It was late in the afternoon when Nan came home, accompanied by a man from the Cañonville livery-stable. Hashknife met her and they walked from the buggy to the house. She did not mention the inquests until Sleepy and Rex met them in the living-room, and the four of them sat down together.

‘They asked the sheriff to arrest Walter for shooting Ben Leach,’ she said bravely. ‘They say, because he took Ben’s horse and gun, it don’t look like self-defense.[’]

‘But they say Dad murdered Peter Morgan.’

‘Who testified?’ asked Hashknife.

‘Some boys of the 6X6 testified that Peter Morgan’s body came on, roped to the saddle of his horse. That was all the testimony, except what was said about the fight Dad had with Peter Morgan in Mesa City, and that Dad swore he’d kill them if they came here.’

‘And that’s all the evidence they needed to name yore dad as the murderer?’

‘That was all. They didn’t ask me to testify. Lem told them about Walter coming home from Mesa City drunk, and what he said about “fixing” one of the 6X6 outfit. Lem tried to give his opinion of Ben Leach following Walter, but the coroner wouldn’t let him talk, and they almost had a fight.’

‘And will the sheriff be obliged to capture your father and brother now?’ asked Rex.

Nan nodded wearily. ‘I guess he will. Oh, I don’t know what to do. We haven’t any money to hire lawyers; nothing to fight with.’

‘The court will appoint a lawyer to defend them,’ said Hashknife.

‘To represent them,’ corrected Nan quickly. ‘But of what value will he be to us? It is merely a matter of form. Oh, I know enough about the law to know what it will mean. A cow-town jury, sitting in judgment on a nester.’

‘Well,’ said the optimistic Sleepy, ‘they ain’t got ’em in jail yet, Nan.’

‘But they will have. Dad and Walter are not far away from here.’

‘I’d like to have a talk with ’em before the sheriff gets his hands on ’em,’ said Hashknife.

‘What for?’ asked Nan.

‘Oh, just to talk about things. I’d like to get their version of things ahead of the rest.’

Later that day Hashknife and Sleepy talked things over from the top-pole of the corral fence.

‘I tell yuh, it’s no puzzle,’ declared Sleepy. ‘Old man Lane killed Pete Morgan, jist as sure as a Californian will lie about his climate. Of course, Pete had no business bein’ here. He’d been warned to stay away—and didn’t. If me and you was on a jury, we’d turn him loose—because we don’t hate a nester.[’]

‘Likewise, this here Ben Leach got his needin’s. Hunted for trouble, and found it. Self-defense of course; but yuh never can convince these natives that Lane didn’t bushwhack Leach. Of course, Lane made a mistake in takin’ the horse and gun, but he was drunk and mad.’

It was a long speech for Sleepy to make. Hashknife lifted his brows in mock astonishment.

‘Yore gettin’ kinda technical, ain’t yuh, Sleepy?’

‘Well,’ confessed Sleepy, ‘that’s the way she looks to me. Whatsa use of stayin’ around here any longer? We’ve got to land a couple of jobs for the winter, ain’t we?’

‘Did we ever quit before the last dog was hung?’

Sleepy shook his head gloomily. They had been together for quite a number of years, these two drifting cowboys. Their trails had led from the wide lands of Alberta to the Mexican border, and no matter where they were there was always a hill just beyond which beckoned them on.

Sleepy had been christened David in the little Idaho town where he was born, but it had been soon changed to his present cognomen because of the fact that, like a weasel, he seemed to sleep with both eyes open.

He and Henry Hartley had met on the old ranch which gave Henry the name of Hashknife, and together these two cowboys of the itching feet struck out for themselves. The ranges were wide and there was plenty of demand for the services of top-hand cowboys, but they did not stay long in any one place.

Fate had given Hashknife an analytical mind. In a different environment he might have been a famous detective instead of a drifting cowboy, a Nemesis of range crooks, where, in most cases, the six-shooter superseded the court of law.

It seemed as though Fate continually threw them into troubled places, no matter which way they traveled, until even Sleepy, prone to argument, admitted that there was little use trying to dodge the issue. Sleepy analyzed nothing. He was content to follow the lengthy Hashknife, no matter where the trail led, and to be ready for trouble at the finish.

Their remuneration had been small. In fact, they might better have been working at forty dollars a month, as far as the financial end of their partnership was concerned. Two horses, riding rigs, clothes, guns, and a few dollars were all they ever had.

‘Yuh can’t take anythin’ with yuh,’ Hashknife had often said when Sleepy remarked about their financial returns.

‘The farther we go, the less chance we have of livin’ to a ripe old age; so what good is the money? I’d rather give while I’m alive to see the happiness it brings. And if we had a lot of money, we wouldn’t know what in hell to spend it for.’

Hashknife debated over Sleepy’s resume of the case. It was the reasonable decision, and was probably the decision of everybody who knew of the case; but Hashknife withheld his opinion because he refused to agree with the masses. To Sleepy, the case was closed; but to Hashknife, it was just beginning to open.

‘They tell me that Paul Lane is a salty old jigger,’ said Sleepy thoughtfully. ‘It would be like him to kill a man and send him home on his own horse. I wish I knew what Pete Morgan was doin’ over here that night?’

‘Evidently tryin’ to “get” old man Lane, Sleepy.’

‘Why?’

‘There yuh are. He came alone. Why?’

‘Don’t ask me—I’m no mind-reader.’

‘And still yuh think there’s nothin’ to the case?’

‘I wasn’t figurin’ any reasons for the killin’.’

‘There’s got to be a reason for the killin’, Sleepy. I want to know why Pete Morgan got up long before daylight, saddled his horse, and came over here—if he did come here. Of course, we’ve got no proof that he did except that the sheriff found his gun in the corral.’

‘Guns don’t fly.’

‘This ’n didn’t have any wings. Sleepy, didja ever see a girl with more nerve than Nan Lane? By golly, she’s a dinger. Wants to cry, but won’t. It’s a hell of a position for her to be in, don’tcha know it. She’s up there in the kitchen cookin’ up a meal for us, when down in her heart she wants to lie down and cry her eyes out. If I ever get married, I hope I get her kind.’

‘One that won’t cry, Hashknife?’

‘Sure.’

‘Yuh never will, cowboy. Mebby she won’t cry from ordinary causes, but jist let you put on a boiled collar and a white shirt, and she’ll cry.’

‘Is it that bad?’ sadly.

‘Worse than that, Hashknife. Yuh look jist like a half-broke Apaloosie lookin’ over a whitewashed fence.’

‘I might get one with a sense of humor, Sleepy.’

‘She’d have to have, cowboy.’

Rex was wandering around the yard, like a lost pup, and finally joined them at the corral.

‘I wish I knew what to do,’ he said sadly. ‘Nan is up there in the kitchen, crying. I—I tried to solace her, but it didn’t seem to do much good. She’s afraid they are going to hang her father, you know. Perhaps I handled the situation badly when I told her we’d both be orphans if such a thing happened. And then I asked her to marry me.’

‘You damn fool!’ exploded Sleepy. ‘That ain’t no time to propose to a girl.’

‘I didn’t know. You see, I—I never proposed before.’

‘There’s a hell of a lot of things you don’t know.’

‘There’s a hell of a lot of things I want to learn,’ retorted Rex heatedly.

‘That’s a lot better,’ grinned Hashknife. ‘Use a little profanity and less dictionary. Correct English is great; but out here they think you’re crazy. You’ll forget how to talk it soon enough. As far as you marryin’ Nan Lane—I’d forget it, Morgan.’

‘What in hell would you support a wife on?’ asked Sleepy.

‘I’m sure I don’t know.’

‘Well, you’re honest,’ grinned Hashknife. ‘I reckon you’re a good kid, Morgan. You mean well enough. Now, forget the marriage stuff for a while.’

‘The sheriff wants to marry her.’

‘Fine. Lem’s a good man; got a good job.’

‘But I don’t think she loves him.’

‘No? Does she love you?’

‘I—I never asked her.’

‘A-a-aw, hell!’ snorted Sleepy. ‘Let’s go and help her cook supper instead of talking about her feelin’s.’

It was after supper that night when Paul Lane came home. Rex was washing the dishes and Hashknife was wiping them, much against the wishes of Nan.

‘It’s the only thing I can do well,’ declared Rex.

‘I used to wash them for my mother.’

Nan was in her room and Sleepy was perched on the woodbox, smoking a cigarette, when Paul Lane stepped into the kitchen, gun in hand. Rex was the only one of the three who had ever seen him before.

He stopped just inside the door and looked at the men.

Rex stopped washing dishes and started to introduce the old man to Hashknife, but the old man stopped him.

‘Where’s Nan?’ he demanded.

‘Here, Dad.’

Nan had stepped from her room and now she crossed the kitchen to her father, who put one arm around her, but still kept his eyes on Hashknife and Sleepy.

‘Who are these men?’ he asked.

‘Friends, Dad; Mr. Hartley and Mr. Stevens. You have met Mr. Morgan before.’

‘Yeah, I’ve met him. I’ve been around here quite a while, lookin’ ’em over through the windows. I didn’t quite figure out who they were, but it didn’t look to me as though an officer of the law would be washin’ dishes. I had to come back, Nan. What’s the news? What has happened?’

With as few words as possible she told him everything that had happened since he left the house. She told him of the shooting of Noah Evans, the double inquest, and their verdicts. Hashknife watched the face of the old man during her recital, and decided that Paul Lane was a tough old ranger. He did not flinch at the verdict, but his blue eyes clouded a trifle.

He was not a big man, and age had sapped some of his vitality, but he was wiry, keen-eyed, and the hands that gripped the Winchester were muscular and steady.

‘Kinda looks as though they had the dead wood on me and the kid,’ he said bitterly. ‘We been hidin’ out in the brush, wonderin’ what was goin’ on; so I took a chance. We got a look at you fellers to-day and wondered who yuh might be. And we seen Nan come back in that buggy; so I decided that there had been an inquest at Cañonville.’

‘Why don’t the both of yuh sneak down and give up to the sheriff?’ asked Hashknife. ‘Looks like the only way out of it, Lane.’

‘And get hung for it, eh?’

‘Mebby not. The law won’t hang yuh without a trial.’

‘Meanin’ that the 6X6 outfit will, eh?’

‘Might be more than them in on the deal. There’s always a pack of wolves, yuh know.’

‘That’s right, Hartley. It shore makes it tough for Nan.’

‘And she’s been mighty game,’ said Hashknife quickly.

‘I—I’m not so game,’ choked Nan. ‘I don’t know what to do except to grin and bear it.’

They moved to the living-room, leaving Rex to finish the rest of the dishes, and sat down together. Hashknife wanted a chance to talk with Paul Lane, and this seemed like the opportune time, but before he could frame the opening question, the front door was flung violently open, and three rifles were covering them through the doorway.

There were Dave Morgan, Red Eller, Spike Cahill, and Ed Jones. There was only one thing to do; so the three men in the room threw up their hands. It took Spike Cahill about ten seconds to collect their guns, and then the captors relaxed.

‘I reckon that about ends the deal,’ growled Dave. ‘We been watchin’ for yuh, Lane. Knowed you’d have to come home, sooner or later.’

‘Well?’ said Lane coldly. ‘What now, Morgan?’

‘A lot depends. Get a rope, Spike.’

‘Just what’s the idea of a rope?’ asked Hashknife.

‘Keep yore nose out of it,’ growled Morgan. ‘I’d advise you two to high-tail out of this country. About the time we tell folks about findin’ yuh here, hobnobbin’ with a man wanted for murder, they might talk of more ropes.’

‘Oh, is this man wanted for murder?’

‘You know damn well he is! Wasn’t that girl at the inquest? Don’t try to be funny.’

Spike Cahill stepped in and flung out the coils of his rope, preparatory to roping Paul Lane.

‘What are you going to do?’ asked Nan. ‘Don’t put a rope on him. Dad will go to jail peacefully.’

‘Jail, eh?’ Spike laughed softly. ‘Yuh think he will? After we exhibit him in Mesa City? Guess ag’in, sister.’

‘You better put your hands up,’ said a voice at the doorway to the kitchen, and the captors jerked around to see Rex Morgan, holding the heavy, double-barrel shotgun against his shoulder, the twin muzzles covering them.

Dave Morgan’s hands jerked shoulder-high, and the other three were quick to follow his lead. Even a tenderfoot could score a bull’s-eye with a shotgun at fifteen feet.

‘Good, kid!’ exclaimed Hashknife, while Dave Morgan swore bitterly, as he watched Sleepy and Hashknife gather up all the guns.

‘You can take a rest with that gun now,’ laughed Hashknife.

‘Well, I’m glad,’ sighed Rex. ‘It is very heavy, and I was afraid some one might know it isn’t loaded.’

Hashknife backed against the wall, gun in hand, and laughed at the expressions on their faces when they realized that the shotgun was not loaded.

‘You can’t get away with this,’ gritted Morgan, facing Hashknife. ‘By God, we’ll show you how to tamper with things that don’t concern yuh. And we’ll make that half-witted, white-faced kid wish he’d kept out of it.’

‘I got away with it—my part of it,’ said Hashknife coldly. ‘I think that kid outsmarted yuh, and saved yuh from lynchin’ a man to-night. And as far as yuh doin’ anythin’ about it—cut yore wolf loose.’

‘We were goin’ to take him to jail,’ said Eller.

‘You’re a liar!’

Eller bristled angrily. ‘You wouldn’t call me that if I had a gun, you hatchet-faced bum.’

‘Step into the middle of the room,’ ordered Hashknife. ‘Right out there, away from the rest. Watch ’em, Sleepy.’ Hashknife stepped up to the bed, picked up a six-shooter and walked back to Eller, who stared at him foolishly. With a flip of his wrist, Hashknife dropped the gun into Eller’s empty holster, and stepped back about six feet and bolstered his own gun.

‘It’s an even break, Eller,’ he said coldly. ‘You’re a liar; a dirty, forked-tongued liar. You’ve got a gun in yore holster, and I’m talkin’ to yuh straight.’

Red Eller hesitated. Hashknife’s right hand hung limply at his side, swaying back and forth past his holster, but there was nothing about his pose or expression that would indicate a quick draw. For several seconds there was no sound except the breathing of people. Then:

‘Don’t do it, Red,’ whispered Spike. ‘It ain’t worth the chance.’

Eller licked his lips and shook his head.

‘I pass,’ he said softly. ‘Mebby I did lie, Hartley.’

Swiftly Hashknife stepped over and removed the gun.

‘What’s next?’ asked Morgan angrily.

‘Go home and try to mind yore own business.’

‘All right—but wait until we tell what happened.’

‘Suits me, gents. Vamoose!’

Hashknife and Sleepy followed them out to their horses, where the four men mounted quickly.

‘What about our guns?’ asked Morgan.

‘One of yuh come back in daylight and get ’em.’

‘Oh, all right. But you two better not be here.’

‘We will be, Morgan. Adios.’

Hashknife watched them ride away in the darkness, and went back into the house, where he found Lane shaking hands with Rex and thanking him for his timely aid with the shotgun.

‘Oh, it wasn’t anything,’ said Rex. ‘I just saw the gun in the corner, and thought I might frighten them with it.’

‘Well, yuh shore did,’ laughed Hashknife. ‘They know what a shotgun will do at short range, and they took no chances. Now,’ he turned to Lane, ‘What are you goin’ to do?’

‘I’m goin’ to see Walter and get him to go to Cañonville with me. We might as well give up and take a chance with the law. I didn’t realize until just now how safe a jail could be.’

‘Oh, I’m glad!’ exclaimed Nan. ‘Anything would be better than this suspense. But will Walter go with you, Dad?’

‘I think so. He is tired of dodging in the hills.’

‘Well, I wouldn’t lose any time,’ declared Hashknife. ‘That bunch will probably get drunk in Mesa City, and yuh never can tell what they will do.’

‘I know,’ nodded Lane. ‘But I don’t know what to do about Nan. She can’t stay here——’

‘I can’t stay anywhere else, Dad. I can’t afford to live at a hotel. Oh, I’ll be all right.’

‘We’ll stay awhile,’ offered Hashknife. ‘I can’t run away now; not after that warnin’. As soon as yuh see the sheriff, send him up here. I want him to understand about that warnin’, ’cause I might need an official reason for throwin’ lead.’

‘All right, Hartley. I’ll leave my rifle and shells here, in case yuh need long range.’

He shook hands with each of them, kissed Nan, and vanished down past the corral in the darkness.

Nan sighed with relief and tried to smile.

‘I guess I better finish washing the dishes,’ said Rex. ‘But I wish some of you would load that shotgun. I might have to shoot next time.’

‘You spoke yore piece, pardner,’ laughed Hashknife. ‘I’ll load the gun for yuh.’

He took a box of shells off a shelf and dropped one in each barrel, after which he stood the gun in a corner.

‘Thank you so much,’ said Rex.

‘Good huntin’ to yuh, brother,’ grinned Hashknife.

‘Oh, but I’m not going hunting for any one.’

‘You won’t have to. In Arizona, that kind of game comes right up to yore door.’