1 Dr. Tönnies, in his review of the first edition of this work, expresses a doubt as to whether slavery in the proper sense exists in every case in which, relying on the often superficial accounts of travellers, we conclude that slavery is present.

The foregoing passage and the whole of the present chapter are, we think, sufficient evidence that we have set ourselves the task of subjecting the accounts of travellers and other writers on savage tribes, on which our conclusions are to be based, to a critical examination. There may be particular instances in which we have failed in this respect; but we believe our conclusions on the whole rest upon a solid basis and Dr. Tönnies’s objection, in corroboration of which he does not adduce a single fact, does not seem to us well founded. 

2 Sometimes, however, children are sold to adoptive parents within the tribe. Such is the case in Greenland; see Crantz I, p. 178. But these are exceptional cases, so, when no particulars are given, we may suppose that the purchased persons become slaves and not adopted children

3 See Tylor, Primitive Culture, I pp. 417 sqq. 

4 The distinction between the several stages of culture will be enlarged upon in the second Part. 

5 Hanoteau et Letourneux, La Kabylie et les coutumes Kabyles

6 When similar phenomena are found among different peoples, modern ethnology supposes that they have spontaneously originated among each of them, viz. as long as the contrary is not made probable. See Steinmetz, Endokannibalismus, pp. 56, 57, and Darwin, Descent of Man, p. 141. 

7 Rink, p. 5. 

8 Ibid., pp. 24, 25. 

9 Ibid, pp. 24–34. 

10 Crantz I. pp. 178, 186. 

11 Ibid., pp. 211, 215. 

12 Nansen. 

13 Boas, Central, Eskimo, pp.580, 581. 

14 Ribbach, p. 286. 

15 Hall. 

16 Klutschak. 

17 Petitot. 

18 Turner, Ungava District. 

19 Bancroft, p. 65; Elliott. 

20 Ray, p. 44; Murdoch, p. 419. 

21 See Schurtz, Katechismus, p. 268. 

22 Bancroft, p. 92. 

23 Petroff, p. 152. 

24 Petroff, pp. 158, 159. 

25 Bancroft, p. 80; see also Holmberg, I pp. 78, 79. 

26 Krause, p. 152, etc.; Bancroft, p. 108; Dall, pp. 419–421; Petroff, p. 165; Elliott, p. 64; Niblack, p. 252; Holmberg, I pp. 50, 51, II pp. 43–46. 

27 Krause, p. 311; Bancroft, p. 168. 

28 Krause, p. 319; Niblack, p. 252; Boas, Die Tsimschian, pp. 237, 240, 244; Kane, Appendix A. 

29 Boas, Kwakiutl Indians, p. 338. 

30 Krause, p. 321. 

31 Sproat, pp. 89–92; Brown, adventures of John Jewitt, pp. 130, 131. 

32 Bancroft p. 195; Brown, ibid., pp. 19, 28, 35. 

33 Bancroft, p. 217. 

34 Mayne, pp. 242, 275, 253, etc. 

35 Kane, pp. 214, 215; Niblack, p. 252. 

36 Jones, The Kutchin Tribes, p. 325. 

37 Hardisty, p. 316. 

38 Whymper; Kirby; Bancroft. 

39 Mackenzie, I p. 152. 

40 Hearne, II pp. 87, 179. 

41 Bancroft, p. 124. 

42 Bancroft, p. 135. 

43 Allison, p. 316. 

44 Roosevelt; Le Jeune in The Jesuit Relations; Sagard; Mackenzie. 

45 Loskiel, p. 195. 

46 Loskiel; Brinton, The Lenape. 

47 Jesuit Relations, V pp. 31, 55; VI p. 245. 

48 Keating, II p. 168. 

49 Jones, Ojibway Indians, pp. 131, 109. 

50 Kohl, I p. 96. 

51 Carver, pp. 325, 326. 

52 Tanner, pp. 17, 112, 114. 

53 Tanner, pp. 11–16. 

54 Keating; Long, Ojibway Indians; Roosevelt. 

55 McLean, p. 64; Kane, p. 128; Mackenzie. 

56 Dodge, pp. 266, 267. 

57 Reports of Expl., Vol. XII Part I p. 99. 

58 Grinnell, pp. 115, 116, 123. 

59 Grinnell; Möllhausen; Mackenzie; Reports of Expl., Vol. I and Vol. XII Part I; Zu Wied, Nord-Amerika; Schoolcraft. 

60 Maurault, pp. 26—28. 

61 Hoffman, p. 35. 

62 Morgan, Anc. Soc., pp. 80, 69. 

63 Charlevoix, Nouv. France, III p. 245. 

64 Lafitau and Loskiel. Loskiel’s account of the Delawares applies equally to the Iroquois, see Loskiel, p. 1. 

65 Lafitau, II p. 308. 

66 Lafitau, III pp. 264–290; Charlevoix, l.c. pp. 242—252; Loskiel, p. 195; Mrs. Kinzie, pp. 214, sqq. 

67 Powell, Wyandot Gov., p. 68. 

68 Adair, pp. 303, 304, 287. 

69 Roosevelt, I p. 50. 

70 Rochefort, p. 412. 

71 Loskiel, p. 197. 

72 Bartram, p. 38. 

73 Roosevelt, I pp. 63, 64. 

74 Charlevoix, Nouv. France, III pp. 426; see also Lettres édif., XX pp. 132, 133. 

75 Bossu, pp. 241, 245, 249. 

76 Strachey, p. 83. 

77 Ibid., pp. 101, 108. 

78 Histoire de la Virginie, p. 261. 

79 Owen Dorsey, Siouan Soc., p. 215. 

80 Eastman, Dahcotah; Eastman, Indian Wars; Reports of Expl., Vol. I; Möllhausen; Ten Kate, Noord-Amerika; Schoolcraft. 

81 Eastman, Indian Wars, p. 412; Copway, pp. 65, 66; Neill, pp. 340, 526. 

82 Mathews, p. 47. 

83 Owen Dorsey, Omaha Soc., pp. 364, 332. 

84 James, p. 299. 

85 Hunter, Gedenkschriften, pp. 268, 270, 271. 

86 Reports of Expl., Vol. XII Part I p. 76. 

87 Lewis and Clark, I pp. 175, 242; see also pp. 212, 233. 

88 Gibbs, p. 188. 

89 Bancroft, p. 269; McLean, p. 54. 

90 The Flatheads of Fort George, who in Kane’s time kept slaves, are described by him as consisting principally of Chinooks and Klickataats. We are not sure whether these Flatheads are the same as those mentioned by Bancroft and McLean. (See Kane, pp. 173, 175, 181). 

91 Bancroft, p. 240; Kane, pp. 181, 182. 

92 Swan, The Northwest Coast, pp. 166, 167, etc. 

93 Lewis and Clark, II pp. 344, 345, 313, 314. 

94 Bancroft, p. 276. 

95 Ross, as quoted by Bancroft, l.c. 

96 Mackenzie, II pp. 217, 263. 

97 Brancroft, p. 269. 

98 Powers, p. 248. 

99 Kane, pp. 237, 242, 248, 320. 

100 Bancroft, pp. 349, 351. 

101 Powers, pp. 22, 75, 76. 

102 Hubbard, as quoted by Bancroft, p. 348. 

103 Bancroft, p. 360. 

104 This conclusion of ours is strengthened by the following statement of Gibbs, which we have already referred to: “Southward it [slavery] ceases, so far as my observation has gone, with the Siskiou Mountains, which divide Oregon from California.” (Gibbs, p. 188). 

105 Gatschet, pp. 59, 62; see also pp. 60, 16. 

106 Bancroft, p. 349. 

107 Ibid., pp. 388, 381. 

108 Ibid., p. 407. 

109 Boscana, in “Life in California”, pp. 308, 309. 

110 Powers, p. 322.