WeRead Powered by ReaderPub
ASCE 1193: The Water-Works and Sewerage of Monterrey, N. L., Mexico / The 4th article from the June, 1911, Volume LXXII, Transactions of the American Society of Civil Engineers. Paper No. 1193, Feb. 1, 1911. cover

ASCE 1193: The Water-Works and Sewerage of Monterrey, N. L., Mexico / The 4th article from the June, 1911, Volume LXXII, Transactions of the American Society of Civil Engineers. Paper No. 1193, Feb. 1, 1911.

Chapter 17: Main Outfall Sewer.
Open in WeRead

About This Book

A technical report presents the planning, design, construction and operation of municipal water-supply and sewerage systems for a growing industrial city. It examines local geology, hydrology, population and climate, surveys water sources and materials for concrete, and details intake works and a small storage dam with a lined settling basin. The account describes transmission mains, distributing reservoirs and gravity supplies, outlines the principal sewerage layout, outfall and disposal by irrigation, and provides laboratory analyses, labor and cost estimates, proposed tariffs and sanitary regulations, accompanied by discussion from reviewing engineers.

  South Reservoir.Obispado Reservoir.
  No.Quantities,
in cubic meters:
No.Quantities,
in cubic meters:
Earthwork:
 Total excavation...34,000...56,479
 Placed in embankment...31,500...7,255
 Placed in spoil banks...2,500...49,224
Concrete:
 Columns (including foundations)1351,240356543
 Primary beams135440374462
 Secondary beams6705151,252576
 Side-walls...1,255...710
 Roof slabSquare
meters:
5,140
520Square
meters:
10,206
1,020
 Floor4,0707809,2002,120
 Parapet walls...90...165
 Total concrete...4,840...5,596
Reinforcing steel bars...Pounds:
387,000
...Pounds:
380,000
Expanded metal in roofs, slabs, etc....Square
meters:
5,691
...Square
meters:
10,490

The total cost of these reservoirs, including valve-houses, by-passes, and the length of supply pipe where the by-pass joins, and including all engineering expenses, etc., but exclusive of the cost of lands, planting, fencing, and special work in connection with the formation of parks, was as follows:

South Reservoir: 394,000 pesos, or 10,368 pesos per million liters.

Obispado Reservoir: 375,000 pesos, or 9,375 pesos[7] per million liters.

[7] Mexican currency.

These rates may be regarded as reasonable when taking into consideration the special difficulties of construction in Mexico, and the high cost of all imported material, on which heavy duties are levied.

The value of the materials alone in these reservoirs amounted to more than 70% of their total cost.

Analyses of Estanzuela and San Geronimo Waters.

Table 8 shows analyses of the Estanzuela and San Geronimo waters, made in February, 1910, by Messrs. Ledoux, of New York City. The Estanzuela sample was taken at the valve-house of the South Reservoir, while that of San Geronimo was taken in Shaft No. 1 of the infiltration gallery when flowing at the rate of about 450 liters per sec. Both waters are absolutely free from turbidity.

TABLE 8.—Analyses of Estanzuela and San Geronimo Waters.
In Parts per Million.
Estanzuela.San Geronimo
Infiltration Gallery.
 
Total solid matter in solution209.00305.00
Organic and volatile matterNot weighable.Not weighable.
 
Analysis of Solids:
Silica10.512.0
Iron and AluminaTraces.Traces.
Lime85.4112.6
Magnesia3.822.6
Soda (Na2O)13.320.2
Potash (K2O)2.01.9
Sulphuric Acid24.411.5
Chlorine2.02.8
 
Probable Combination of Bases &
Acid Radicals in the Solids:
Silica10.512.0
Iron and AluminaTraces.Traces.
Sodium Chloride3.34.6
Potassium Sulphate3.73.5
Sodium Sulphate26.340.8
Calcium Sulphate13.322.1
Calcium Carbonate142.7184.8
Magnesium Carbonate8.449.8
 ————
208.2317.6
 
Nitrogen as Free Ammonia0.0040.032
Nitrogen as Albuminoid Ammonia0.0060.022
Nitrogen as Nitrites (N2O3)0.0020.002
Nitrogen as Nitrates (N2O3)0.1001.85
Total Hardness (as CaCO3)155.0220.0
Alkalinity (as CaCO3)121.0180.0

City Water Distribution System.

The distribution system was begun in September, 1906, but the general lay-out of the mains was modified in July, 1907, in view of the division of the system into two services, for high and low pressure. Plate XIX shows in skeleton form the lines of the cast-iron mains. These are laid at the present time along routes containing houses (excluding wooden shacks) which can be served immediately. The distribution system is arranged to serve as follows:

Estanzuela supply4,150houses.
San Geronimo supply8,600"
———
Total12,750houses.

This represents, at the present time, a division of the city of 3212% for the Estanzuela, and 6712% for the San Geronimo supply. Of the area of the supply district north of Santa Catarina River, 57% will be supplied from San Geronimo and 43% from Estanzuela. The real development of the city, however, is northward in the area of the low-pressure supply.

The static pressure over the city in the two sections varies as follows:

Estanzuela supply85 to 50 lb.
San Geronimo supply55 to 29 lb.

The main supply pipe from the South Reservoir is 61 cm. (24 in.) in internal diameter, and this size allows ample provision for future extensions. The supply pipe from the Obispado Reservoir is 76 cm. (30 in.) in internal diameter. On this main, in Calle de Cinco de Mayo, at a distance of 320 m. from the reservoir, has been placed a 76-cm. (30-in.) Venturi meter, the recording apparatus being in the house on the side of the road. Both these supply pipes are carried well into the city, and from them the distribution mains are laid; these are 45.7 and 30 cm. (18 and 12 in.) in internal diameter, with intermediate sections of 15 and 10 cm. (6 in. and 4 in.). Along Calle de Cinco de Mayo, where the division between the two services takes place, two lines are laid, a 30-cm. for high pressure and a 38-cm. (15-in.) for the low pressure. A duplicate pipe, 30 cm. (12 in.) in diameter, is also laid in Calle de Dr. Coss. On Calle de Alvarez the low-pressure pipe is 61 cm. (24 in.), and the high-pressure, 45.7 cm. (18 in.) in diameter. Provision is also made for extending the range of the two services to other districts. Practically every block is provided with gate-valves to cut off the supply in any direction. On the 76-cm. main, 61-cm. (24-in.) valves are used, and are connected by tapers to the pipe. On the 61-cm. mains, 45.7-cm. (18-in.) valves are used. The actual frictional loss by reducing the valve being small, this method permitted the use of valves of a more convenient size. On all the larger valves there are 15-cm. by-passes fitted with independent gate-valves.

Fig. 15.—Connection Between High-and Low-pressure Areas And The Intersection Of Cinco De Mayo And Alvarez Streets.

Larger.

Scour-out pipes, 10 cm. (4 in.) and 15 cm. (6 in.) in diameter, are placed in various parts of the system, draining to the sewers. Air-valves, both double and single, are also placed at high points in different parts of the system.

Reducing Valves.—At four points in the system the mains are arranged so that the supply can be interchangeable. Fig. 15 shows the arrangement of the mains at the junction of Cinco de Mayo and Alvarez Streets, and is typical of the arrangement at the other points.

Each reducing valve is placed on a 30-cm. (12-in.) branch main between the two services. These valves adjust themselves automatically to the pressure required, after they have been properly regulated to the different pressures on either side. To allow repairs to be easily made, there are ordinary gate-valves at each end enclosed in the same pit. If necessary, as in case of fire, any part of the system can be changed into high pressure temporarily by closing the valves against the San Geronimo supply.

Table 9 gives the length of the mains as laid, and the number of valves.

TABLE 9.—Length of Water Mains.
Diameter:Length,
in meters.
Number of
gate-valves.
Centimeters.Inches.
10.2449,831.68677
15.2631,918.31306
30.51214,461.31117
38.1151,661.9811
45.7184,522.615
61.0242,826.5410
76.2301,454.40
———————
Totals106,676.831,126

The pipes were all cast according to the British Standard Specification, in 3.65-m. (12-ft.) lengths, and were supplied by Messrs. D. Y. Stewart and Company, and Messrs. Dick, Kerr and Company, of Kilmarnock and London. The valves were all of standard design, faced with gun-metal, and were supplied by Messrs. Glenfield and Kennedy, Limited, of Kilmarnock, Scotland.

In the distribution system it is proposed to provide 200 fire-hydrants, by arrangement with the municipality, but only a few of these have been placed. The general type is a double hydrant for two 63.5-mm. (212-in.) streams. These are to be placed at the corner of every block in the business portion of the city; single-way hydrants will be used in the residential districts.

Laying Cast-iron Pipes.—Table 10 has been prepared to show what can be accomplished with Mexican labor in laying pipes. In this kind of work the labor was particularly efficient; after the gangs were once drilled into shape, the work proceeded systematically, and at very good speed. All the pipes, after being laid, were tested to 150 lb. per sq. in. in the presence of the Technical Inspector.

Table 11 gives the details of the excavation, the material, and the average cost, of laying about 106.6 km. of pipes.

House Connections.—The ordinary house connections, which are of 19-mm. (34-in.) galvanized-steel pipe, are connected to the mains by lead goosenecks and brass corporation cocks. The Company's obligation under the concession extended to the edge of the sidewalk, and at this point curb-boxes, chiefly of the Hays pattern, were placed; but, subsequently, owing to the metering of every house service in the city, the control of the Company extended to the meter, which, as a rule, is placed immediately inside of the house. Owing to the rapid deterioration of the house service pipes in some districts of the northern part of the city, where the soil is formed of decaying organic matter, it has been decided to use lead pipe entirely from the main to the meter.

Damage Due to Floods.—During the night of August 27th, the main 61-cm. pipe, under the river bed of Santa Catarina, at the point where the main entered the city, was destroyed for a distance of 130 m., due to the scouring away of a whole block of city property. The Venturi meter register chart at the South Reservoir showed that the break occurred a few minutes before midnight. The location of this pipe is shown by Fig. 5; its broken end was in proximity to an old bridge pier. Fortunately, at the time of the flood, the Obispado Reservoir works were completed, and the whole city was supplied with water from San Geronimo within 48 hours. As only about 1,500 services had then been connected, this delay was not serious; in fact, in the lower part of the city, the water in the mains was sufficient until the San Geronimo supply could be connected. To make a temporary connection to conduct the high-pressure water to the city, a 15-cm. steel pipe was placed above ground, on the line of the main, for a distance of 100 m. This pipe was supported by a cable, 30 mm. in diameter, and by timber trestles. By limiting the supply district, this pipe was of sufficient capacity to serve until the large main could be safely restored.

TABLE 10.—Cost of Laying and Jointing Cast-Iron Pipes,
Excluding Lowering and Testing.
76 Cm. (30 in.)
Employees.Rate for 10 hour day. Pesos.Total No. men.Total cost of labor. Pesos.No. of pipes laid..Cost per linear meter. Pesos.
Foreman4.5014.50......
Caulkers3.00412.00......
Lead pourers2.0024.00......
Lead melter1.5011.50200.498
Pipe cutter2.0012.00......
Peons1.001212.00......
Water boy0.5010.50......
—————
...2236.50......
61 Cm. (24 in.)
Employees.Rate for 10 hour day. Pesos.Total No. men.Total cost of labor. Pesos.No. of pipes laid..Cost per linear meter. Pesos.
Foreman4.5014.50......
Caulkers3.00515.00......
Lead pourers2.0024.00......
Lead melter1.5011.50250.410
Pipe cutter2.0012.00......
Peons1.001010.00......
Water boy0.5010.50......
—————
...2137.50......
50 Cm. (20 in.)
Employees.Rate for 10 hour day. Pesos.Total No. men.Total cost of labor. Pesos.No. of pipes laid..Cost per linear meter. Pesos.
Foreman4.5014.50......
Caulkers3.00412.00......
Lead pourers2.0024.00......
Lead melter1.5011.50350.287
Pipe cutter2.0012.00......
Peons1.001212.00......
Water boy0.5010.50......
—————
...2236.50......
45.7 Cm. (18 in.)
Employees.Rate for 10 hour day. Pesos.Total No. men.Total cost of labor. Pesos.No. of pipes laid..Cost per linear meter. Pesos.
Foreman4.5014.50......
Caulkers3.00412.00......
Lead pourers2.0024.00......
Lead melter1.5011.50400.221
Pipe cutter2.0012.00......
Peons1.0088.00......
Water boy0.5010.50......
—————
...1832.50......
38 Cm. (15 in.)
Employees.Rate for 10 hour day. Pesos.Total No. men.Total cost of labor. Pesos.No. of pipes laid..Cost per linear meter. Pesos.
Foreman4.5014.50......
Caulkers3.00412.00......
Lead pourers2.0024.00......
Lead melter1.5011.50450.196
Pipe cutter2.0012.00......
Peons1.0088.00......
Water boy0.5010.50......
—————
...1832.50......
30.5 Cm. (12 in.)
Employees.Rate for 10 hour day. Pesos.Total No. men.Total cost of labor. Pesos.No. of pipes laid..Cost per linear meter. Pesos.
Foreman4.5014.50......
Caulkers3.00412.00......
Lead pourers2.0024.00......
Lead melter1.5011.50600.147
Pipe cutter2.0012.00......
Peons1.0088.00......
Water boy0.5010.50......
—————
...1832.50......
15 Cm. (6 in.)
Employees.Rate for 10 hour day. Pesos.Total No. men.Total cost of labor. Pesos.No. of pipes laid..Cost per linear meter. Pesos.
Foreman4.5014.50......
Caulkers3.00412.00......
Lead pourers2.0024.00......
Lead melter1.5011.501000.082
Pipe cutter2.0012.00......
Peons1.0066.00......
Water boy0.5010.50......
—————
...1630.50......
10 Cm. (4 in.)
Employees.Rate for 10 hour day. Pesos.Total No. men.Total cost of labor. Pesos.No. of pipes laid..Cost per linear meter. Pesos.
Foreman4.5014.50......
Caulkers3.00412.00......
Lead pourers2.0024.00......
Lead melter1.5011.501500.0574
Pipe cutter2.0012.00......
Peons1.0066.00......
Water boy0.5010.50......
—————
1630.50......

TABLE 11.—Cast-Iron Water Pipes.—Cost of Materials and Laying at Monterrey.
Materials per Standard Length of Pipe.
Key: cm = centimeter in = inch mm = millimeter kg = kilogram m = linear meter
Pipe DiameterThicknessWeight of PipeCost/piece fob MonterreyLeadOakumCharcoalTotal Material Cost per m
cminmmkgpesosWeight kgCost pesosCost pesosCost pesospesos
 
10410.310911.652.00.370.0250.05253.30
15611.116315.743.70.670.06750.0654.51
30.51215.846376.507.91.440.12250.121.35
381517.468079.3610.61.940.1750.1222.30
45.71819.087190.2813.42.420.23750.137525.42
612422.21,261117.6018.83.420.3350.17533.20
763025.41,946199.0524.54.420.440.212555.77
Labor.
Key: cm = centimeter, in = inch, m = meter
Diameter of pipe:Width of trenchDepthCubic meters per linear meterCost of excavation per lin. mBack-filling and removing surplusTotal cost, excavation back filling etc.Hauling per linear meterCost of laying per linear meterTotal hauling and laying per linear meterTotal excavation and laying, labor, complete
cminmmPesosPesosPesosHaulingMisc.PesosPesosPesos
 
1040.550.900.500.600.180.780.02750.0050.060.09250.8725
1560.601.000.600.720.220.940.450.0050.8250.13251.0725
30.5120.651.200.780.940.291.230.180.00750.14750.3351.565
38150.701.300.911.100.341.440.27250.010.190.47751.9125
45.7180.801.401.121.340.411.750.27250.010.2450.52752.2775
61241.001.501.501.800.552.350.8250.080.411.3153.665
76301.101.601.762.110.652.760.830.100.531.464.22

Note.—The above costs of earthwork are based on the following rates and percentages over the whole city:

Earth, per cubic meter0.35pesos50%
Soft sillar0.75"20%
Hard sillar1.50"20%
Rock (chiefly conglomerate)4.00"10%
Summary of Table 11.
Diameter of pipe:Total labor cost.Materials.Total cost per linear meter.
Centimeters.Inches.Pesos.Pesos.Pesos.
 
1040.87253.304.1725
1561.07254.515.5825
30.5121.56521.3522.915
38151.912522.3024.2125
45.7182.277525.4227.6975
61243.66533.2036.865
76304.2255.7759.99

The flood destroyed about 1,200 houses in the neighborhood of the river. In a number of blocks the smaller mains were scoured away, but considerable salvage was done afterward, and, as it is the intention of the authorities not to permit rebuilding along the flood-path of the river, these mains do not require reconstruction.

Main Sewerage System.

The Company's obligations, as far as drainage is concerned, were limited to the removal and disposal of sewage, no provision being required for storm-water, which is allowed to find its way to the natural watercourses. Apart from that fact, however, the best system for a city like Monterrey, where rainfall for many months at a time is very scarce, is the strictly "separate system." In the design advantage was taken of the natural topography of the drainage district, which is almost an ideal one for a gravitation system of sewers, the general fall in all directions being northeast; it was also in this direction that the best available land could be obtained for disposal purposes.

Plate XX shows in skeleton form the general lay-out of the sewers. Two drainage districts are arranged, divided by Calle de Washington, which may be regarded as practically the center of the city, and each of these districts has an independent main collector connecting to the outfall sewer at the northeast extremity of the city.

The system has been designed so that extensions may be made and may cover any part within the city limits; the main collectors are large enough for the whole area when fully built up.

The sewers are designed on a very liberal basis, namely, on the assumption that when flowing half full the quantity to be dealt with will be 380 liters per capita per day, with a maximum rate of flow of 200 per cent. It was assumed that each house would be occupied by 7 persons and have a frontage of 1212 m. The minimum velocities in the sewers, when running full, vary between 0.91 and 1.5 m. per sec., with the exception of a few blocks.

The minimum size adopted was 24.3 cm. (8 in.) in internal diameter. The sewers of diameters between 24.3 and 50 cm., are 0.91 m. (36 in.) long, and are of salt-glazed vitrified clay, imported from San Antonio, Tex.

Table 12 gives the details of the length of the various sewers laid.

TABLE 12.—Length of Sewers.
Diameter:Kind.Length, in meters.
cmin.
24.38Fire clay38,332.85
25.410"16,400.69
30.512"7,953.15
38.115"4,850.56
45.718"2,023.40
50.820"1,450.53
55.922Reinforced concrete tubes, 6.9 cm. thick3,134.20
61.025Reinforced concrete tubes, 7.6 cm. thick357.40
68.627Brick and concrete484.05
76.230Brick and concrete662.69
———
Total75,649.15

The greater number of the manholes are of brickwork, 23 cm. thick, and have concrete inverts. They have a diameter of 1.2 m., which is reduced to 0.61 m. at the top, and each is provided with a heavy cast-iron frame and closed cover weighing about 190 kg. There are 521 manholes, and they are placed at every block and on long lines about 80 m. apart.

Fig. 16.—Standard 300-gal. Flush Tanks.
Larger.

The sewers are flushed with 15-cm. (6-in.) automatic flushing siphons of the Miller pattern with 20-cm. (8-in.) discharge pipes. There are 278 of these siphons, and they are placed in flush-tanks (Fig. 16) built of brickwork and plastered with 1:1 cement mortar. Their capacity varies from 800 to 1,200 liters, and they discharge from 2212 to 2812 liters per sec. They are timed to flush once in 24 hours.

The system is at present ventilated by 23-cm. (9-in.) steel ventilating columns (Fig. 16), with ornamental cast-iron bases. There are 220 of these columns. Most of them are 7.85 m. above the level of the edge of the sidewalk, and are connected to special 15-cm. branch pipes leading from the sewer on the outside of the flush-tanks. In the center of the city they are provided with extension lengths, giving a total height of 12 m.

Table 13 gives the particulars of the average distributed cost of laying the 75.6 km. of sewers.

Kind of Sewer.Internal Diameter of Sewers. Cost of materials including 10 cm. (4 in.) branches every 412 m. Pesos.Earthwork and Labor: Total cost of sewer complete per linear meter.
cm.in.Average depth of sewer
m.
Cost of excavation, including back filling, removing surplus, etc. Pesos.Cost of labor in laying (including hauling, etc.). Pesos.
Fire clay 24.3 8 2.00 2.10 3.46 0.21 5.67
" 25.4 10 2.78 2.25 3.97 0.2625 7.0125
" 30.5 12 3.64 2.50 4.705 0.305 8.65
" 38.1 15 6.14 2.75 5.50 0.4375 12.0775
" 45.7 18 8.80 3.00 6.745 0.645 16.19
" 50.8 20 11.30 3.50 8.275 0.815 20.39
Concrete 55.9 22 5.93 3.50 9.19 1.325 16.445
" 61.0 25 7.30 3.75 11.245 1.685 20.23
One brick thick on concrete foundations 68.6 27 7.17 3.75 11.735 3.93 22.835
76.2 30 7.925 4.00 14.53 4.515 26.97
Fig. 17.—Sketch Showing Disconnecting Trap On House Drain.

The house connections are chiefly of 10-cm. (4-in.) pipes, laid on a minimum gradient of 212%, from oblique branches on the sewer to siphon intercepting traps near the house, as shown by Fig. 17. From this trap a 10-cm. fire-clay inspection pipe is carried up and capped at the sidewalk level with a cast-iron box having a locked cover. From this inspection pipe a branch is connected to a cast-iron fresh-air inlet, in most cases set in the wall of the house, the inlet being 30 cm. above the level of the pavement.

Effect of the Flood on Sewers.—The flood of August 27th and 28th, 1909, partly destroyed one of the main collectors, which was laid along the banks of the river and encased in concrete. This has now been relaid farther north, and out of the way of any future floods. The total length of the new sewers replacing those damaged amounts to 1200 m., and they vary in internal diameter from 20 to 55.9 cm. (8 to 22 in.).

Main Outfall Sewer.

The direction of the main outfall sewer was determined after a thorough study of all the available land lying to the north and northeast of the city, as it was the intention of the Company to utilize for irrigation purposes the sewage and any surplus waters that might be developed. The best available site was found to be about 12 km. north of the city, a little northwest of the village of San Nicolas de los Garzas, as shown on Plate II. The long length of outfall required was justified by the cheap cost of the land and its excellent character for sewage irrigation. The sewer was designed for a capacity of 90,000,000 liters a day (36.76 cu. ft. per sec.) in order to allow for conveying surplus waters as well as sewage.

The outfall intercepts the two main branches of the city sewers at Calle de Allende and Calle de Tapia, and its total length is approximately 11,900 m. The chief type adopted is shown on Plate XXII. It is formed with an invert of radial bricks laid in 1:2 cement mortar, on a foundation of 1:3:5 concrete approximately 7 cm. thick. As the ground was chiefly in hard sillar, only a little concrete was required to mould the bottom to the correct shape. The arch was formed of special radial bricks, 15 cm. (6 in.) deep, laid in cement mortar. These bricks were adopted in preference to concrete, owing to the heavy cost of sand and rock, due to the long haul, and for the purpose of obtaining rapid work. Plate XXI shows the sewer arch, and one of the ventilating columns and manholes. The bricks were obtained from the local brick plant, and form a very satisfactory material for sewers, being well burnt, thoroughly hard, and absorbing not more than 712% of their weight of water. The contract prices for the labor on the brickwork were 1.25 pesos per sq. m., and 1.38 pesos for the arch.