WeRead Powered by ReaderPub
The dialogues of Plato in five volumes, Vol. 2 (of 5) cover

The dialogues of Plato in five volumes, Vol. 2 (of 5)

Chapter 45: INTRODUCTION.
Open in WeRead

Explore more books like this:

About This Book

A collection of Socratic dialogues that investigates virtue, knowledge, piety, justice, the soul, rhetoric, and political education through conversational enquiry. Several pieces question whether virtue can be taught and whether moral truth is recollected or learned, while others present a legal defense, a discussion of obedience to law after conviction, and an extended debate contrasting persuasive speech with genuine justice. Shorter works test definitions and the value of wealth, and two dialogues examine erotic desire and civic self-knowledge. The dialogical method repeatedly exposes assumptions, elicits precise definitions, and follows ethical and metaphysical implications across varied social settings.

ERYXIAS.

INTRODUCTION.

Much cannot be said in praise of the style or conception of the Eryxias. It is frequently obscure; like the exercise of a student, it is full of small imitations of Plato:—Phaeax returning from an expedition to Sicily (cp. Socrates in the Charmides from the army at Potidaea), the figure of the game at draughts, 395 B, borrowed from Rep. vi. 487, etc. It has also in many passages the ring of sophistry. On the other hand, the rather unhandsome treatment which is exhibited towards Prodicus is quite unlike the urbanity of Plato.

Yet there are some points in the argument which are deserving of attention. (1) That wealth depends upon the need of it or demand for it, is the first anticipation in an abstract form of one of the great principles of modern political economy, and the nearest approach to it to be found in an ancient writer. (2) The resolution of wealth into its simplest implements going on to infinity is a subtle and refined thought. (3) That wealth is relative to circumstances is a sound conception. (4) That the arts and sciences which receive payment are likewise to be comprehended under the notion of wealth, also touches a question of modern political economy. (5) The distinction of post hoc and propter hoc, often lost sight of in modern as well as in ancient times. These metaphysical conceptions and distinctions show considerable power of thought in the writer, whatever we may think of his merits as an imitator of Plato.