| a. | Leaves persistent and green throughout the winter, needle-shaped, awl-shaped or scale-like. | ||||||||||||||
| b. | Leaves in clusters of 2-5, sheathed. | PINUS, p. 5. | |||||||||||||
| bb. | Leaves solitary, not clustered. | ||||||||||||||
| c. | Leaves opposite. | ||||||||||||||
| d. | Twigs flattened; leaves all of one kind, scale-like, decurrent on the stem; fruit a small, pale brown cone. | THUJA, p. 31. | |||||||||||||
| dd. | Twigs essentially terete; leaves of two kinds, either scale-like, or else awl-shaped, often both kinds on the same branch, not decurrent on the stem; fruit berry-like, bluish. | JUNIPERUS, p. 33. | |||||||||||||
| cc. | Leaves alternate or spirally-whorled. | ||||||||||||||
| d. | Leaves flattened, soft to the touch. | ||||||||||||||
| e. | Leaves 1/2 - 1-1/4 inches long, sessile, aromatic; cones 2-4 inches long; bark of trunk with raised blisters containing resin. | ABIES, p. 27. | |||||||||||||
| ee. | Leaves seldom over 1/2 inch long, short-petioled, not aromatic; cones about 3/4 inch long; bark of trunk without raised blisters. | TSUGA, p. 29. | |||||||||||||
| dd. | Leaves 4-sided, harsh to the touch. | PICEA, p. 19. | |||||||||||||
| aa. | Leaves not persistent and green throughout the winter, but deciduous in early autumn. | ||||||||||||||
| b. | Twigs, branches or trunks armed with stiff, sharp prickles, spines or thorns. | ||||||||||||||
| c. | Thorns or spines not exceeding 1/2 inch in length on the branches. | ||||||||||||||
| d. | Spines in pairs at each node; buds rusty-hairy, 3-4 superposed; fruit a flat pod. | ROBINIA, p. 169. | |||||||||||||
| dd. | Spines one at each node; buds glabrous, not superposed; fruit orange-like. | MACLURA, p. 133. | |||||||||||||
| cc. | Thorns or spines much exceeding 1/2 inch in length on the branches. | ||||||||||||||
| d. | Thorns usually branched, situated above the nodes; lateral buds superposed, the lower covered by bark; fruit a flat pod. | GLEDITSIA, p. 165. | |||||||||||||
| dd. | Thorns unbranched on twigs, situated at the nodes; lateral buds not superposed, not covered by bark; fruit a small pome. | CRATAEGUS, p. 151. | |||||||||||||
| bb. | Twigs, branches or trunks unarmed. | ||||||||||||||
| c. | Leaf-scars mainly crowded on short, stout, lateral shoots. | ||||||||||||||
| d. | Bundle-scar 1; fruit a cone, usually present. | LARIX, p. 17. | |||||||||||||
| dd. | Bundle-scars 2; fruit a globose drupe falling in autumn. | GINKGO, p. 3. | |||||||||||||
| cc. | Leaf-scars distributed along the lateral branches. | ||||||||||||||
| d. | Leaf-scars (or some of them) 3 at a node, i. e., whorled. | CATALPA, p. 223. | |||||||||||||
| dd. | Leaf-scars 1-2 at a node, i.e., not whorled. | ||||||||||||||
| e. | Leaf-scars 2 at a node, i.e., opposite. | ||||||||||||||
| f. | Terminal buds 1/2 - 1-1/2 inches long, resin-coated; twigs very stout. | AESCULUS, p. 195. | |||||||||||||
| ff. | Terminal buds rarely exceeding 1/2 inch in length, not resin-coated; twigs not conspicuously stout. | ||||||||||||||
| g. | Leaf buds with 1 pair of scales visible. | ||||||||||||||
| h. | Buds scurfy-pubescent. | VIBURNUM, p. 229. | |||||||||||||
| hh. | Buds glabrous. | CORNUS, p. 203. | |||||||||||||
| gg. | Leaf buds with 2 or more pairs of scales visible. | ||||||||||||||
| h. | Bundle-scars usually 3, distinct, separated. | ACER, p. 174. | |||||||||||||
| hh. | Bundle-scars many, minute, more or less confluent in a U-shaped line. | FRAXINUS, p. 211. | |||||||||||||
| ee. | Leaf-scars 1 at a node, i.e., alternate. | ||||||||||||||
| f. | Bundle-scars 1-3. | ||||||||||||||
| g. | Bundle-scar only 1, or appearing as 1. | ||||||||||||||
| h. | Twigs bright green, spicy-aromatic; bundle-scar appearing as a horizontal line; terminal bud present; pith homogeneous. | SASSAFRAS, p. 139. | |||||||||||||
| hh. | Twigs brownish, not spicy-aromatic; bundle-scar appearing as a large dot; terminal bud absent; pith chambered. | CELTIS, p. 131. | |||||||||||||
| gg. | Bundle-scars 3 or in 3 compound, but distinct groups. | ||||||||||||||
| h. | Terminal bud present. | ||||||||||||||
| i. | Stipule-scars present. | ||||||||||||||
| j. | First scale of lateral bud directly in front, i.e., exactly above the center of the leaf-scar; twigs brittle; pith somewhat star-shaped in cross-section. | POPULUS, p. 45. | |||||||||||||
| jj. | First scale of lateral bud not directly in front, i. e., to one side of the center of the leaf-scar; twigs not brittle; pith circular in cross-section. | PRUNUS, p. 153. | |||||||||||||
| ii. | Stipule-scars absent. | ||||||||||||||
| j. | Buds bright to dark red, the terminal 1/8 - 1/4 inch long. | ||||||||||||||
| k. | Branches contorted, bearing many short, spur-like branchlets; fruit an apple an inch or more in diameter, light green. | PYRUS, p. 143. | |||||||||||||
| kk. | Branches not contorted, not bearing short, spur-like branchlets; fruit berry-like, 1/2 inch long, blue-black. | NYSSA, p. 209. | |||||||||||||
| jj. | Buds brownish to gray, the terminal exceeding 1/4 inch in length. | ||||||||||||||
| k. | Buds narrow-conical, sharp-pointed; leaf-scars small, narrowly crescent-shaped; twigs about 1/16 inch thick; pith homogeneous; fruit berry-like, not present. | AMELANCHIER, p. 149. | |||||||||||||
| kk. | Buds broadly conical to ovoid, blunt-pointed; leaf-scars conspicuous, broadly heart-shaped; twigs about 1/4 inch thick; pith chambered; fruit a nut, often present. | JUGLANS, p. 61. | |||||||||||||
| hh. | Terminal bud absent (sometimes present on short shoots of Betula). | ||||||||||||||
| i. | Stipule-scars present. | ||||||||||||||
| j. | Bud-scale only 1 visible; twigs brittle. | SALIX, p. 34. | |||||||||||||
| jj. | Bud-scales 2 or more; twigs not brittle. | ||||||||||||||
| k. | Bark smooth, close, warty or peeling into papery layers, but not flaky nor rough-ridged. | ||||||||||||||
| l. | Tip of bud appressed; fruit berry-like. | CELTIS, p. 131. | |||||||||||||
| ll. | Tip of bud not appressed; fruit not berry-like. | ||||||||||||||
| m. | Trunk fluted; catkins not present in winter; lenticels not elongated horizontally; low tree or bushy shrub. | CARPINUS, p. 83. | |||||||||||||
| mm. | Trunk not fluted; catkins usually present in winter; lenticels elongated horizontally; large trees. | BETULA, p. 85. | |||||||||||||
| kk. | Bark flaky or rough-ridged, not warty nor peeling off in papery layers. | ||||||||||||||
| l. | Bundle-scars depressed, conspicuous; bark thick, more or less deeply furrowed. | ULMUS, p. 123. | |||||||||||||
| ll. | Bundle-scars not depressed, inconspicuous; bark thin, broken into narrow, flattish strips, loose at the ends. | OSTRYA, p. 81. | |||||||||||||
| ii. | Stipule-scars absent. | ||||||||||||||
| j. | Buds silky-pubescent, depressed; twigs stout, clumsy, blunt, with conspicuous leaf-scars. | GYMNOCLADUS, p. 163. | |||||||||||||
| jj. | Buds glabrous, not depressed; twigs slender, with inconspicuous leaf-scars. | ||||||||||||||
| k. | Buds 1/8 inch long, obtuse, somewhat flattened and appressed; pith with reddish longitudinal streaks. | CERCIS, p. 167. | |||||||||||||
| kk. | Buds 1/8-1/4 inch long, acute, not flattened nor appressed; pith without reddish streaks. | PRUNUS, p. 153. | |||||||||||||
| ff. | Bundle-scars 4-many. | ||||||||||||||
| g. | Bundle-scars in a single U-shaped line. | ||||||||||||||
| h. | Terminal bud present; fruit berry-like; a shrub or small tree. | PYRUS, p. 143. | |||||||||||||
| hh. | Terminal bud absent; fruit not berry-like; large trees. | ||||||||||||||
| i. | Stipule-scars present; twigs slender. | ||||||||||||||
| j. | Stipule-scars encircling the twig; leaf-scars nearly surrounding the bud; bark peeling off in thin plates, exposing the lighter colored inner bark. | PLATANUS, p. 141. | |||||||||||||
| jj. | Stipule-scars not encircling the twig; leaf-scars not nearly surrounding the bud; bark thick, rough-ridged, not exposing the inner bark. | ULMUS, p. 123. | |||||||||||||
| ii. | Stipule-scars absent; twigs very stout. | ||||||||||||||
| j. | Bundle-scars usually not more than 5. | GYMNOCLADUS, p. 163. | |||||||||||||
| jj. | Bundle-scars usually 6-12. | AILANTHUS, p. 171. | |||||||||||||
| gg. | Bundle-scars variously grouped or scattered, but not in a single line. | ||||||||||||||
| h. | Terminal bud present. | ||||||||||||||
| i. | Stipule-scars present. | ||||||||||||||
| j. | Stipule-scars encircling the twig; visible bud-scales 2, united. | LIRIODENDRON, p. 137. | |||||||||||||
| jj. | Stipule-scars not encircling the twig; visible bud-scales more than 2, not united. | ||||||||||||||
| k. | Buds 4 times as long as broad, not clustered at the tips of vigorous shoots; fruit a prickly bur. | FAGUS, p. 93. | |||||||||||||
| kk. | Buds not 4 times as long as broad, usually clustered at the tips of vigorous shoots; fruit an acorn. | QUERCUS, p. 98. | |||||||||||||
| ii. | Stipule-scars absent. | CARYA, p. 67. | |||||||||||||
| h. | Terminal bud absent (occasionally present in Castanea). | ||||||||||||||
| i. | Bud at end of twig very obliquely unsymmetrical, mucilaginous when chewed. | TILIA, p. 201. | |||||||||||||
| ii. | Bud at end of twig symmetrical, not mucilaginous when chewed. | ||||||||||||||
| j. | Bud-scales 2-3 visible; pith star-shaped in cross-section; sap not milky; fruit a prickly bur, present; large tree. | CASTANEA, p. 95. | |||||||||||||
| jj. | Bud-scales 4-8 visible; pith not star-shaped in cross-section; sap milky; fruit berry-like, not present; small tree. | MORUS, p. 135. | |||||||||||||
Ginkgo. Maidenhair Tree
Ginkgo. Maidenhair TreeHABIT.—A slender tree in youth, with slender, upright branches, becoming broader with age and forming a symmetrical, pyramidal crown; probably 60-80 feet high, with a trunk diameter of 2-4 feet.
LEAVES.—Clustered at the ends of short, spur-like shoots, or scattered alternately on the long terminal branches; simple; 2-5 inches broad; more or less fan-shaped; usually bilobed and irregularly crenate at the upper extremity; thin and leathery; glabrous, pale yellow-green on both sides; petioles long, slender; turning a clear, golden yellow before falling in autumn.
FLOWERS.—May, with the leaves; dioecious; the staminate in short-stalked, pendulous catkins, 1 to 1-1/2 inches long, yellow; the pistillate more or less erect on the shoot, long-stalked, consisting of 2 naked ovules, one of which usually aborts.
FRUIT.—Autumn; a more or less globose drupe, orange-yellow to green, about 1 inch in diameter, consisting of an acrid, foul-smelling pulp inclosing a smooth, whitish, somewhat flattened, almond-flavored nut.
WINTER-BUDS.—Terminal bud about 1/8 inch long, conical, smooth, light chestnut-brown; lateral buds divergent, usually only on rapid-growing shoots.
BARK.—Twigs gray-brown and smooth; thick, ash-gray and somewhat roughened on the trunk, becoming more or less fissured in old age.
WOOD.—Light, soft, weak, close-grained, yellow-white to light red-brown, with thin, lighter colored sapwood.
NOTES.—Origin in dispute, but probably a native of northern China. Extensively cultivated in China and Japan, where its fruit is esteemed. Easily propagated from seed. Thrives in deep, well-drained, rich soil. Practically free from insect and fungous attacks, and little harmed by the smoke of cities. Probably hardy throughout the southern half of the Lower Peninsula.
| a. | Leaves 5 in a cluster; cones 4-10 inches long. | P. strobus, p. 7. | ||
| aa. | Leaves 2 in a cluster; cones less than 4 inches long. | |||
| b. | Leaves 1-3 inches long. | |||
| c. | Leaves about 1 inch long, divergent; cones sessile, pointing forward towards the tip of the branch, persistent 10-15 years, opening very unevenly. | P. banksiana, p. 9. | ||
| cc. | Leaves 1-1/2-3 inches long, slightly divergent; cones stout-stalked, pointing away from the tip of the branch, maturing in second season, opening evenly. | P. sylvestris, p. 13. | ||
| bb. | Leaves 3-6 inches long. | |||
| c. | Bark of trunk red-brown; cones maturing in second season, about 2 inches long; cone-scales thickened at the apex, but unarmed. | P. resinosa, p. 15. | ||
| cc. | Bark of trunk gray to nearly black; cones maturing in first season, 2-3 inches long; cone-scales thickened at the apex and topped with a short spine. | P. laricio austriaca, p. 11. | ||
| a. | Leaves 5 in a cluster; cones 4-10 inches long. | P. strobus, p. 7. | ||
| aa. | Leaves 2 in a cluster; cones less than 4 inches long. | |||
| b. | Leaves 1-3 inches long. | |||
| c. | Leaves about 1 inch long, divergent; cones sessile, pointing forward towards the tip of the branch, persistent 10-15 years, opening very unevenly. | P. banksiana, p. 9. | ||
| cc. | Leaves 1-1/2-3 inches long, slightly divergent; cones stout-stalked, pointing away from the tip of the branch, maturing in second season, opening evenly. | P. sylvestris, p. 13. | ||
| bb. | Leaves 3-6 inches long. | |||
| c. | Bark of trunk red-brown; cones maturing in second season, about 2 inches long; cone-scales thickened at the apex, but unarmed. | P. resinosa, p. 15. | ||
| cc. | Bark of trunk gray to nearly black; cones maturing in first season, 2-3 inches long; cone-scales thickened at the apex and topped with a short spine. | P. laricio austriaca, p. 11. | ||
White Pine
White PineHABIT.—A large tree 60-80 feet high, with a trunk diameter of 2-4 feet; forming a wide, pyramidal crown. Formerly trees 100-150 feet in height and 5-7 feet in trunk diameter were not exceptional.
LEAVES.—In clusters of five; 3-5 inches long; slender, straight, needle-shaped, 3-sided, mucronate; pale blue-green. Persistent about 2 years.
FLOWERS.—June; monoecious; the staminate oval, light brown, about 1/3 inch long, surrounded by 6-8 involucral bracts; the pistillate cylindrical, about 1/4 inch long, pinkish purple, long-stalked.
FRUIT.—Autumn of second season, falling during the winter and succeeding spring; pendent, short-stalked, narrow-cylindrical, often curved, greenish cones, 4-10 inches long; scales rather loose, slightly thickened at the apex; seeds red-brown, 1/4 inch long, with wings 1 inch long.
WINTER-BUDS.—Oblong-ovoid, sharp-pointed, yellow-brown, 1/4-1/2 inch long.
BARK.—Twigs at first rusty-tomentose, later smooth and light brown, finally thin, smooth, greenish; thick, dark gray on the trunk, shallowly fissured into broad, scaly ridges.
WOOD.—Light, soft, weak, compact, straight-grained, easily worked, light brown, with thin, whitish sapwood.
DISTRIBUTION.—Upper Peninsula and Lower Peninsula north of Allegan, Eaton and St. Clair Counties. Often planted as an ornamental tree farther south.
HABITAT.—Prefers a light, fertile loam; sandy soils of granite origin.
NOTES.—Rapid of growth. Small seedlings easily transplanted. Formerly very abundant, but rapidly nearing extinction through destructive lumbering.
Jack Pine. Scrub Pine
Jack Pine. Scrub PineHABIT.—Usually a small tree 20-30 feet high, with a trunk diameter of 8-12 inches; forming a crown varying from open and symmetrical to scrubby, stunted, and variously distorted.
LEAVES.—In clusters of two; about 1 inch long; narrow-linear, with sharp-pointed apex; stout, curved or twisted, divergent from a short sheath; dark gray-green. Persistent 2-3 years.
FLOWERS.—May-June; monoecious; the staminate in oblong clusters 1/2 inch long, composed of many sessile, yellow anthers imbricated upon a central axis; the pistillate in subglobose clusters, composed of many carpel-like, purple scales (subtended by small bracts) spirally arranged upon a central axis.
FRUIT.—Autumn of second or third season, but remaining closed for several years and persistent on the tree for 10-15 years; erect, usually incurved, oblong-conical, sessile cones, 1-1/2-2 inches long; scales thickened at the apex; seeds triangular, nearly black, 3/8 inch long, with wings 1/3 inch long.
WINTER-BUDS.—Terminal bud 1/4 inch long, ovoid, rounded, pale brown; lateral buds smaller.
BARK.—Twigs yellow-green, becoming purple, finally dark red-brown and rough with the persistent bases of fallen leaves; thin, dark red-brown on the trunk, with shallow, rounded ridges, rough-scaly on the surface.
WOOD.—Light, soft, weak, close-grained, light brown, with thick, whitish sapwood.
DISTRIBUTION.—Common from Clare County northward; occurs sparingly along the lake shore as far south as Grand Haven on the west and Port Austin on the east.
HABITAT—Sandy, sterile soil.
NOTES.—Cones open unevenly. Slow of growth. Difficult to transplant.
Austrian Pine. Black Pine
Austrian Pine. Black PineHABIT.—A large tree 60-80 feet high, with a trunk diameter of 2-4 feet; forming a massive, spreading crown of stiff, strong branches.
LEAVES.—In clusters of two; 3-6 inches long; slender, rigid, sharp-pointed, curved towards the twig; deep green on both faces. Persistent 3-6 years.
FLOWERS.—May-June; monoecious; the staminate cylindrical, subsessile, bright yellow, about 3/4 inch long; the pistillate cylindrical, small, bright red, subsessile.
FRUIT.—Autumn of first season, opening two years after full size is attained and remaining on the tree several years; erect, sessile, long-ovoid cones 2-3 inches long; scales smooth, lustrous, thickened at the apex and topped with a short spine in the center; seeds red-brown, 1/4 inch long, with wings 3/4 inch long.
WINTER-BUDS.—Oblong-conical, sharp-pointed, red-brown, resinous, about 1/2 inch long.
BARK.—Twigs brownish to olive-brown and smooth, becoming darker with age; thick, gray to nearly black on old trunks and coarsely and deeply fissured.
WOOD.—Light, strong, very resinous, red-brown, with thick, yellowish to reddish white sapwood.
NOTES.—Perfectly hardy. Adapts itself to a variety of soils. Well adapted for screens and wind-breaks. Easily transplanted when small. Grows rapidly.
Scotch Pine. Scotch Fir
Scotch Pine. Scotch FirHABIT.—A large tree 60-80 feet high, with a trunk diameter of 1-2 feet; the side branches persist, forming a massive, wide-spreading crown.
LEAVES.—In clusters of two; 1-1/2-3 inches long; stiff, more or less twisted, spreading slightly from a short sheath; bluish- or often glaucous-green. Persistent 3-4 years.
FLOWERS.—May-June; monoecious; the staminate ovoid, short-stalked, yellowish, about 1/4 inch long; the pistillate oblong, reddish, short-stalked, about 1/4 inch long.
FRUIT.—Autumn of second season, falling as soon as ripe; pendent, stout-stalked, ovoid-conical cones 1-1/2-2-1/2 inches long; scales dull gray-brown, thickened at the apex into 4-sided, recurved points; seeds red-brown, nearly 1/4 inch long, with wings about 3/4 inch long.
WINTER-BUDS.—Oblong-ovoid, sharp-pointed, red-brown, resinous, about 1/4 inch long.
BARK.—Twigs reddish to orange-brown, becoming grayish; thick, dark orange-brown on old trunks and coarsely and deeply fissured.
WOOD.—Light, stiff, straight-grained, strong, heavy, hard, resinous, red-brown, with thick, yellow to reddish white sapwood.
NOTES.—Very rapid of growth. Reaches perfection only in cold or elevated regions. Adapts itself to a variety of soils. A valuable ornamental tree. Very useful for screens or shelter belts.
Red Pine, Norway Pine
Red Pine, Norway PineHABIT.—A large tree 70-80 feet high, with a trunk diameter of 2-3 feet; stout, horizontal branches, form a broad, rounded, rather open crown.
LEAVES.—In clusters of two; 4-6 inches long; slender, straight, needle-shaped, sharp-pointed, flexible, from elongated, persistent sheaths; lustrous dark green. Persistent 4-5 years.
FLOWERS.—April-May; monoecious; the staminate in oblong, dense clusters, 1/2-3/4 inch long, composed of many sessile, purple anthers imbricated upon a central axis; the pistillate single or few-clustered at the end of the branchlets, subglobose; scales ovate, scarlet, borne on stout peduncles covered with pale brown bracts.
FRUIT.—Autumn of second season, falling the next summer; ovoid-conical, nearly sessile cones, about 2 inches long; scales thickened at the apex; seeds oval, compressed, light mottled-brown, with wings 1/2-3/4 inch long.
WINTER-BUDS.—About 3/4 inch long, ovoid or conical, acute, red-brown, with rather loose scales.
BARK.—Twigs orange-brown, becoming rough with the persistent bases of leaf-buds; thick and red-brown on the trunk, shallowly fissured into broad, flat ridges.
WOOD.—Light, hard, very close-grained, pale red, with thin, yellow to white sapwood.
DISTRIBUTION.—Very abundant in Clare County and northward; frequent on the east side of the state as far south as Port Huron.
HABITAT.—Sandy plains and dry woods.
NOTES.—Rapid of growth on the better soils. Difficult to transplant.
Tamarack
TamarackHABIT.—A tree sometimes 80-100 feet high, with a trunk diameter of 1-2 feet; forming a broad, open, irregular crown of horizontal branches.
LEAVES.—Scattered singly along the leading shoots or clustered on the short lateral branchlets; linear, with blunt apex; rounded above, keeled beneath; about 1 inch long; bright green; sessile. Deciduous in early autumn.
FLOWERS.—April-May, with the leaves, monoecious; the staminate sessile, subglobose, yellow, composed of many short-stalked anthers spirally arranged about a central axis; the pistillate oblong, short-stalked, composed of orbicular, green scales (subtended by red bracts) spirally arranged about a central axis.
FRUIT.—Autumn of first season, but persistent on the tree for a year longer; ovoid, obtuse, light brown, short-stalked cones, 1/2-3/4 inch long; seeds 1/8 inch long, with pale brown wings widest near the middle.
WINTER-BUDS.—Small, globose, lustrous, dark red.
BARK.—Twigs at first grayish, glaucous, later light orange-brown, and finally dark brown; red-brown and scaly on the trunk.
WOOD.—Heavy, hard, very strong, coarse-grained, very durable, light brown, with thin, nearly white sapwood.
DISTRIBUTION.—Common throughout the state.
HABITAT.—Prefers cold, deep swamps, or in the north coming out on the drier uplands.
NOTES.—Becomes a picturesque tree in old age. Should be transplanted while dormant.
| a. | Leaves 3/4-1 inch long, sharp-pointed; twigs glabrous. | ||
| b. | Cones 1-2 inches long, maturing in first season; leaves ill-scented when bruised. | P. canadensis, p. 21. | |
| bb. | Cones 3-6 inches long, maturing in second season; leaves not ill-scented when bruised. | P. abies, p. 25. | |
| aa. | Leaves 1/8-3/8 inch long, blunt-pointed; twigs rusty-pubescent. | P. mariana, p. 23. | |
| a. | Leaves 3/4-1 inch long, sharp-pointed; twigs glabrous. | ||
| b. | Cones 1-2 inches long, maturing in first season; leaves ill-scented when bruised. | P. canadensis, p. 21. | |
| bb. | Cones 3-6 inches long, maturing in second season; leaves not ill-scented when bruised. | P. abies, p. 25. | |
| aa. | Leaves 1/8-3/8 inch long, blunt-pointed; twigs rusty-pubescent. | P. mariana, p. 23. | |