell v. Chown | 1895 | 69 Fed. Rep., 993 | 282 |
| Burrow-Giles v. Sarony | 1884 | 111 U. S. Rep., 53 | 245, 256, 270 |
| Callaghan v. Myers | 1888 | 128 U. S. Rep., 617 | 240, 251, 253, 257, 267, 273, 289 [xxxii] |
| Carlisle v. Colusa County | 1893 | 57 Fed. Rep., 979 | 239 |
| Carte v. Bailey | 1874 | 64 Maine, 458 | 270, 273, 274, 299 |
| Carte v. Duff | 1885 | 25 Fed. Rep., 183 | 279, 287, 296 |
| Carte v. Evans | 1886 | 27 Fed. Rep., 861 | 241, 251, 252, 273, 274 |
| Carte v. Ford | 1883 | 15 Fed. Rep., 439 | 296 |
| Chapman v. Ferry | 1883 | 18 Fed. Rep., 539 | 251, 253 |
| "" | 1882 | 12 Fed. Rep., 693 | 289, 290 |
| Chase v. Sanborne | 1874 | 4 Cliff., 306 | 241, 251 |
| Chicago Music v. Butler | 1884 | 19 Fed. Rep., 758 | 251 |
| Child v. New York Times | 1901 | 110 Fed. Rep., 527 | 290 |
| Chils v. Gronland | 1890 | 41 Fed. Rep., 145 | 239, 282 |
| Clayton v. Stone | 1828 | 2 Paine, 382 | 236, 237, 239, 242 |
| Clemens v. Belford | 1883 | 14 Fed. Rep., 728 | 297 |
| Coffeen v. Brunton | 1849 | 4 M'Lean, 516 | 243, 246 |
| Collender v. Griffith | 1878 | 11 Blatchf., 212 | 246 |
| Colliery Engineer Co. v. United Correspondence Schools | 1899 | 94 Fed. Rep., 152 | 271, 291 |
| Connecticut v. Gould | 1888 | 34 Fed. Rep., 319 | 240 |
| Corbett v. Purday | 1897 | 80 Fed. Rep., 901 | 244 |
| Courier v. Donaldson | 1900 | 104 Fed. Rep., 993 | 246 |
| Cowen v. Banks | 1862 | 24 How. Pr., 72 | 240, 267 |
| Crowe v. Aiken | 1870 | 2 Biss., 208 | 263, 264, 299 |
| Daly v. Brady | 1889 | 39 Fed. Rep., 265 | 252, 290 |
| "" | 1895 | 69 Fed. Rep., 285 | 292 |
| Daly v. Palmer | 1868 | 6 Blatchf., 256 | 281, 286, 291 |
| Daly v. Walrath | 1899 | 40 App. Div. N. Y., 220 | 264, 296, 299 |
| Daly v. Webster | 1892 | 1 U. S. App., 573 | 240, 252, 281, 287 |
| Davidson v. Wheelock | 1886 | 27 Fed. Rep., 61 | 241 |
| Davies v. Vories | — | 42 S. W., 707 | 274 |
| Dewight v. Appleton | 1842 | 1 N. Y. Leg. Obs., 195 | 259 |
| Dielman v. White | 1900 | 102 Fed. Rep., 892 | 271 |
| Doan v. American Book Co. | 1901 | 105 Fed. Rep., 772 | 298 |
| Dodd v. Smith | 1891 | 144 Pa., 340 | 298 |
| D'Ole v. Kansas City Star Co. | 1899 | 94 Fed. Rep., 840 | 262 |
| Donnelley v. Ivers | 1882 | 20 Blatchf., 381 | 252 |
| Drummond v. Altemus | 1894 | 60 Fed. Rep., 338 | 297, 298 |
| Drury v. Ewing | 1862 | 1 Bond., 541 | 242, 283 |
| Egbert v. Greenberg | 1900 | 100 Fed. Rep., 447 | 239, 267 |
| Ehret v. Pierce | 1880 | 18 Blatchf., 302 | 245, 246, 282 |
| Elizabeth v. Pavement Co. | 1877 | 97 U. S. Rep., 126 | 289 |
| Emerson v. Davis | 1845 | 3 Story, 768 | 241, 243, 278, 279, 281 |
| Estes v. Leslie | 1886 | 27 Fed. Rep., 22 | 297 |
| Estes v. Williams | 1884 | 21 Fed. Rep., 189 | 296, 297 |
| Ewer v. Coxe | 1824 | 4 Wash. C. C., 487 | 251, 296[xxxiii] |
| Falk v. Brett | 1891 | 48 Fed. Rep., 678 | 245 |
| Falk v. Curtis | 1901 | 107 Fed. Rep., 126 | 290, 291 |
| "" | 1900 | 100 Fed. Rep., 77 | 290 |
| "" | 1900 | 98 Fed. Rep., 989 | 290 |
| Falk v. Donaldson | 1893 | 57 Fed. Rep., 32 | 245, 253, 276, 280, 281, 283 |
| Falk v. Gast | 1893 | 54 Fed. Rep., 890 | 259, 262, 289 |
| "" | 1891 | 48 Fed. Rep., 262 | 245, 251, 259 |
| Falk v. Heffron | 1893 | 56 Fed. Rep., 299 | 290 |
| Falk v. Howell | 1888 | 37 Fed. Rep., 202 | 276, 281, 283 |
| Falk v. Schumacher | 1891 | 48 Fed. Rep., 222 | 255, 293 |
| Farmer v. Culvert | 1872 | 5 Am. L. T. R., 168 | 280, 282 |
| Farmer v. Elstner | 1888 | 33 Fed. Rep., 494 | 279, 289 |
| Fishel v. Lueckel | 1892 | 53 Fed. Rep., 499 | 276, 277, 280, 291 |
| Folsom v. Marsh | 1841 | 2 Story, 100 | 243, 277, 279, 280, 284 |
| French v. Kreling | 1894 | 63 Fed. Rep., 621 | 262 |
| French v. Maguire | 1878 | 55 How. (N. Y.) Pr., 471 | 263, 299 |
| Gilmore v. Anderson | 1890 | 42 Fed. Rep., 267 | 289 |
| "" | 1889 | 38 Fed. Rep., 846 | 274, 278, 283 |
| Goldmark v. Kreling | 1888 | 35 Fed. Rep., 661 | 281 |
| "" | 1885 | 25 Fed. Rep., 349 | 299 |
| Gottsberger v. Aldine | 1887 | 33 Fed. Rep., 381 | 261 |
| Gould v. Banks | 1832 | 8 Wend., 562 | 240, 274 |
| Gray v. Russell | 1839 | 1 Story, 11 | 240, 241, 243, 270, 278, 279, 284 |
| Greene v. Bishop | 1858 | 1 Cliff., 186 | 243, 269, 279 |
| Harper v. Holman | 1897 | 84 Fed. Rep., 224 | 291, 296 |
| Harper v. Shoppell | 1886 | 23 Blatchf., 431 | 276 |
| Hefel v. Whitely | 1893 | 54 Fed. Rep., 179 | 256 |
| Hegemen v. Springer | 1901 | 110 Fed. Rep., 374 | 290 |
| Heine v. Appleton | 1853 | 4 Blatchf. C. C., 12 | 240, 269, 271, 272, 293 |
| Henderson v. Tompkins | 1894 | 60 Fed. Rep., 758 | 240 |
| Higgins v. Keuffel | 1891 | 140 U. S. Rep., 428 | 246 |
| Hill v. Epley | 1858 | 31 Penn., 331 | 293 |
| Hoertel v. Raphael Tuck | 1899 | 94 Fed. Rep., 844 | 294 |
| Holmes v. Donohue | 1896 | 77 Fed. Rep., 179 | 263 |
| Holmes v. Hurst | 1898 | 174 U. S. Rep., 82 | 263, 296 |
| Howell v. Miller | 1898 | 91 Fed. Rep., 129 | 241, 280, 282 |
| Hubbard v. Thompson | 1882 | 14 Fed. Rep., 689 | 291 |
| Illustrated American v. New York Press | 1892 | Cited, U. S., 594 | 256 |
| Isaacs v. Daly | 1875 | 39 N. Y., 511 | 244, 245 |
| Jackson v. Walkie | 1886 | 29 Fed. Rep., 15 | 255 |
| Jewellers' Mercantile Agency v. Jewellers' Publishing Co. | 1898 | 155 N. Y., 241 | 251, 260, 261, 262, 263, 296[xxxiv] |
| Jewellers' Mercantile Agency v. Jewellers' Publishing Co. | 1896 | 84 Hun., 12 | 251, 260 |
| Johnson v. Donaldson | 1880 | 3 Fed. Rep., 22 | 243, 278, 290 |
| Johnson v. Klopsch | 1890 | 88 Fed. Rep., 692 | 293 |
| Jollie v. Jacques | 1850 | 1 Blatchf., 618 | 241, 244, 251, 281 |
| Jones v. Thoms | 1843 | 1 N. Y. Leg. Obs. 408 | 299 |
| Keene v. Clarke | 1867 | 5 Rob. (NY.), 38 | 263, 293 |
| Keene v. Kimball | 1860 | 16 Gray, 549 | 263, 266, 299 |
| Keene v. Wheatley | 1860 | 4 Phil. (Pa.), 157 | 262, 263, 274, 284 |
| Kennedy v. McTammany | 1888 | 33 Fed. Rep., 584 | 276 |
| Kiernan v. Manhattan | 1876 | 50 How. Pr., 194 | 262 |
| Kipling v. Fenno | 1900 | 106 Fed. Rep., 692 | 298 |
| Koppel v. Downing | — | 24 Wash. L. R., 342 | 269 |
| Ladd v. Oxnard | 1896 | 75 Fed. Rep., 703 | 237, 239, 260, 261, 263, 277, 283 |
| Larrowe v. O'Loughlin | 1898 | 88 Fed. Rep., 896 | 263 |
| Lawrence v. Dana | 1869 | 4 Cliff, 1 | 241, 242, 251, 258, 269, 271, 273, 277, 279, 280, 284, 285, 289, 293 |
| List Publishing Co. v. Keller | 1887 | 30 Fed. Rep., 772 | 281, 282 |
| Little v. Gould | 1851 | 2 Blatchf., 165 | 269, 271, 272, 273, 274, 291 |
| Little v. Hall | 1855 | 18 How., 165 | 240, 299 |
| Littleton v. Oliver | 1894 | 62 Fed. Rep., 597 | 254 |
| McDonald v. Hearst | 1899 | 95 Fed. Rep., 656 | 292 |
| MacKaye v. Mallory | 1882 | 12 Fed. Rep., 328 | 273 |
| M'Lean v. Flemming | 1877 | 96 U. S. Rep., 245 | 277, 296 |
| Maloney v. Foote | 1900 | 101 Fed. Rep., 264 | 277 |
| Martinetti v. Maguire | 1867 | 1 Abb. U. S., 356 | 266 |
| Mead v. West | 1896 | 80 Fed. Rep., 380 | 241, 278, 281, 282, 283 |
| Menendez v. Holt | 1888 | 128 U. S. Rep., 514 | 293 |
| Merrell v. Tice | 1881 | 104 U. S. Rep., 557 | 251, 253, 296 |
| Merriam v. Famous Shoe Co. | 1891 | 47 Fed. Rep., 411 | 297, 298 |
| Merriam v. Holloway | 1890 | 43 Fed. Rep., 450 | 297 |
| Merriam v. Texas Siftings | 1892 | 49 Fed. Rep, 944 | 298 |
| Mifflin v. Dutton | 1901 | 107 Fed. Rep., 708 | 256, 263 |
| Millet v. Snowden | 1848 | 1 West L. J., 240 | 277 |
| Morrison v. Pettibone | 1897 | 87 Fed. Rep., 330 | 276, 277, 280 |
| Mott v. Clow | 1897 | 53 U. S. App., 461 | 237, 238, 239, 242, 246 |
| Munro v. Smith | 1890 | 42 Fed. Rep., 266 | 282 |
| Mutual Advertising Co. v. Refo | 1896 | 76 Fed. Rep., 961 | 240, 271, 272, 282[xxxv] |
| Nash v. Lathrop | 1886 | 142 Mass., 29 | 240 |
| Oertel v. Wood | 1870 | 40 How. Pr., 10 | 299 |
| Oertel v. Jacoby | 1872 | 44 How., 179 | 299 |
| Osgood v. Allen | 1872 | 1 Holmes, 185 | 244 |
| Osgood v. Aloe | 1897 | 83 Fed. Rep., 470 | 251, 253, 256, 260 |
| Paige v. Banks | 1871 | 7 Blatchf., 152 | 268 |
| Palmer v. De Witt | 1872 | 47 N. Y., 532 | 263, 264, 296, 299, 30 |
| Parker v. Hulme | 1849 | 1 West L. J., 240 | 277 |
| Parkinson v. Lascelle | 1875 | 3 Sawyer, 330 | 251 |
| Parton v. Prang | 1872 | 3 Cliff, 537 | 273, 296, 299, 300 |
| Perris v. Hexamer | 1878 | 99 V. S. Rep., 674 | 280 |
| Pierce v. Werckmeister. | 1896 | 72 Fed. Rep., 57 | 259, 263 |
| Pierpont v. Fowle | 1846 | 2 Wood, and Min., 23 | 267, 271 |
| Press Publishing Co. v. Munroe | 1896 | 73 Fed. Rep., 196 | 262, 270, 271, 274, 300 |
| Pulte v. Derby | 1852 | 5 M'L., 328 | 260, 273 |
| Reed v. Carusi | 1845 | 72 Fed. Cas., No. 11,642; 8 L. R., 411 | 241, 290 |
| Reed v. Holliday | 1884 | 19 Fed. Rep., 325 | 277, 279, 291 |
| Rees v. Peltzer | 1874 | 75 Ill., 475 | 263, 296, 299 |
| Richardson v. Miller | 1877 | 3 L. and Eq. Rep. (Am.), 614 | 246, 262, 267, 294 |
| Rigney v. Dalton | 1896 | 77 Fed. Rep., 176 | |
| Rigney v. Raphael Tuck | 1896 | 77 Fed. Rep., 173 | 294 |
| Roberts v. Myers | 1860 | 13 L. R. Mass., 398 | 244, 270 |
| Rogers v. Jewett | 1858 | 12 L. R., 339 | 291 |
| Rosenbach v. Dreyfuss | 1880 | 2 Fed. Rep., 217 | 247, 294 |
| Ross v. Raphael Tuck | 1898 | 91 Fed. Rep., 128 | 294 |
| Sanborn v. Dakin | 1889 | 39 Fed. Rep., 266 | 280, 282 |
| Sarony v. Ehrich | 1886 | 28 Fed. Rep., 79 | 291 |
| Schreiber v. Thornton | 1883 | 17 Fed. Rep., 603 | 245 |
| Schumacher v. Wogram | 1888 | 35 Fed. Rep., 210 | 246, 257 |
| Schumacher v. Schwencke | 1885 | 25 Fed. Rep., 466 | 271, 272 |
| "" | — | 23 Blatchf., 373 | 246 |
| "" | 1887 | 30 Fed. Rep., 690 | 277 |
| Scoville v. Toland | 1848 | 6 West Law, J., 84 | 243 |
| Scribner v. Allen & Co. | 1892 | 49 Fed. Rep., 854 | 251, 256, 293 |
| Serrana v. Jefferson | 1888 | 33 Fed. Rep., 347 | 282 |
| Shook v. Daly | 1875 | 49 How. Pr., 366 | 266 |
| Shook v. Rankin | 1875 | 6 Biss., 477 | 241, 263 |
| Snow v. Laird | 1900 | 98 Fed. Rep., 813 | 242, 245 |
| Snow v. Mast | 1895 | 65 Fed. Rep., 995 | 257 |
| Social Register Association v. Howard | 1894 | 64 Fed. Rep., 270 | 296 |
| Springer v. Falk | 1894 | 20 U. S. App., 296 | 259, 276, 280, 283, 290, 292[xxxvi] |
| Stephens v. Cady | 1852 | 14 How., 528 | 273, 275 |
| Stevens v. Gladding | 1854 | 17 How., 447 | 273, 275, 289 |
| Story v. Holcombe | 1847 | 4 M'L., 306 | 277, 279, 283, 284, 285 |
| Stowe v. Thomas | 1853 | 2 Wall. Jr., 547 | 284, 286 |
| Struve v. Schwedler | 1857 | 4 Blatchf., 23 | 251 |
| Stuart v. Smith | 1895 | 68 Fed. Rep., 189 | 291 |
| Taft v. Stephens | 1889 | 39 Fed. Rep., 781 | 294 |
| Taylor v. Gilman | 1885 | 24 Fed. Rep., 632 | 288, 290, 292 |
| Thomas v. Lennox | 1883 | 14 Fed. Rep., 849 | 241, 263, 279 |
| Thompson v. Hubbard | 1888 | 131 U. S. Rep., 123 | 251,259 |
| Thornton v. Schreiber | 1887 | 124 U. S. Rep., 612 | 290 |
| "" | — | 8 Sup. Ct., 618 | 288, 290, 292 |
| Tompkins v. Halleck | 1882 | 133 Mass., 32 | 263, 299 |
| Trow v. Boyd | 1899 | 97 Fed. Rep., 586 | 291, 292 |
| Wall v. Gordon | 1872 | 12 Abb. Pr. N. S. (N. Y.), 349 | 262 |
| Webb v. Powers | 1847 | 2 Woodb. and M., 497 | 273, 277, 282, 283 |
| Werckmeister v. Springer | 1894 | 63 Fed. Rep., 808 | 256, 263, 273, 274 |
| West v. Lawyers | 1896 | 51 U. S. App., 216 | 240, 251, 278 |
| "" | 1894 | 64 Fed. Rep., 360 | 282, 289, 296 |
| Wheaton v. Peters | 1834 | 8 Pet., 591 | 237, 240, 251, 268, 296, 299 |
| Wheeler v. Cobbey | 1895 | 70 Fed. Rep., 487 | 292 |
| Williams v. Smythe | 1901 | 110 Fed. Rep., 961 | 291 |
| Wood v. Abbott | 1866 | 5 Blatchf. C. C., 325 | 245 |
| Yuengling v. Schile | 1882 | 12 Fed. Rep., 97 | 246, 247, 248, 269, 273 |