WeRead Powered by ReaderPub
British Supremacy & Canadian Self-Government, 1839-1854 cover

British Supremacy & Canadian Self-Government, 1839-1854

Chapter 28: E
Open in WeRead

About This Book

The study traces how early Victorian Canada negotiated the tension between imperial authority and growing colonial self-government, using official correspondence and provincial pamphlets to reconstruct political debate. It analyzes the social forces that shaped a distinctive Canadian community—education, religion, and partisan life—and profiles successive governors-general whose decisions affected the balance between London and local opinion. The author argues that British ministers often misunderstood colonial temper, that popular loyalty coexisted with demands for autonomy, and that racial and moral solidarities, more than constitutional formulas, underpinned evolving relations and the practical consequences of increased self-government.


C

Campbell, Robert, as School-master, 33

Canada, Autonomy of, see Autonomy.

Communications in, and to, in early days, 9 et sqq.

Disaffection in, how cured by Elgin, 222

as Envisaged by Grey and by Durham, 276-7

History of, Political lessons from, 345-6

Loyalty of, as affected by Autonomy, 203, 229, 314, 323 et sqq., 342; Mistrust of, over Militia Bill, 289

Relations of, with Great Britain, as affected by Autonomy, in anticipation (Stanley's), 139-40, 156, and in fact, 156, 323 et sqq.; true basis of, 239

Social and Physical conditions in (circa 1839), 8 et sqq.

Tariff reorganisation in, difficulties created by, with U.S.A., 288

Canal-works, condition in 1841, 99

Canning, George, 189; and Bagot, 126, 137

Capital, the, Crown's right to name, Bagot on, 155; Brown on, 326-7

Carlyle, Thomas, on Buller, 241

Caron, Réné Edouard, Speaker of Upper House, and La Fontaine, 177

Cartier, Sir George Étienne, French-Canadian Leader, 14; and French-Canadian feeling, 332 &n.; Loyalty of, 338

Cartwright, J. S., 144; Political views of, 60, 133, 151

Cartwright, Sir Richard, and British views on Separation, 290

on Annexation views after 1856, 333-4; on Personal Morals of Members of Canadian Assemblies, 320; on the Political influence of The Globe, 341-2

Cathcart, Earl of, as interim Governor-General, 7 n., 70 n., 187 &n.

Cauchon, Joseph, and Confederation, 314; Loyalty of, 338

Chatham, Earl of, 4

China, Elgin's work in, 189, 191

Christian Guardian, The, 38 &n.2

Church of England in Canada (see also Clergy Reserves), 43-4, 47, 49

Church Support, Voluntary principle of, Rolph on, 51-2

Civil List difficulties, 138, 140, 146, 154, 155, 163; Grey's attitude as to, 272; Stanley's views on, 130; the Surrender, 154-5, 163, 279

Clear-Grit party, Loyalty of, 339; Politics of, 300 &n.2, 301, 302

Clericalism in French Canada, 14, 15, 17; and School Control, 31-2

Clergy Reserve Question, dispute on, 47-54, 62, 64, 252-3, 254-5, 268; Settlement of, by compromise, 90-2, 279, 306

Coalition Governments in Canada (see Baldwin-Hincks & others), 298-9, 304

Cobden, Richard, and Separation, 217, 283, 284, 285

Coburg, Population (1846), 25; Social conditions and prices at (1845), 27-8

Colborne, Sir John, Acting Governor, and the Anglican Church, 43; French risings quelled by, 5, 57, 214; on the French and the Union, 83

Colleges and Universities, Canadian, 35-8, 136

Colonial Administration, Russell's speech on, 1850, 263

Autonomy (see also Autonomy, Canadian), MacDonald's views on, 344

Connexion with the Empire, Continuance of, various views on (see also Annexation, Separation, &c.), 2, 3, 277 et sqq., 323 et sqq.

Government, Conflicting views on, passim

Independence, Burke's view on, 2, 3

Parliaments, Defects of, 65-6, 289

Unity, Conditions adverse to, 24

Colonial Office, the, Elgin's influence on, 222-5; Permanent officials of, Buller on, 234-5, 236

Colonial Advocate, The, 38

Colonial Gazette, on Poulett Thomson, 77-8

Colonial Policy, by Earl Grey, Canada chapter in, inspired by Elgin, 275

Colonies, Responsible Government for, Buller's famous pamphlet, 234-5 &n., 236, 240

Colonies, Secretaries of State for, see also under Names

Lord J. Russell, 1839

Lord Stanley, 1841

Gladstone, 1846

Earl Grey, 1846

Sir J. Pakington, 1852

Duke of Newcastle, 1852

Sir George Gray, 1854

Views on, of British Politicians, 2, 3, 217, 230 et sqq., 255-8, 262, 264, 283, 284, 285, 290, 292 et alibi

Colonists, Buller's views on, 242; Cartwright's opinion of, 60

Colonization, The Art of, by Wakefield, 239

Commercial crisis, Canadian, in 1849, Elgin on, 331

Marine, as a pillar of Empire, 262

Relations, Peel on, 254

Treaty, see Reciprocity Treaty

Compromise, Bagot's views on, and Stanley's, 139-40

Confederation of British North American Colonies, various Schemes for, 196-7; the result of Autonomy, 305; Difficulties connected with, 279-80, 312; Russell's aim in furthering, 265; Scheme of Brown and Macdonald for, 302 et sqq., 312-14, 341, 342

"Connexion," the Basis of, sentimental rather than practical, 239; Effect on, of Autonomy, 323 et sqq.

Conservative Party, Canadian (see also Family Compact, & Tory Party), in 1841, 105; Loyalty of, 339

Conservatism of the French Canadians, 15, 17, 32, 41

United Empire Loyalists, 18

Constitutional Act of 1791, and the Clergy Reserve question, 48-9

Constitutional Question in Canada, three allied problems forming, Elgin's mode of dealing with, 201 et sqq.

Convent Education of Women, 16, 31

Copyright prohibition, effect on Reading habits, 39 &n., 40

Corduroy Roads, 12

Cornwall, Strachan's School at, 35

Corruption, political, in Canada, 315 et sqq.; Brown's salutary counteraction of, 341

County Courts, Canadian, new system set up, 106

Crime, in early days, 29 &n.2, 30

Crown, the, and the Case of a Governor-General, compared by Stanley, 152-3

Crown Colony administration, period of, 4-5


D

Dalhousie, Earl of, Governor-General, 189-90

Daly, Sir Dominick, the "perpetual secretary," 168, 176, 177

Darwin, and Bright & Cobden, parallel between, 284

Davidson, John, retirement of, 150

Day, Charles Dewey, 113

Debate in House of Commons on Canadian affairs (1844), 182

Defence of Canada (see also Militia Bill), British views on, 254, 272, 287 et sqq.

Democracy, attitude to, of the Family Compact, 60 et sqq.

Democratic Government in Canada, established by Elgin, 190

Institutions, Elements of Success in, 320

Derby, Earl of (see for earlier references, Stanley, Lord), 252

Derbyites, and Separation, 290

Despatches of Elgin and later Governors, 208-9, 249, 325

Diplomacy, and Separation, 287 War, and Land as matters for Imperial Control, in Wakefield's view, 240

District Councils for French Canada set up, 98, 118, 119

Draper, Hon. H. W., Attorney-General, leader of Ministerialists, 105, 111 &n., 113, 150, 177; Metcalfe on, 184; Resignation of, 194

on the Political crisis of 1842, 134-5

Disraeli, Benjamin (Earl of Beaconsfield), Imperialism of, misgivings in, 255-8, 292

District Council Bill (Canadian), passed, 106, 118

Doctrinaire, the, in Practical Politics, position of Metcalfe as illustrating, 185,

Domestic Colonial affairs, Imperial Intervention in, views of Russell, and of Grey, 271-2, 274

Dorchester, Earl of, and Colonial affairs, 4; and the French Canadians, 13

Dorion, A. A., see Brown-Dorion ministry

"Double majority," evolution of, 307-8

"Double Shuffle" episode, 318-9

Dougalls, the, and the Montreal Witness, 38-9

Drunkenness, among Whites and Indians, 30; among Members of Parliament, 320

Durham, Earl of, Governor-General, 6, 14, 71, 76, 190, 191, 251; Canadian views on, 190; and the Change in British views on Canadian affairs, 237; and the Destruction of French Nationalism, 57, 59, 83, 211, 311-2; and Immigration, 97; Responsible Colonial government as advocated by, 61, 149, 166, 244-5; non-Separationist views, 281; Visit of, to Canada, 31

on the Catholic clergy of Lower Canada, 41-2; on Local Government, 94

Durham's Report, 4 n., 5 n., 6, 57; Effects of, 249; Fallacy in, 260-1; Illusions on, dispelled, 243-4; Imperial note of, 246-7


E

Economics, and Separation, 220, 285-6, 330-1

Education, French-Canadian, 14, 15, 16

by Newspaper, 38-9

School and College, 31 et sqq., 136

of Scottish immigrants, 23

Ekfried, Early Education at, 33

Elgin, Countess of, 190

Elgin, Earl of, Governor-Generalship of, 7, 56, 70, 187 et sqq.

Character and Politics of, 188 et sqq., 190, 191, 209, 221, 225 et sqq., 256, 297; Chief result of his rule, 190, 268-71; Despatches of, 325, Influence of, on Autonomy movement, 188 et sqq., 228-9, and on Grey's Colonial policy, 275; Insult to, 204, 208-9, 227, 320, Scottish loyal address on, 328-9; and Irish disaffection, 200, 337; Non-Separationist views of, 278, 281; Relations with French Canada, 193, 195-6, 198, 210 et sqq., 222

Later career of, 188-9, 191

on Baldwin, 110, 339; on British Press methods, 232; on Canadian attitude to Free Trade, 220, 285-6; on Canadian Party Politics, 56, 195, 293, 295; on the elections of 1844, 181; on French Canadian Nationalism, 196, and Loyalty (1850), 305-6; on Metcalfe's policy, 192, 202; on Montreal, its inhabitants and Annexation views at (1849), 334; on Moral influence of Governors, 324; on Sydenham's attitude to Autonomy, 123-4; on True and False Imperialism, 224-5

Emigration and its horrors, 20-1; Wakefield's system of, 238

English Canadians, loyalty of, 338

English character of Colonists, Disraeli's views on, 257-8

English tone in Canadian Society (circ. 1846), 26-7

Episodes in a Life of Adventure, by Oliphant, referred to, 225

Examiner, The, Politics of, 64

Executive Council, British and Canadian views on, 71 et sqq.

Sydenham's, inherited by Bagot, 131; Stanley's advice on, 129, 136, 143, 144-5, actual Composition of, 144; La Fontaine's demands and the upshot, 149 et sqq.; Stanley's sarcasm, 152-3

Executive Responsibility, as conceived by Durham, 244-5