§ 45. A LEPER HEALED, AND MUCH POPULAR EXCITEMENT


Mark 1:40-45 Matt. 8:2-4 Luke 5:12-16
40    And there cometh to
him a leper, beseeching
him, 1and kneeling
down to him,
and saying unto him,
If thou wilt, thou
canst make me clean.
41 And being moved
with compassion, he
stretched forth his
hand, and touched
him, and saith unto
him, I will; be thou
made clean. 42 And
straightway the
leprosy departed from
him, and he was
made clean. 43 And he
2strictly charged him,
and straightway sent
him out, 44 and saith
unto him, See thou
say nothing to any
man: but go thy way,
shew thyself to the
priest, and offer for
thy cleansing the
things which Moses
commanded, for a
testimony unto them.

45 But he went out, and
began to publish it
much, and to spread
abroad the 3matter,
insomuch that 4Jesus
could no more openly
enter into 5a city,
but was without in
desert places: and
they came to him
from every quarter.
2 And behold, there
came to him a leper
and worshipped him,
saying, Lord, if thou
wilt, thou canst make
me clean.

3 And he stretched
forth his hand, and
touched him, saying,
I will; be thou made
clean. And straightway
his leprosy was
cleansed.




4 And Jesus saith unto
him, See thou tell
no man; but go thy
way, shew thyself to
the priest, and offer
the gift that Moses
commanded, for a
testimony unto them.
12    And it came to
pass, while he was
in one of the cities,
behold, a man full of
leprosy: and when
he saw Jesus, he fell
on his face, and
besought him, saying,
Lord, if thou wilt,
thou canst make me
clean. 13 And he
stretched forth his
hand, and touched him,
saying, I will; be thou
made clean. And
straightway the
leprosy departed from
him.
14            And
he charged him to
tell no man: but go
thy way, and shew
thyself to the priest,
and offer for thy


cleansing, according
as Moses commanded,
for a testimony
unto them [see Lev.
13:49; 14:2-32
].
15 But so much the
more went abroad the
report concerning him:
and great multitudes
came together
to hear, and to be
healed of their
infirmities. 16 But he
withdrew himself in
the deserts, and
prayed.
1 Some ancient authorities omit and kneeling down to him.
2 Or, sternly.
3 Gr. word.
4 Gr. he.
5 Or, the city.




§ 46. THRONGED IN CAPERNAUM, HE HEALS A PARALYTIC LOWERED THROUGH THE ROOF OF PETER'S HOUSE


Mark 2:1-12 Matt. 9:1-8 Luke 5:17-26
1    And when he
entered again into
Capernaum after some
days, it was noised
that he was 4in the
house. 2 And many
were gathered
together, so that there
was no longer room
for them, no, not even
about the door: and
he spake the word
unto them. 3 And they
come, bringing unto
him a man sick of the
palsy, borne of four.
4 And when they could
not 5come nigh unto
him for the crowd,
they uncovered the
roof where he was:
and when they had
broken it up, they let
down the bed whereon
the sick of the



palsy lay. 5 And Jesus
seeing their faith
saith unto the sick of
the palsy, 1Son, thy
sins are forgiven. 6 But
there were certain
of the scribes sitting
there, and reasoning
in their hearts,
7 Why doth this man
thus speak? he
blasphemeth: who can
forgive sins but one,
even God? 8 And
straightway Jesus,
perceiving in his spirit
that they so reasoned
within themselves,
saith unto them, Why
reason ye these things
in your hearts?
9 Whether is easier, to
say to the sick of the
palsy, Thy sins are
forgiven; or to say,
Arise, and take up
thy bed, and walk?
10 But that ye may
know that the Son
of man hath 3power
on earth to forgive
sins (he saith to the
sick of the palsy),a 11 I
say unto thee, Arise,
take up thy bed, and
go unto thy house.

12 And he arose, and
straightway took up
the bed, and went
forth before them all;
insomuch that they
were all amazed, and
glorified God, saying,
We never saw it on
this fashion.
1    And he entered into
a boat, and crossed
over, and came into
his own city.








2 And behold, they
brought to him a man
sick of the palsy,
lying on a bed:












and Jesus seeing their
faith said unto the
sick of the palsy,
1Son, be of good
cheer; thy sins are
forgiven. 3 And
behold, certain of the
scribes said within
themselves, This man
blasphemeth.




4 And Jesus 2knowing
their thoughts said,



Wherefore think ye
evil in your hearts?
5 For whether is easier,
to say, Thy sins are
forgiven; or to say,
Arise, and walk? 6 But


that ye may know
that the Son of man
hath 3power on earth
to forgive sins (then
saith he to the sick
of the palsy), Arise,
and take up thy bed,
and go unto thy


house. 7 And he arose,
and departed to his
house.


8                But
when the multitudes
saw it, they were
afraid, and glorified
God, which had given
such 3power unto
men.
17    And it came to
pass on one of those
days, that he was
teaching; and there
were Pharisees and
doctors of the law
sitting by, which were
come out of every
village of Galilee and
Judea and Jerusalem:
and the power of the
Lord was with him
6to heal. 18 And behold,
men bring on a
bed a man that was
palsied: and they
sought to bring him
in, and to lay him
before him. 19 And not
finding by what way
they might bring him
in because of the
multitude, they went
up to the housetop,
and let him down
through the tiles with
his couch into the
midst before Jesus.
20 And seeing their
faith, he said, Man,
thy sins are forgiven
thee. 21 And the scribes
and the Pharisees began
to reason, saying,
Who is this that
speaketh blasphemies?
Who can forgive
sins, but God alone?



22 But Jesus perceiving
their reasonings,
answered and
said unto them, 7What
reason ye in your
hearts?

23          Whether
is easier, to say, Thy
sins are forgiven thee;
or to say, Arise and
walk?


24 But that ye may
know that the Son
of man hath 3power
on earth to forgive
sins (he said unto
him that was palsied),
I say unto thee,
Arise, and take up
thy couch, and go
unto thy house. 25 And
immediately he rose
up before them, and
took up that whereon
he lay, and departed
to his house,
glorifying God. 26 And
amazement took hold
on all, and they
glorified God; and they
were filled with fear,
saying, We have seen
strange things to-day.
1 Gr. Child.
2 Many ancient authorities read seeing.
3 Or, authority.
4 Or, at home.
5 Many ancient authorities read bring him unto him.
6 Gr. that he should heal. Many ancient authorities read that he should heal them.
7 Or, Why.

a Note the parenthetic explanation of the writers in the middle of the saying of Jesus. It is proof that each of the Gospels had the same written source here or rather, as we know otherwise, that Matthew and Luke had Mark before them.





§ 47. THE CALL OF MATTHEW (LEVI) AND HIS RECEPTION IN HONOR OF JESUS

Capernaum


Mark 2:13-17 Matt. 9:9-13 Luke 5:27-32
13    And he went forth
again by the sea side;
and all the multitude
resorted unto him,
and he taught them.
14 And as he passed
by, he saw Levi the son
of Alphæus sitting
at the place of toll,
and he saith unto
him, Follow me. And
he arose and followed


him. 15 And it came
to pass, that he was
sitting at meat in his
house, and many
4publicans and sinners
sat down with Jesus
and his disciples: for
there were many, and
they followed him.
16 And the scribes 5of
the Pharisees, when
they saw that he was
eating with the sinners
and publicans,
said unto his disciples,
6He eateth 7and
drinketh with publicans
and sinners.
17 And when Jesus
heard it, he saith
unto them, They that
are 3whole have no
need of a physician,
but they that are
sick: I came not to
call the righteous, but
sinners.





9    And as Jesus
passed by from thence,
he saw a man, called
Matthew, sitting at
the place of toll: and
he saith unto him,
Follow me. And he
arose, and followed
him.
10    And it came to
pass, as he 1sat at
meat in the house,
behold, many
publicans and sinners
came and sat down
with Jesus and his
disciples.

11            And when
the Pharisees saw it,
they said unto his
disciples, Why eateth
your 2Master with
the publicans and
sinners?


12 But when he heard
it, he said, They that
are 3whole have no
need of a physician,
but they that are sick.
13 But go ye and learn
what this meaneth,a
I desire mercy,
and not sacrifice: for
I came not to call the
righteous, but sinners.
27    And after these
things he went forth,
and beheld a publican,
named Levi,
sitting at the place of
toll, and said unto
him, Follow me.



28 And he forsook all,
and rose up and
followed him.

29                  And
Levi made him a
great feast in his
house: and there was
a great multitude of
publicans and of
others that were sitting
at meat with them.

30 And 8the Pharisees
and their scribes
murmured against his
disciples, saying, Why
do ye eat and drink
with the publicans
and sinners?


31        And Jesus
answering said unto
them, They that are
3whole have no need
of a physician; but
they that are sick.

32                I am
not come to call the
righteous but sinners
to repentance.
1 Gr. reclined: and so always.
2 Or, Teacher.
3 Gr. strong.
4 That is, collectors or renters of Roman taxes: and so elsewhere.
5 Some ancient authorities read and the Pharisees.
6 Or, How is it that he eateth ... sinners?
7 Some ancient authorities omit and drinketh.
8 Or, the Pharisees and the scribes among them.

a Hos. 6:6.





§ 48. JESUS IN THREE PARABLES DEFENDS HIS DISCIPLES FOR FEASTINGa INSTEAD OF FASTING


Mark 2:18-22 Matt. 9:14-17 Luke 5:33-39
18    And John's
disciples and the
Pharisees were fasting:
and they come and say
unto him, Why do
John's disciples and
the disciples of the
Pharisees fast, but
thy disciples fast not?
19 And Jesus said unto
them, Can the sons of
the bride-chamber fast,
while the bridegroom
is with them?
as long as they have
the bridegroom with
them, they cannot
fast. 20 But the days
will come, when the
bridegroom shall be
taken away from
them, and then they
will fast in that day.


21                No
man seweth a piece
of undressed cloth on
an old garment: else
that which should
fill it up taketh from
it, the new from the
old, and a worse rent
is made. 22 And no
man putteth new wine
into old 2wine-skins:
else the wine
will burst the skins,
and the wine perisheth,
and the skins:
but they put new wine
into fresh wine-skins.
14    Then come to him
the disciples of John,
saying, Why do we
and the Pharisees fast
1oft, but thy disciples



fast not? 15 And Jesus
said unto them, Can
the sons of the bride-
chamber mourn, as
long as the bridegroom
is with them?



but the days will come,
when the bridegroom
shall be taken
away from them, and
then will they fast.



16                And no
man putteth a piece
of undressed cloth
upon an old garment;
for that which should
fill it up taketh from
the garment, and a
worse rent is made.
17 Neither do men put
new wine into old
2wine-skins: else the
skins burst, and the
wine is spilled, and
the skins perish: but
they put new wine
into fresh wine-skins,
and both are
preserved.
33    And they said unto
him, The disciples
of John fast often, and
make supplications;
likewise also
the disciples of the
Pharisees; but thine
eat and drink. 34 And
Jesus said unto them,
Can ye make the sons
of the bride-chamber
fast while
the bridegroom is
with them?



35 But the days will
come; and when the
bridegroom shall be
taken away from
them, then will they
fast in those days.
36        And he spake
also a parableb unto
them; No man rendeth
a piece from a new
garment and putteth
it upon an old
garment; else he will
rend the new, and
also the piece from
the new will not agree
with the old. 37 And
no man putteth new
wine into old 2wine-
skins; else the new
wine will burst the
skins, and itself will
be spilled, and the
skins will perish.
38 But new wine must
be put into fresh
wine-skins. 39 And no
man having drunk
old wine desireth new:
for he saith, The old
is 3good.
1 Some ancient authorities omit oft.
2 That is, skins used as bottles.
3 Many ancient authorities read better.

a It was probably the presence of the disciples of Christ at Matthew's feast on one of the Jewish fast days that occasioned the complaint of John's disciples and the Pharisees. It is sad to see disciples of John aligned with the Pharisees against Jesus.

b Note the use of the term parable in Luke. There are three parables (the sons of the bride-chamber, the new patch on an old garment, the new wine in old wine-skins) here together. A few isolated ones have already occurred as in John 2:19.





In sections 49 to 51 we see the Pharisees attacking Jesus both in Jerusalem and in Galilee with great hostility and with the purpose of killing him because of violation of the Pharisaic regulations about the Sabbath. Jesus defends himself and his disciples by various arguments and personal claims.





§ 49. AT A FEAST IN JERUSALEM (POSSIBLY THE PASSOVER) JESUS HEALS A LAME MAN ON THE SABBATH AND DEFENDS THIS ACTION TO THE PHARISEES IN A GREAT DISCOURSE


John 5:1-47

1    After these things there was 1a feasta of the Jews; and Jesus went up to Jerusalem.b

2    Now there is in Jerusalem by the sheep gate a pool, which is called in Hebrew 2Bethesda, having five porches. 3 In these lay a multitude of them that were sick, blind, halt, withered3. 5 And a certain man was there, which had been thirty and eight years in his infirmity. 6 When Jesus saw him lying, and knew that he had been now a long time in that case, he saith unto him, Wouldst thou be made whole? 7 The sick man answered him, 4Sir, I have no man, when the water is troubled, to put me into the pool: but while I am coming, another steppeth down before me. 8 Jesus saith unto him, Arise, take up thy bed, and walk. 9 And straightway the man was made whole, and took up his bed and walked.

    Now it was the sabbath on that day. 10 So the Jews said unto him that was cured, It is the sabbath, and it is not lawful for thee to take up thy bed [see Ex. 20:10; Deut. 5:14]. 11 But he answered them, He that made me whole, the same said unto me, Take up thy bed, and walk. 12 They asked him, Who is the man that said unto thee, Take up thy bed, and walk? 13 But he that was healed wist not who it was: for Jesus had conveyed himself away, a multitude being in the place. 14 Afterward Jesus findeth him in the temple, and said unto him, Behold, thou art made whole: sin no more, lest a worse thing befall thee. 15 The man went away, and told the Jews that it was Jesus which had made him whole. 16 And for this cause did the Jews persecute Jesus, because he did these things on the sabbath. 17 But Jesus answered them, My Father worketh even until now, and I work. 18 For this cause therefore the Jews sought the more to kill him, because he not only brake the sabbath, but also called God his own Father, making himself equal with God.

19    Jesus therefore answered and said unto them,

    Verily, verily, I say unto you, The Son can do nothing of himself, but what he seeth the Father doing: for what things soever he doeth, these the Son also doeth in like manner. 20 For the Father loveth the Son, and sheweth him all things that himself doeth: and greater works than these will he shew him, that ye may marvel. 21 For as the Father raiseth the dead and quickeneth them, even so the Son also quickeneth whom he will. 22 For neither doth the Father judge any man, but he hath given all judgement unto the Son; 23 that all may honour the Son, even as they honour the Father. He that honoureth not the Son honoureth not the Father which sent him. 24 Verily, verily, I say unto you, He that heareth my word, and believeth him that sent me, hath eternal life, and cometh not into judgement, but hath passed out of death into life. 25 Verily, verily, I say unto you, The hour cometh, and now is, when the dead shall hear the voice of the Son of God; and they that hear shall live. 26 For as the Father hath life in himself, even so gave he to the Son also to have life in himself: 27 and he gave him authority to execute judgement, because he is 5the Son of man. 28 Marvel not at this: for the hour cometh, in which all that are in the tombs shall hear his voice, 29 and shall come forth; they that have done good, unto the resurrection of life; and they that have 6done ill, unto the resurrection of judgement.

30    I can of myself do nothing: as I hear, I judge: and my judgement is righteous; because I seek not mine own will, but the will of him that sent me. 31 If I bear witness of myself, my witness is not true. 32 It is another that beareth witness of me; and I know that the witness which he witnesseth of me is true. 33 Ye have sent unto John, and he hath borne witness unto the truth. 34 But the witness which I receive is not from man: howbeit I say these things, that ye may be saved. 35 He was the lamp that burneth and shineth: and ye were willing to rejoice for a season in his light. 36 But the witness which I have is greater than that of John: for the works which the Father hath given me to accomplish, the very works that I do, bear witness of me, that the Father hath sent me. 37 And the Father which sent me, he hath borne witness of me. Ye have neither heard his voice at any time, nor seen his form. 38 And ye have not his word abiding in you: for whom he sent, him ye believe not. 39 7Ye search the scriptures, because ye think that in them ye have eternal life; and these are they which bear witness of me; 40 and ye will not come to me, that ye may have life. 41 I receive not glory from men. 42 But I know you, that ye have not the love of God in yourselves. 43 I am come in my Father's name, and ye receive me not: if another shall come in his own name, him ye will receive. 44 How can ye believe, which receive glory one of another, and the glory that cometh from 8the only God ye seek not? 45 Think not that I will accuse you to the Father: there is one that accuseth you, even Moses, on whom ye have set your hope. 46 For if ye believed Moses, ye would believe me; for he wrote of me. 47 But if ye believe not his writings, how shall ye believe my words?c

1 Many ancient authorities read the feast.
2 Some ancient authorities read Bethsaida, others Bethzatha.
3 Many ancient authorities insert, wholly or in part, waiting for the moving of the water: 4 for an angel of the Lord went down at certain seasons into the pool, and troubled the water: whosoever then first after the troubling of the water stepped in was made whole, with whatsoever disease he was holden.
4 Or, Lord.
5 Or, a son of man.
6 Or, practised.
7 Or, Search the scriptures.
8 Some ancient authorities read the only one.

a This feast of John 5:1 was most probably a Passover (see note at end of volume, note 7). If so, we should know that our Lord's public ministry lasted three years and a fraction, and that the great ministry in Galilee lasted some 18 to 20 months. Otherwise, we should know of only two years and a fraction for the former, and 6 to 8 months for the latter; as John gives three passovers beyond question (John 2:13; 6:4; 12:1), and our Lord's ministry began some time before the first of these. If the feast of 5:1 was not a passover, it is quite impossible to determine what other feast it was. While one would be glad to settle these questions, if it were possible, yet it really does not matter as regards understanding our Lord's recorded history and teachings during the great ministry in Galilee, the only point of difference being that if this feast was a Passover (or if there is an unmentioned Passover) we should conceive of the three journeys about Galilee as occupying a longer time, and including more extensive unrecorded labors in preaching and healing.

b It is to be noted that John's Gospel gives the Jerusalem Ministry of Jesus almost entirely except Galilee in ch. 2, Samaria and Galilee in ch. 4, Galilee in ch. 6 and again in ch. 21. It seems clear that John wrote with full knowledge of the Synoptic Gospels and supplements them at certain points. Both Luke and John were thus critics of the Gospel records.

c Observe that here more than a year before the crucifixion, and probably two years (i.e. if the feast of 5:1 was a passover or if an unnamed passover is granted), the hostility of the Jews at Jerusalem (comp. John 4:1) has reached the point of a desire to kill him, as a sabbath breaker and a blasphemer (5:16-18). So we shall find him staying away from Jerusalem at the passover of John 6:4, and until the Tabernacles six months before the crucifixion (John 7:1-10). Meantime, the hostility will go on increasing in other parts of the country (Mark 3:6, etc.).—Notice also that in this discourse at Jerusalem our Lord repeatedly declares himself in a high sense the Son of God, and the appointed judge of mankind (ver. 27), and says that Moses wrote concerning him (ver. 46). All this indicated that he was the Messiah, but he did not here expressly assert it as he did in Samaria (John 4:26). That would have precipitated the collision, for to claim to be the Messiah would in the view of the Jewish rulers involve political consequences. Comp. John 11:48.





§ 50. ANOTHER SABBATH CONTROVERSY WITH THE PHARISEES WHEN THE DISCIPLES PLUCK EARS OF GRAIN IN THE FIELDS

Probably in Galilee on the Way Back from Jerusalema


Mark 2:23-28 Matt. 12:1-8 Luke 6:1-5
23    And it came to
pass, that he was
going on the sabbath
day through the
cornfields; and his
disciples 3began, as
they went, to pluck the
ears of corn. 24 And
the Pharisees said
unto him, Behold,
why do they on the
sabbath day that
which is not lawful?
25        And he said
unto them, Did ye
never read what David
did, when he had
need, and was an
hungred, he, and
they that were with
him? 26 How he
entered into the house
of God 4when Abiathar
was high priest, and
did eat the shewbread,
which is not
lawful to eat, save
for the priests, and
gave also to them
that were with him?










27        And he said
unto them, The
sabbath was made for
man, and not man for
the sabbath: 28 so that
the Son of man is
lord even of the
sabbath.b
1    At that season Jesus
went on the sabbath
day through the
cornfields; and his
disciples were an
hungred, and began to
pluck ears of corn,
and to eat. 2 But the
Pharisees, when they
saw it, said unto
him, Behold, thy
disciples do that which
it is not lawful to do
upon the sabbath.
3 But he said unto
them, Have ye not
read what David did,
when he was an
hungred, and they that
were with him; 4 how
he entered into the
house of God, and
1did eat the shewbread,
which it was
not lawful for him
to eat, neither for
them that were with
him, but only for
the priests? 5 Or have
ye not read in the
law, how that on
the sabbath day the
priests in the temple
profane the sabbath
[see Num. 28:9-10],
and are guiltless?
6 But I say unto you,
that 2one greater than
the temple is here.
7 But if ye had known
what this meaneth
[see Hos. 6:6], I
desire mercy, and not
sacrifice, ye would not
have condemned the
guiltless. 8 For the
Son of man is lord of
the sabbath.
1    Now it came to
pass on a 5sabbath,
that he was going
through the cornfields
[see Deut. 23:25];
and his disciples
plucked the ears of
corn, and did eat,
rubbing them in their
hands. 2 But certain
of the Pharisees said,
Why do ye that which
is not lawful to do
on the sabbath day [see
John 5:10; Ex. 20:10;
Deut. 5:14
]? 3 And
Jesus answering them
said, Have ye not
read even this, what
David did, when he
was an hungred, he,
and they that were
with him [see Lev.
24:9; 1 Sam. 21:1-6
];
4 how he entered into
the house of God, and
did take and eat the
shewbread, and gave
also to them that
were with him; which
it is not lawful to eat
save for the priests
alone?











5         And he said
unto them, The Son
of man is lord of the
sabbath.
1 Some ancient authorities read they did eat.
2 Gr. a greater thing.
3 Gr. began to make their way plucking.
4 Some ancient authorities read in the days of Abiathar the high priest.
5 Many ancient authorities insert second-first.

a Because in Mark 3:7 Jesus withdraws to the Sea of Galilee.

b Note the five arguments made by Jesus in defence of the conduct of the disciples on the Sabbath (the historical appeal in the conduct of David, the appeal to the law about the temple service, the voice of prophecy, the purpose of God in the Sabbath, and the lordship of the Messiah over the Sabbath). Jesus had already (John 5:17) argued that he was equal to the Father and hence had the right to do certain things (acts of mercy) on the Sabbath.





§ 51. A THIRDa SABBATH CONTROVERSY WITH THE PHARISEES OVER THE HEALING OF A MAN WITH A WITHERED HAND IN A SYNAGOGUE

In Galilee


Mark 3:1-6 Matt. 12:9-14 Luke 6:6-11
1    And he entered
again into the
synagogue; and there
was a man there which
had his hand withered.

2    And they watched
him, whether he
would heal him on
the sabbath day; that
they might accuse
him.
3                And he
saith unto the man
that had his hand
withered, 1Stand
forth. 4 And he saith
unto them, Is it
lawful on the sabbath
day to do good, or
to do harm? to save
a life, or to kill? But
they held their peace.
5 And when he had
looked round about
on them with anger,
being grieved at the
hardening of their
heart, he saith unto
the man, Stretch
forth thy hand. And
he stretched it forth:
and his hand was
restored.

6        And the
Pharisees went out,
and straightway with
the Herodians took
counsel against him,
how they might
destroy him.b
9    And he departed
thence, and went into
their synagogue: 10 and
behold, a man having
a withered hand.

                    And
they asked him,
saying, Is it lawful to
heal on the sabbath
day? that they might
accuse him.
11                And he
said unto them, What
man shall there be
of you, that shall
have one sheep, and
if this fall into a pit
on the sabbath day,
will he not lay hold
on it, and lift it out?
12 How much then is a
man of more value
than a sheep!
Wherefore it is lawful
to do good on the
sabbath day.



13 Then saith he to the
man, Stretch forth
thy hand. And he
stretched it forth; and
it was restored whole,


as the other. 14 But
the Pharisees went
out, and took counsel
against him, how they
might destroy him.
6    And it came to
pass on another sab-
bath, that he entered
into the synagogue
and taught: and there
was a man there,
and his right hand
was withered. 7 And
the scribes and the
Pharisees watched
him, whether he
would heal on the
sabbath; that they
might find how to
accuse him. 8 But he
knew their thoughts;
and he said to the
man that had his
hand withered, Rise
up, and stand forth
in the midst. And
he arose and stood
forth. 9 And Jesus
said unto them, I ask
you, Is it lawful on
the sabbath to do
good, or to do harm?
to save a life, or to
destroy it? 10 And he
looked round about
on them all, and said
unto him, Stretch
forth thy hand. And
he did so: and his
hand was restored.


11 But they were filled
with 2madness; and
communed one with
another what they
might do to Jesus.
1 Gr. Arise into the midst.
2 Or, foolishness.

a On three other later occasions controversies arise with the Pharisees concerning Sabbath observance (John 9:1-34; Luke 13:10-21; 14:1-24). In John 7:20-24 Jesus refers to the miracle in John 5 and adds another argument (circumcision on the Sabbath) for his conduct on the Sabbath.

b Here at some point near the sea of Galilee, there is already a plot to kill him, as some had wished to do in Jerusalem (comp. on § 49).