| BOOK III. |
| OF MONEY AND COIN. |
| |
| PART I. |
| |
| The principles of money deduced, and applied to the coin of Great Britain. |
| |
| Introduction, |
523 |
| |
| Chap. I. Of money of accompt, |
526 |
| |
What money is |
—— |
| |
Definitions |
—— |
| |
Money a scale for measuring value, |
—— |
| |
Principles which determine the value of things |
527 |
| |
Prices not regulated by the quantity of money, |
—— |
| |
But by the relative proportion between commodities and the wants of mankind, |
528 |
| |
Necessity of distinguishing between money and price, |
529 |
| |
Money of accompt what, and how contrived, |
—— |
| |
Examples of it, |
531 |
| |
Bank money, |
—— |
| |
Angola money, |
—— |
| |
| Chap. II. Of artificial or material money, |
—— |
| |
Usefulness of the precious metals for the making money, |
532 |
| |
Adjusting a standard, what? |
533 |
| |
Debasing and raising a standard, what? |
534 |
| |
The alteration of a standard, how to be discovered? |
—— |
| |
Of alloy, |
—— |
| |
| Chap. III. Incapacities of the metals to perform the office of an invariable measure of value, |
535 |
| |
| |
1. They vary in their relative value to one another, |
—— |
| |
All measures ought to be invariable, |
—— |
| |
Consequences when they vary, |
536 |
| |
Defects of a silver standard, |
537 |
| |
Arguments in favour of it, |
—— |
| |
Answers to these arguments, |
538 |
| |
Usefulness of an universal measure, |
539 |
| |
They have two values, one as coin, and one as metals, |
540 |
| |
Smaller inconveniences attending material money, |
—— |
| |
It wears in circulation, |
—— |
| |
It is inaccurately coined, |
541 |
| |
The coinage adds to its value, without adding to its weight, |
—— |
| |
The value of it may be arbitrarily changed, |
—— |
| |
Trade profits of the smallest defects in the coin, |
—— |
| |
| Chap. IV. Methods which may be proposed for lessening the several inconveniences to which material money is liable, |
542 |
| |
Use of theory in political matters, |
—— |
| |
Five remedies against the effects of the variation between the value of the metals, |
—— |
| |
Remedies against the other inconveniences, |
544 |
| |
Against the wearing of the coin, |
—— |
| |
Against inaccuracy of coinage, |
—— |
| |
Against the expence of coinage, |
—— |
| |
Against arbitrary changes in the value of coin, |
545 |
| |
| Chap. V. Variations to which the value of the money-unit is exposed from every disorder in the coin, |
—— |
| |
How the market price of the metals is made to vary, |
—— |
| |
The variation ought to be referred to the rising metal, and never to the sinking, |
546 |
| |
How the money-unit of accompt is made to vary in its value from the variation of the metals, |
547 |
| |
Consequences of this, |
—— |
| |
The true unit is the mean proportional between the value of the metals, |
—— |
| |
The unit to be attached to the mean proportion upon a new coinage, not after the metals have varied, |
548 |
| |
It is better to affix the unit to one, than to both metals, |
549 |
| |
Variation to which the money-unit is exposed from the wearing of the coin, |
—— |
| |
Variations to which the money-unit is exposed, from the inaccuracy in the fabrication of the money, |
550 |
| |
Variation to which the money-unit is exposed from the imposition of coinage, |
551 |
| |
When coinage is imposed, bullion must be cheaper than coin, |
—— |
| |
Exception from this rule, |
552 |
| |
Variation to which the money-unit is exposed by the arbitrary operations of Princes in raising and debasing the coin, |
—— |
| |
| Chap. VI. How the variations in the intrinsic value of the unit of money must affect all the domestic interests of a nation, |
553 |
| |
How this variation affects the interests of debtors and creditors, |
—— |
| |
A mistake of Mr. Locke, |
555 |
| |
When the value of the unit is diminished, creditors lose; when it is augmented, debtors lose, |
556 |
| |
| Chap. VII. Of the disorder in the British coin, so far as it occasions the melting down or the exporting of the specie, |
558 |
| |
Defects in the British coin, |
—— |
| |
Of the standard of the English coin and money-unit, |
—— |
| |
A pound sterling by statute contains 1718.7 grains troy fine silver, |
559 |
| |
The guinea 118.644 grains fine gold, |
—— |
| |
Coinage in England free, |
—— |
| |
The standard not attached to the gold coin till the year 1728, |
560 |
| |
Consequences of this regulation to debase the standard, |
—— |
| |
That debtors will not pay in silver but in gold, |
—— |
| |
That some people consider coin as money of accompt, |
561 |
| |
Others consider it as a metal, |
—— |
| |
Operations of money-jobbers, when the coin deviates from the market proportion of the metals, or from the legal weight, |
562 |
| |
They melt down when the metals in it are wrong proportioned, |
—— |
| |
And when the coin is of unequal weight, |
—— |
| |
Why silver bullion is dearer than coin, |
—— |
| |
Because that species has risen in the market price as bullion, and not as coin, |
563 |
| |
What regulates the price of bullion? |
564 |
| |
1. The intrinsic value of the currency, |
—— |
| |
2. A demand for exporting bullion, |
565 |
| |
3. Or for making of plate, |
—— |
| |
Exchange raises, and the mint price brings down bullion, |
—— |
| |
Continuation of the operations of money-jobbers: their rule for melting the coin, |
566 |
| |
The price in guineas equal to the price of shillings of 65 in the pound troy, |
—— |
| |
When guineas may be melted down with profit, |
—— |
| |
Silver is exported preferably to gold, |
567 |
| |
This hurtful, when done by foreigners, |
—— |
| |
| Chap. VIII. Of the disorder in the British coin, so far as it affects the value of the pound sterling currency, |
568 |
| |
Two legal pounds sterling in England, |
—— |
| |
And several others, in consequence of the wearing of the coin, |
569 |
| |
Why any silver coin remains in England, |
—— |
| |
Value of a pound sterling current determined by the operations of trade, |
—— |
| |
To the mean value of all the currencies, |
570 |
| |
Exchange a good measure for the value of a pound sterling, |
—— |
| |
The use of paper money not hurtful in debasing the standard, |
571 |
| |
The pound sterling not regulated by statute, but by the mean value of the current money, |
—— |
| |
Why exchange appears so commonly against England, |
—— |
| |
How the market price of bullion shews the value of the pound sterling, |
—— |
| |
Shillings at present weigh no more than 1⁄65 of a pound troy, |
572 |
| |
And are worn 4.29 troy grains lighter than their standard weight, |
—— |
| |
A pound sterling worth, at present, no more than 1638 grains troy fine silver, according to the price of bullion, |
573 |
| |
And according to the course of exchange, |
—— |
| |
Shillings coined at 65 in the pound troy, would be in proportion with the gold, |
574 |
| |
Which shews that the standard has been debased, |
—— |
| |
And that the preserving it where it is, is no new debasement, |
—— |
| |
Proof that the standard has been debased by law, |
575 |
| |
And is at present reduced to the value of the gold, |
—— |
| |
| Chap. IX. Historical account of the variations of the British coin, |
576 |
| |
Purport of this treatise not to dictate, but to inquire, |
—— |
| |
How the disorder in the coin may be remedied without inconveniences, |
—— |
| |
By making the nation itself choose the remedy, |
577 |
| |
If the present standard is departed from, every other that might be pitched on is arbitrary, |
—— |
| |
People imagine the present standard is the same with that of Queen Elizabeth, |
578 |
| |
Debasements of the standard during the reformation, |
—— |
| |
Raised by Edward VI. |
—— |
| |
Debased by Elizabeth, |
—— |
| |
Supported by her successors, |
—— |
| |
Until it was debased by the clipping, after the revolution, |
579 |
| |
Lowndes’s scheme refuted by Locke: the standard raised to that of Elizabeth, and the consequences of that measure, |
580 |
| |
Silver has been rising from the beginning of this century, |
—— |
| |
The English standard has been debased by law, since 1726, |
—— |
| |
The trading interest chiefly to be blamed for this neglect, |
581 |
| |
Debasing the standard chiefly affects permanent contracts, |
—— |
| |
And prevents prices from rising as they should do, |
—— |
| |
| Chap. X. Of the disorder of the British coin, so far as it affects the circulation of gold and silver coin, and of the consequences of reducing guineas to twenty shillings, |
582 |
| |
Why silver coin is so scarce, |
583 |
| |
Consequences of fixing the guineas at 20 shillings, with regard to circulation, |
—— |
| |
Will make coin disappear altogether, |
584 |
| |
How light shillings are bought by weight, |
—— |
| |
Consequences as to the circulation with merchants and bankers, |
585 |
| |
That guineas would still pass current for 21 shillings, |
—— |
| |
That the standard would be affixed to the light silver, as it was in the year 1695, |
—— |
| |
That merchants would gain by it, |
586 |
| |
Debtors would be ruined, |
—— |
| |
Consequences as to the bank, |
—— |
| |
Reducing guineas to 20 shillings is the same as making them a commodity, |
587 |
| |
| Chap. XI. Method of restoring the money-unit to the standard of Elizabeth, and the consequences of that revolution, |
—— |
| |
How to fix the pound sterling at the standard of Queen Elizabeth, |
—— |
| |
The consequences of this reformation will be to raise the standard 5 per cent. |
588 |
| |
Every interest in a nation equally intitled to protection, |
589 |
| |
Those who suffer by the debasement of the standard, |
—— |
| |
Ought only to benefit by the restitution, |
590 |
| |
And not the whole class of creditors, |
—— |
| |
Whose claim ought to be liable to a conversion, |
591 |
| |
According to justice and impartiality, |
—— |
| |
| Chap. XII. Objections stated against the principles laid down in this inquiry, and answers to them, |
592 |
| |
That a pound will always be considered as a pound, |
593 |
| |
That the standard is not debased at present, being fixed to the statute, not to the coin, |
—— |
| |
That the pound sterling is virtually worth 1718.7 grains fine silver, |
—— |
| |
That these principles imply a progressive debasement of the standard every new coinage, |
594 |
| |
That the same argument holds for debasing the standard measures of weights, capacity, &c. |
—— |
| |
That the wearing of the coin falls on them who possess it at the crying down, but does not debase the standard, |
—— |
| |
That inland dealings, not the price of bullion, or course of exchange, regulate the standard, |
—— |
| |
That public currency supports the value of the coin, |
—— |
| |
That this scheme is the same with that of Lowndes, |
—— |
| |
Answers to these objections, |
595 |
| |
That a pound will be considered at its worth by all debtors, and by those who buy, |
—— |
| |
If the standard was affixed to the statute, people would be obliged to pay by weight, |
—— |
| |
No body can be obliged to pay 1718.7 grains fine silver for a pound sterling, |
596 |
| |
That it is not the regulation of the mint, but the disorder of the coin which must debase the standard, |
—— |
| |
That people are obliged to measure by the standard weight, but are not obliged to pay by the standard pound, |
597 |
| |
That the loss upon light money when called in, does not fall upon the possessors, |
—— |
| |
That inland dealings cannot support the standard where there are money-jobbers or foreign commerce, |
599 |
| |
That public currency supports the authority of the coin, not the value of the pound sterling, |
601 |
| |
That the scheme is similar, though not the same with that of Lowndes, |
602 |
| |
Lowndes reasoned upon wrong principles, |
—— |
| |
Locke attended to supporting the standard, without attending to the consequences, |
—— |
| |
Political circumstances are greatly changed, |
604 |
| |
Reconciliation of the two opinions, |
606 |
| |
The question in dispute is not understood, |
607 |
| |
The true characteristic of a change upon the standard is not attended to, |
—— |
| |
Principles will not operate their effects without the assistance of the state, |
608 |
| |
When people understand one another, they soon agree, |
—— |
| |
Permanent contracts are confounded with sale in the dispute, |
609 |
| |
The interest of creditors is always the predominant, and determines the opinion of a nation, |
611 |
| |
Application of principles to the operation the Dutch have lately made upon their coin, |
612 |
| |
All decisions in political questions depend upon circumstances, |
613 |
| |
| Chap. XIII. In what sense the standard may be said to have been debased by law; and in what sense it may be said to have suffered a gradual debasement by the operation of political causes, |
614 |
| |
These proportions appear contradictory, |
—— |
| |
Debased by law, when affixed to the gold, |
615 |
| |
Effects which the changing the proportion of the metals has upon melting the coin, and regulating payments, |
—— |
| |
Payments made by bankers regulate all others, |
—— |
| |
The standard gradually debased by the rising of the silver, |
616 |
| |
The proportion of the metals in 1728, supposed to have been as 15.21 is to 1., |
—— |
| |
By what progression the silver standard has been debased, |
—— |
| |
The standard of Elizabeth, for the pound sterling, was 1718.7 grains silver, and 157.6 ditto gold, both fine, |
617 |
| |
The gold standard of her pound worth, at present, 2285.5 grains fine silver, |
—— |
| |
The variation of the metals has produced three different standards of Elizabeth, |
—— |
| |
One worth £ 1 0 11⅜ present currency, |
618 |
| |
Another worth £ 1 7 10⅞ ditto, |
—— |
| |
And a third worth £ 1 4 5⅛ ditto, |
—— |
| |
The last is the true standard of Elizabeth for the pound sterling, and worth at present 2002 grains fine silver, and 138 ditto gold, |
—— |
| |
But may vary at every moment, |
619 |
| |
Gold rose during the whole 17th century, |
—— |
| |
And silver has risen since the beginning of this century, |
—— |
| |
Some positions recapitulated, |
620 |
| |
| Chap. XIV. Circumstances to be attended to in a new regulation of the British coin, |
621 |
| |
The adopting of the standard of Elizabeth, has an air of justice, |
—— |
| |
Advantages of that of Mary I., |
—— |
| |
Conversions necessary in every case, |
622 |
| |
Every interest within the state to be examined, |
—— |
| |
Landed interest examined, |
—— |
| |
Interest of the public creditors examined, |
625 |
| |
Interest of trade examined, |
628 |
| |
Interest of buyers and sellers examined, |
—— |
| |
Interest of the bank examined, |
629 |
| |
Inconveniences attending all innovations, |
632 |
| |
Argument for preserving the standard at the present value, |
—— |
| |
That every change must either hurt the bank, or the public creditors, |
—— |
| |
A more easy method of making a change upon the standard, |
633 |
| |
| Chap. XV. Regulations which the principles of this inquiry point out as expedient to be made, by a new statute for regulating the British coin, |
634 |
| |
1. Regulation as to the standard, |
—— |
| |
2. As to the weight, |
—— |
| |
3. Mint price, |
—— |
| |
4. Denominations, |
635 |
| |
5. Marking the weight on the coins, |
—— |
| |
6. Liberty to stipulate payment in gold or silver, |
—— |
| |
7. Creditors may demand payment, half in gold, and half in silver, |
—— |
| |
8. Regulations as to sale, |
—— |
| |
9. Ditto as to payments to and from banks, &c., |
—— |
| |
10. All coin to be of full weight, when paid away, |
—— |
| |
11. Liberty to melt or export coin, but death to clip or wash, |
—— |
| |
12. Rule for changing the mint price of the metals, |
636 |
| |
13. When to change the mint price, |
—— |
| |
14. Rule for changing the denomination of the coins, |
—— |
| |
15. How contracts are to be acquitted, after a change of the denomination has taken place, |
—— |
| |
16. The weight of the several coins never to be changed, except upon a general recoinage of one denomination at least, |
638 |
| |
How these regulations will preserve the same value to the pound sterling at all times, and how fractions in the denomination of coin may be avoided, |
—— |
| |
17. Small coins to be current only for 20 years, and large coins for 40 years, or more, |
639 |
| |
18. All foreign coins to pass for bullion only, |
—— |
| |
Consequences of these regulations, |
—— |