[C] During a visit to Rio de Janeiro in February 1963, Dr. Menzel discussed this case with some of Brazil’s leading astronomers; they concurred in the view that the Trindade saucer was a hoax.

The final paragraph from a United States Intelligence report provides perhaps the most appropriate comment on the affair:

“It is the reporting officer’s private opinion that a flying saucer sighting would be unlikely at the very barren island of Trindade, since everyone knows that Martians are extremely comfort-loving creatures.”

Project Ozma

Astronomers have found no evidence suggesting that intelligent life exists on any of earth’s sister planets. Most scientists would agree, however, that life of some kind probably does exist in other parts of our galaxy and in other galaxies. Even if this probability were certainty and space travel were possible over the vast distances we measure in light years, the chance that earthman and alien will ever establish physical contact remains infinitesimally small. An explorer (whether from earth or from a planet of another sun) would have to begin by locating, among the millions of stars in the heavens, a particular star that had a family of life-bearing planets. If he were able to identify one of these needles in the cosmic haystack, he would next have to find out which of the planets supported living, intelligent organisms. If he could find the planet and set down his spaceship, the explorer would then have to try to identify and to communicate with creatures that might be unimaginably strange—so strange that he would not recognize them as either living or intelligent.

At present, only light waves and radio waves can bridge the immensities of space. Physical travel to other star systems is not now and may never be possible. Nevertheless, men are making attempts to find out whether other intelligent beings do exist outside the solar system and, if so, where. The earliest effort, known as Project Ozma, started a few years ago at the National Radio Astronomy Observatory at Green Bank, West Virginia. As the first step in a systematic search, the astronomers began to listen for possible radio signals from the neighborhood of certain stars. Tau Ceti, Epsilon Eridani, and 61 Cygni were chosen as the first targets because they lie within range of our radio telescopes—ten to eleven light years distant—and because they resemble our own sun in age and type and therefore might have planetary systems not unlike our own. So far, the radio telescopes have detected no phenomena that might be interpreted as artificial signals.

The problems involved are incredibly difficult. A background of radio noise—“swishes,” “whistles,” “tweeks”—comes in constantly from the universe at large. Deliberate signals, if they occurred, would be hard to distinguish from the random noise. Even if signals came in and were detected, they might still be indecipherable just as the written records of some early civilizations on our own planet remain a mystery. Egyptian hieroglyphs were meaningless pictures for millennia until the Rosetta stone provided the key, less than 200 years ago. The many pages of text and pictures left by the Mayan Indians cannot yet be read, except for some dates and a few astronomical symbols. Hundreds of inscriptions exist in the Etruscan language, written in an alphabet that resembles the familiar Greek, but scholars have deciphered only a few words.

If we are not able to interpret the records devised and set down by human beings like ourselves, we will not easily understand signals that might possibly be broadcast by aliens from the planets of other suns.

[X-1] Wiener, J. S. The Piltdown Forgery. London: Oxford Univ. Press, 1955.

[X-2] MacDougall, C. D. Hoaxes. New York: Ace Books, 1958.

[X-3] Fry, D. W. The White Sands Incident. Los Angeles: New Age Publ. Co., 1954.

[X-4] Redondo Beach (Calif.) Daily Breeze, September 25, 1953.

[X-5] Bethurum, T. Aboard a Flying Saucer. Los Angeles: De Vorss & Co., 1954.

[X-6] Van Tassel, G. W. I Rode a Flying Saucer. Los Angeles: New Age Publ. Co., 1952.

[X-7] Cahn, J. P. “Flying Saucers and the Mysterious Little Men,” True magazine (September 1952).

[X-8] Menger, H. From Outer Space To You. Clarksburg, West Virginia: Saucerian Publications, 1959.

[X-9] Peterborough (N.H.) Transcript, Oct. 30, 1958.

[X-10] Leslie, D., and Adamski, G. Flying Saucers Have Landed. New York: British Book Centre, 1953.

[X-11] Adamski, G. Inside the Space Ships. Abelard-Schuman, 1955.

[X-12] —— Flying Saucers, Farewell. Abelard-Schuman, 1961.

[X-13UFO Investigator (June 1959).

[X-14] Michel, A. The Truth about Flying Saucers. New York: Criterion Books, 1956.

[X-15] “Have We Visitors from Outer Space?” Life magazine (April 4, 1952).

[X-16] Rio de Janeiro: O Cruzeiro, May 17, 1952.

[X-17] Civilian Saucer Investigations Quarterly Bulletin (September 1952).

[X-18] Air Force Files.

[X-19UFO Critical Bulletin (March-April 1958).

[X-20] Fontes, O. T. “The Brazilian Navy UFO Sighting at the Island of Trindade,” Flying Saucers (February 1961), p. 27 ff.

[X-21] Maney, C. A., and Hall, R. The Challenge of Unidentified Flying Objects. Washington, D.C., 1961.

[X-22] Rio de Janeiro: O Cruzeiro, March 8, 1958.