Both these fables may, I think, have been built up on a slender basis of fact—the only fact which the Greeks seem to have known about the bird. Aristotle (Hist. Anim. v. 8. 4) tells us that the ἀλκύων was very seldom seen. “It is the rarest of all birds, for it is only seen at the setting of the Pleiades (about Nov. 9) and at the winter solstice; and it appears at seaports flying as much as round a ship, and then vanishing away.” Whether the bird is still seen in Greece only in late autumn and winter I cannot say; but Mr. Seebohm tells us (Brit. Birds, ii. 345) that in Eastern Europe it is compelled by the cold to migrate, some finding their way to Egypt, and therefore necessarily crossing the Ægean, or passing over Greece or the western coast of Asia Minor. I think it is a fair guess that those known to Aristotle were on their way from Thrace and Scythia to a warmer climate; and this hypothesis would explain not only their short stay, but their connection with the sea and harbours, and their mysterious character. Even supposing that a few haunted the Greek rivers at other times of the year, they would not be often seen there by a people not given either to sporting or to exploring out-of-the-way places; the one fact which would impress itself on the unscientific mind would be the sudden apparition in winter, and especially in mid-winter, of this little blue-green spirit about the harbours, and its as rapid disappearance.
If this be so, I think we have not far to seek for the origin of the two fables. Nothing being known of its nesting, it was assumed that it nested at or about the time when it appeared; and the not unfrequent calm and fine weather of mid-December would confirm the fancy, and give it a new mythical colouring. (The matter-of-fact philosopher does not of course allow that these fine days always occurred in his own experience; they are not always met, he says (v. 8. 3), in this country at the time of the solstice, “but they always occur in the Sicilian Sea.”) When this fable of the nesting-time had once established itself, it would be not very difficult to find a nest among the curiosities of the sea. So the little blue bird came to suffer “a sea-change, into something rich and strange,” through the careless fancy of the imaginative Greek.
Note D. Redpolls in the Alps. (p. 195.)
On page 49 of the first edition of this book there was a paragraph which described the shooting by Anderegg of a Lesser Redpoll (Linota rufescens) on the Engstlen Alp. The date was June 30 (1884), and I had little doubt that the bird (which was a female) was one of a pair which had been breeding there. And this idea was confirmed by the discovery of a nest in the same place by Anderegg in May of the present year (1886), which Mr. Scott Wilson, who was with him at the time, considered to belong to the Lesser Redpoll.
The form, however, of the Redpoll which is usually found in the Alps is that which is usually called ‘Mealy’ (Linota linaria); this has been reported by Mr. Seebohm as pretty frequent in the Engadine, and by Prof. Newton, on the authority of Colonel Ward, as having been abundant in Canton Vaud in the winter of 1874-5. All the Redpolls I saw last September were, to judge from size and colouring, of this form: so also were all that I have seen in Swiss museums marked as having been shot in the Alps. Believing therefore, on these grounds, and in deference to the arguments of the Rev. H. A. Macpherson, that both Mr. Scott Wilson and myself had made a mistake, I struck out the paragraph in question from my second edition.
Since doing so, however, I have paid a visit to Cambridge, where Prof. Newton pointed out to me a passage in Prof. Giglioli’s recently published catalogue of Italian birds bearing on the point. He writes without hesitation of Linota rufescens as occasionally breeding in the Italian Alps. This induces me to add this note to the present edition; for if it could be distinctly proved that L. rufescens is found breeding in the Alpine region, new light would be thrown, not only on the curious geographical distribution of this form, but on the abnormal character of the ornithology of the Alps. Prof. Giglioli may be himself mistaken, and as Anderegg and I failed to skin our bird, we cannot produce it as evidence; but my notes made while examining it point decidedly to L. rufescens rather than L. linaria, the length, for example, appearing as only four inches.
Footnotes
‘Fountains, and ye that warble as ye flow
Melodious murmurs, warbling tune his praise.’
The word seems to express a kind of singing which is soft, continuous, and ‘legato.’
I Virgil then, of sweet Parthenope
The nursling, woo’d the flowery walks of peace
Inglorious, &c.
And all the while, with hollow voice, thine own
Loved wood-pigeon shall soothe thee, nor alone,
For from the lofty elm the dove shall ever moan.
But no whit the more
For all expedients tried and travail borne
By man and beast in turning oft the soil,
Do greedy goose and Strymon-haunting cranes
And succory’s bitter fibres not molest
Or shade not injure—
Time it is to set
Snares for the crane, and meshes for the stag,
And hunt the long-eared hares.
The Dardanians on the walls raise a shout to the sky.
Hope comes to kindle wrath; they hurl their missiles strongly;
even as under black clouds cranes from the Strymon utter
their signal notes and sail clamouring across the sky, and
noisily stream down the gale.
—Aen. x. 262 foll.
Never at unawares did showers annoy:
Or, as it rises, the high-soaring cranes
Flee to the hills before it, or, with face
Upturned to heaven, the heifer snuffs the gale
Through gaping nostrils, or about the meres
Shrill-twittering flits the swallow.
—Georgic i. 373.
In blushing spring
Comes the white bird long-bodied snakes abhor.
—Georg. ii. 320.
Then the crow
With full voice, good-for-nought, inviting rain,
Stalks on the dry sand mateless and alone.
—Georg. i. 388.
Soft then the voice of rooks from indrawn throat
Thrice, four times, o’er repeated, and full oft
On their high cradles, by some hidden joy
Gladdened beyond their wont, in bustling throngs
Among the leaves they riot; so sweet it is
When showers are spent, their own loved nests again
And tender brood to visit.
—Georg. i. 410.
Whose weedy water feeds the snow-white swan.
—Georg. ii. 199.
—Aen. xi. 456; cp. vii. 700.
When cool eve
Allays the air, and dewy moonbeams slake
The forest glades, with halcyon’s voice the shore
And every thicket with the goldfinch rings.
—Georg. iii. 338.
Not to the Sun’s warmth there upon the shore
Do halcyons dear to Thetis ope their wings.
—Georg. i. 398.
Ere yet the lowering storm breaks o’er the land
A sullen groundswell heaves along the strand,
On mountain heights dry snapping sounds are heard,
The booming shores bedrizzled are and blurred,
And soughs of wind sigh through the forest stirred.
The wave already scarce foregoes the hull
When homeward from the offing flies the gull,
With screams borne inland by the blast; and when
Sea-coots play round the margin of the fen;
The heron quits the marsh where she was bred
And soars upon a cloud far overhead.
As in the poplar-shade a nightingale
Mourns her lost young, which some relentless swain,
Spying, from the nest has torn unfledged, but she
Wails the long night, and perched upon a spray
With sad insistence pipes her dolorous strain,
Till all the region with her wrongs o’erflows.
—Georg. iv. 511.
INDEX OF BIRDS MENTIONED IN THE VOLUME.
(The scientific names are those used in Dresser’s List of European Birds.)
- A
- Accentor, Alpine. Accentor collaris (Scop.), 95, 196.
- Accentor, Hedge. Accentor modularis (Linn.), 95.
- Aquatic Warbler. Acrocephalus aquaticus (Gmel.), 86.
- B
- Bittern. Botaurus stellaris (Linn.), 85.
- Blackbird. Turdus merula (Linn.), 31, 60, 82, 88.
- Blackcap. Sylvia atricapilla (Linn.), 51 foll., 119, 164.
- Bonelli’s Warbler. Phylloscopus Bonellii (Vieill.), 109.
- Brambling. Frangilla montifringilla (Linn.), 172.
- Bullfinch. Pyrrhula europaea (Vieill.), 12, 120.
- Bunting, Corn. Emberiza miliaria (Linn.), 139, 149.
- Bunting, Reed. Emberiza schoeniclus (Linn.), 149.
- Buzzard. Buteo vulgaris (Leach), 88.
- C
- Chiff-chaff. Phylloscopus collybita (Vieill.), 38, 42 foll., 83, 92. Note B.
- Chough, Alpine. Pyrrhocorax alpinus (Koch.), 82, 93, 194, 235.
- Chough, Cornish. Pyrrhocorax graculus (Linn.), 93.
- Citril Finch. Chrysomitris citrinella (Linn.), 80, 97.
- Corncrake. Crex pratensis (Bechst.), 65.
- Crane. Grus communis (Bechst.), 224 foll.
- Creeper. Certhia familiaris (Linn.), 25, 190.
- Crossbill. Loscia curvirostra (Linn.), 188.
- Crow. Corvus corone (Linn.), 153, 187, 236, 237.
- Cuckoo. Cuculus canorus (Linn.), 125-128.
- Curlew. Numenius arquata (Linn.), 143.
- E
- Eagle, Golden. Aquila chrysaetus (Linn.), 92.
- F
- Fieldfare. Turdus pilaris (Linn.), 35, 143.
- Flycatcher, Pied. Muscicapa atricapilla (Linn.), 92, 133.
- Flycatcher, Spotted. Muscicapa grisola (Linn.), 65, 130-134.
- G
- Garden-warbler. Sylvia salicari (Linn.), 51 foll., 88.
- Goldfinch. Carduelis elegans (Steph.), 138, 171, 242.
- Grasshopper-warbler. Locustella naevia (Bodd.), 154 foll.
- Greenfinch. Ligurinus chloris (Linn.), 65, 119.
- Gull, Common. Larus canus (Linn.), 141.
- K
- Kestrel. Falco tinnunculus (Linn.), 32, 141, 154.
- Kingfisher. Alcedo ispida (Linn.), 13, 14, 187, 240, 241, 260.
- M
- Magpie. Pica rustica (Scop.), 153.
- Marsh Warbler. Acrocephalus palustris (Bechst.), 86.
- Martin, Crag. Chelidon rupestris (Scop.), 91, 190.
- Martin, House. Chelidon urbica (Linn.), 7, 190, 250.
- Missel-thrush. Turdus viscivorus (Linn.), 98, 119.
- Moorhen. Gallinula chloropus (Linn.), 13.
- N
- Nightingale. Daulias luscinia (Linn.), 66, 161 foll., 250.
- Nightjar. Caprimulgus europaeus (Linn.), 134.
- Nuthatch. Sitta caesia (Wolf), 25, 128.
- P
- Petrel, Stormy. Procellaria pelagica (Linn.), 33.
- Pipit, Tree. Anthus trivialis (Linn.), 153.
- Pipit, Water (or Alpine). Anthus spinoletta (Linn.), 94, 194, 196.
- Plover, Common. Vanellus vulgaris (Bechst.), 101, 143.
- Ptarmigan. Lagopus mutus (Leach), 82, 100.
- R
- Raven. Corvus corax (Linn.), 232, 234.
- Redpoll, Lesser. Linota rufescens (Vieill.), 21, 193, 262.
- Redstart. Ruticilla phoenicurus (Linn.), 62, 63, 88, 121.
- Redstart, Black. Ruticylla tithys (Scop.), 80, 89, 123 foll., 193.
- Redwing. Turdus iliacus (Linn.), 30, 142.
- Reed-warbler. Acrocephalus streperus (Vieill.), 41, 56, 57, 86.
- Ring-dove. Columba palumbus (Linn.), 219 foll.
- Ring-Ousel. Turdus torquatus (Linn.), 82, 98, 151.
- Robin. Erithacus rubecula (Linn.), 9, 88, 119, 125-127, 140, 206.
- Rock-dove. Columba livia (Bonnat), 219, 221.
- Rook. Corvus frugilegus (Linn.), 134, 141, 142.
- S
- Sandpiper, Common. Totanus hypoleucus (Linn.), 137.
- Sandpiper, Green. Totanus ochropus (Linn.), 136, 137.
- Sedge-warbler. Acrocephalus schoenobaenus (Linn.), 41, 42, 57.
- Serin Finch. Serinus hortulanus (Koch.), 97.
- Siskin. Chrysomitris spinus (Linn.), 120.
- Snipe, Jack. Gallinago gallinula (Linn.), 24.
- Snow-Finch. Montifringilla nivalis (Linn.), 82, 100, 101.
- Sparrow. Passer domesticus (Linn.), 64, 88.
- Stonechat. Pratincola rubicola (Linn.), 147.
- Swallow. Hirundo rustica (Linn.), 7, 90, 201, 250.
- Swan. Cygnus musicus (Linn.), 237, 238.
- Swift. Cypselus apus (Linn.), 65, 90.
- Swift, Alpine. Cypselus melba (Linn.), 91.
- T
- Teal. Querquedula crecca (Linn.), 241.
- Tern. Sterna fluviatilis (Naum.), 33.
- Thrush, Song. Turdus musicus (Linn.), 30.
- Tit, Blue. Parus caeruleus (Linn.), 29, 105, 151.
- Tit, Cole. Parus ater (Linn.), 52, 105.
- Tit, Crested. Lophophanes cristatus (Linn.), 106, 184.
- Tit, Great. Parus major (Linn.), 29, 105, 151.
- Tit, Long-tailed. Acredula caudata (Linn.), 29, 105, 142.
- Tit, Marsh. Parus palustris (Linn.), 29, 105.
- Turtle-dove. Turtur communis (Selby), 133, 143, 219.
- W
- Wagtail, Gray. Motacilla melanope (Pall.), 17, 98, 186.
- Wagtail, Pied. Motacilla lugubris (Temm.), 87, 148, 186.
- Wagtail, White. Motacilla alba (Linn.), 87, 98.
- Wagtail, Yellow. Motacilla raii (Bp.), 64, 138.
- Wall Creeper. Tichodroma muraria (Linn.), 82, 101.
- Wheatear. Saxicola oenanthe (Linn.), 98, 172, 204.
- Whinchat. Pratincola rubetra (Linn.), 88, 145, 146.
- Whitethroat. Sylvia rufa (Bodd.), 41, 54 foll.
- Whitethroat, Lesser. Sylvia curruca (Linn.), 40, 53 foll.
- Willow-warbler. Phylloscopus trochilus (Linn.), 40-42, 47, 88.
- Wood-pecker, Great Black. Dryocopus martius (Linn.), 104, 184, 185.
- Wood-pecker, Green. Gecinus Viridis (Linn.), 26, 165.
- Wood-pecker, Lesser-Spotted. Dendrocopus minor (Linn.), 26, 166.
- Wood-pecker, Greater-Spotted. Dendrocopus major (Linn.), 181.
- Wood-pecker, Three-toed. Picoides tridactylus (Linn.), 104, 191.
- Wryneck. Yunx torquilla (Linn.), 167.
- Y
- Yellow-hammer. Emberiza citrinella (Linn.), 88.
THE END.