CHAPTER VIII.
WOODEN BRIDGES.

139. Wooden bridging, owing to its cheapness and fitness for universal application, has been and is being adopted in all parts of the country. Almost any variety of form may be seen upon our railroads, and though less durable than stone or iron, it may with proper precaution be made to last a long time.

OF THE FORCES AT WORK IN BRIDGES.

140. There are four distinct strains to which a piece of timber or a bar of metal may be exposed, each of which tends to destroy the piece in a different manner. The amount and character of these strains, depend upon the position of the bar or beam, and upon the direction of the force.

A beam may be pulled apart by stretching,—Tension.

It may be destroyed by crushing,—Compression.

It may be broken transversely,—Cross strain.

It may be crushed across the grain,—Detrusion.

TENSION.

141. If one thousand pounds were hung from the end of a suspended timber, so that the direction of the weight coincides with the axis of the timber, then will the tension upon the beam be one thousand pounds.

If the direction of the force is vertical, and the beam is inclined, then the strain is increased by as much as the diagonal of inclination exceeds the vertical; for example, let one thousand pounds be suspended from the lower end of a beam ten feet long, inclined at an angle of 45°. The diagonal being ten, the vertical will be 7.07 feet, and the strain is increased as follows:—

7.07 to 10 as 1,000 to 1,414 lbs.

As the angle of inclination, from the horizontal, increases, the strain from a given load decreases, until the beam is vertical, when a weight acts with its least power.

COMPRESSION.

142. If a vertical post is loaded with one thousand pounds, the compressive strain upon that post will also be one thousand pounds. If a post is inclined, the amount of strain is increased, as noticed in the case of tension, and to the same amount, that is, depending upon the inclination.

A piece of wood or metal acting as a post, or pillar, must not only be able to resist crushing, but also bending or bulging laterally.

143. A cylinder of which the length is only seven or eight times the diameter, will not bulge by any force that can be applied to it longitudinally, but will split. When the length exceeds this, it will be destroyed by a similar movement to that produced by a cross strain. When the length of a cast-iron pillar is thirty diameters, the fracture is produced by bending alone; when less, partly by bending and partly by fracture. When the column is cast hollow, and enlarged towards the middle, the strength is increased in a very great ratio.

144. The formula for finding the weight which any beam acting as a post, will support before bending, is, according to Barlow, who considers the weight as varying inversely as the length, as follows:—

WL2
80E
= bd3,

and the value of W is

bd3 × 80E
L2
,

and the weight being given, and the sectional dimensions assumed, we have

d = ∛(WL2
80Eb
),

and

b = WL2
80Ed3
,
Where W represents the weight in pounds,
L represents the length in feet,
E represents a constant,
d represents the depth in inches,
b represents the breadth in inches.

CROSS STRAIN.

145. The amount of strain caused by any weight applied in a transverse direction, to a beam supported at both ends, is as the breadth, as the length inversely, and as the square of the depth. Whatever depression takes place, tends to shorten the upper, and to extend the under-side; whence the fibres of the top part suffer compression, and those of the bottom extension. The amounts of compression and extension must of course be equal, and therefore if any material resists these two strains in a different degree, the number of fibres opposing each will also be different.

The top being compressed, while the bottom is extended, of course at some point within the beam there exists a line which suffers neither compression nor extension. The position of this line (the neutral axis) depends upon the relative power of the material to oppose the strains, upon its form and upon its position. Thus if wood resists two thousand pounds per square inch of extension, and one thousand pounds of compression, the axis will be twice as far from the top as from the bottom.

In some materials the neutral axis changes its place while the bar is at work; thus wrought iron, after being a little compressed, will bear a great deal more compression than when in its original state; also the lower fibres, after being extended, will resist less than at first; the effect of which two actions is to move the neutral axis up.

146. The following table shows the relative resisting powers of wood, wrought and cast-iron; with the corresponding positions of the axis, with sufficient accuracy for practice.

Material. Resistance to extension. Resistance to compression. Ratio. Distance of axis from top, in fractions of the depth.
 
Wrought iron, 90 66 90
66
90
156
or 0.58
Cast-iron, 20 111 20
111
20
131
or 0.15
Wood, 2 1 2
1
or 0.66

Thus in beams subjected to a cross strain, as well as to a direct extensile or compressive one, the resistance is effected by the incompressibility and inextensibility of the material.

147. The formula for dimensioning any beam to support a given weight transversely is

S = 4bd2
e
,
Where S represents the ultimate strength in lbs.
b represents the breadth in inches,
d represents the depth in inches,
e represents the length in inches,

DETRUSION.

148. Detrusion, or crushing across a fixed point, is such as occurs wherever a brace abuts against a chord, or where a bridge bears upon a bolster or wall plate; also the shearing of bolts, pins, and rivets.

GENERAL RESISTANCE OF MATERIALS.

149. The resistance to extension, to compression, (as regards simple crushing,) and to detrusion, is as the area of cross section; i. e., if we double the area, we double the strength. The resistance to a cross strain is as the breadth, as the length inversely, and as the square of the depth; i. e. if we double the breadth we double the strength; if we double the length, we divide the strength by two; and if we double the depth, we multiply the strength by four.

ACTUAL STRENGTH OF MATERIALS.

150. Any material will bear a much larger load for a short time than for a long one. The weight that does not so injure materials as to render them unsafe, is from one third to one fourth only of the ultimate strength. Throughout the present work one fourth will be the most that will in any case be used.

WROUGHT IRON.

151. Extension.

lbs. per square inch.
Mean of 17 experiments by Barlow (p. 270) 62,720
Weisbach’s Mechanics (Vol. ii., p. 71) 60,500
Overman’s Mechanics, (p. 408, 409) 61,333
Brown, Rennie, and Telford, (mean) 65,251
 
The mean 62,451
 
Reducing by 4 for safety 15,613

Or in round numbers 15,000 lbs. per square inch, is the resistance of wrought iron to extension, to be used in practice.

152. Compression.—Great discrepancies appear among writers on the strength of materials, as to the compressive strength of wrought iron. Though all estimate the resistance to compression, as great as to extension, yet no one in summing up the general result of experiment, places the former at more than from 50 to 75 per cent. of the latter. William Fairbairn gives, as the relative resistances to extension and compression in bars applied as girders, 2 to 1.

We have by Weisbach 56,000  
We have by Rondelet 70,000  
We have by Hodgkinson 65,000  
 
 
The mean 63,667  
 
 
Reducing by 4 15,917  
 
 
In round numbers 16,000 lbs. per square inch.

As far as practice is any guide, from 8,000 to 12,000 pounds per inch is the most to be used. The ratio of 90 to 66, seems to express very nearly the action as in the most reliable structures; which will, therefore, be adopted, or 11,000 pounds per square inch nearly. The resistance to compression is very much greater after wrought iron has been somewhat compressed.

CAST-IRON.

153. Extension.—This material is seldom used to resist a tensile force. That the tables may be complete, however, the following is given:—

By Weisbach 20,000 pounds.
By Barlow 18,233 pounds.
By Overman 20,000 pounds.
By Rennie 18,000 pounds.
By Hodgkinson 16,577 pounds.
By the British Iron Commission 15,711 pounds.
 
 
The mean 18,087 pounds.
 
 
Reducing by 4 4,522 pounds.
 
 
In round numbers 4,500 pounds.

154. Compression.

By Weisbach 109,800 pounds.
By Hodgkinson 107,520 pounds.
By Iron Commission 100,000 pounds.
Stirling’s toughened 130,000 pounds.
 
 
Mean of Common 105,773 pounds.
 
 
Mean of Stirling’s 130,000 pounds.
 
 
Reducing by 4 for safety (Common) 26,443 pounds.
 
 
Reducing by 4 for safety (Stirling’s) 32,500 pounds.
 
 
In round numbers (Common) 25,000 pounds.
 
 
In round numbers (Stirling’s) 30,000 pounds.

155. Following are given the condensed results of the preceding figures, which may be relied upon as giving perfectly safe dimensions in practice.

Wrought Iron. Cast-Iron.  
15,000 4,500 Tensile strength,
11,000 25,000 Compressive strength.

For additional remarks on iron, see chap. IX.

156. Nature and Strength of American Woods.

Name of the wood. Weight per cubic foot. Resistance to Extension. Resistance to Compression. Value of S. Elasticity.
 
White Pine 26 12,000 6,000 1,229
Yellow Pine 31 12,000 6,000 1,185
Pitch Pine 46 12,000 6,000 1,727 4,900
Red Pine 35 12,000 6,000 1,527 7,359
Virginia Pine 37 12,000 6,000 1,456
Spruce 48 12,000 6,000 1,036
Larch 33 12,000 6,000 907 2,465
Tamarack 26 12,000 6,000 907
White Cedar 22 8,000 4,000 766
Canada Balsam 34 12,000 6,000 1,123
White Oak 48 15,000 7,500 1,743 8,595
Red Oak 41 15,000 7,600 1,687
Live Oak 72 15,000 7,200 1,862
White Beech 44 18,000 9,100 1,380 5,417
Red Beech 48 18,000 9,000 1,739
Birch 44 15,000 7,000 1,928
Black Birch 41 15,000 7,200 2,061
Yellow Birch 36 15,000 7,200 1,335
Ash 38 16,000 8,100 1,795 6,581
Black Ash 35 16,000 8,000 861
Swamp Ash 57 16,000 8,000 1,165
Hickory 51 15,000 7,200 2,129
Butternut 54 15,000 7,600 1,465
Ironwood 54 16,000 8,100 1,800
Rock Elm 45 16,000 8,011 1,970 2,799
The mean tensile strength of wood is 14,080 lbs.
Reducing by 4 for safety 3,520 lbs.
Reducing for want of seasoning 2,000 lbs.
The reduced mean compressive strength 1,000 lbs.
Reduced resistance to detrusion 150 lbs.
Ratio of tensile to compressive strength 2 to 1.  
Mean value of S in formula (WL = 4Sbd2) for the woods most used in practice 1,250.  

157. The lateral adhesion of fir was found, by Barlow, to be six hundred pounds per square inch. (Lateral adhesion is the resistance which the fibres offer to sliding past each other in the direction of the grain; as, in pulling off the top of a post where it is halved on to the chord.)

158. As regards the nature of timber, seasoning, time of cutting, etc., although these are important items, still, generally, commercial considerations outbalance all else. The most complete treatise on the nature of woods, is “Du Hamel, L′exploitation des bois;” from which it appears that the best oaks, elms, and other large trees, are the product of good lands, rather dry than moist. They have a fine, clear bark, the sap is thinner in proportion to the diameter of the trunk, the layers are less thick, but more adherent the one to another; and more uniform than those of trees growing on moist places. The grain of the latter may look very fine and compact, but microscopic examination shows the pores to be full of gluten.

The density of the same species of timber, in the same climate, but on different soils, will vary as 7 to 5; and the strength, both before and after seasoning, as 5 to 4.

In trees not beyond their prime, the density of the butt is to that of the top, as 4 to 3; and of centre to circumference, as 7 to 5. After maturity, the reverse occurs in both cases.

Oak, in seasoning, loses from ¼ to ⅓ of its weight; but its strength is increased from 30 to 40 per cent.

GENERAL TABLE OF THE NATURE OF MATERIALS.

159. The tensile strength of wrought iron assumed as 1,000.

Material. Tension. Compression. Cross Strain. Sum. Weight per cubic ft. Sum divided by weight per cub. ft.
Cast-Iron 300 1,666 31.68 1,997.68 450 4.4
Wrought Iron 1,000 733 55.40 1,788.40 480 3.7
Wood 133 66 5.60 204.60 30 6.8

The advantage possessed by iron over wood, is in durability only. The above figures show how much more of the strength of the material is consumed by its own weight in iron than in wood. In actual practice, however, the method of making joints and other details often render iron the lightest material.

RULES FOR PRACTICE.

TENSION.

160. The tensile strength of any material, is expressed by the formula

T = Sa,
Where T represents the whole strength,
S represents the strength per square inch,
a represents the area of section in inches.

whence the necessary area of section of any material to resist a tensile strain, is found by the following rules:—

Wrought Iron

a = W
15,000
,

Cast-Iron

a = W
4,500
,

Wood

a = W
2,000
.

COMPRESSION.

161. Wrought Iron

a = W
12,000
,

Cast-Iron

a = W
25,000
,

Wood

a = W
1,000
.

CROSS STRAIN.

162. The power of any material to resist a cross strain, is shown by the formula

W = 4sbd2
L
,
Where W represents the breaking weight in pounds,
s represents the constant in the table of woods,
b represents the breadth in inches,
d represents the depth in inches,
and L represents the length in inches,

and to reduce the load to one fourth of the breaking weight

W = 4sbd2
4L
,

and finally, by substituting for 4s, 4 × 1,250, (1,250 of the table of woods,) we have

W = 5000bd2
4L
.

Also, knowing the weight to be supported, and requiring the dimensions, we take out the values of d and b, and have

d = √(W × 4L
5000b
) = the depth,
b = W × 4L
5000d2
= the breadth.

As an example of the use of the formula, take the following:—

Let the span, or length, be 20 feet,
The breadth 12 inches, and depth 18,

required the load.

The formula

W = 5000bd2
4L

becomes

W = 5000 × 12 × 182
4 × 240
= 20,250 lbs.

Again, the weight to be supported being 15,000 lbs., length 30 feet, breadth 16 inches, the formula for the depth becomes

d = √(15000 × 1440
5000 × 16
) = √270 = 16 inches,

also,

b = 15000 × 1440
5000 × 256
= 21600000
1280000
= 16 inches.

CAST-IRON.

163. The formula, expressive of the strength of a cast-iron beam, is

850bd2 = WL,

from which we have

b = LW
850d2
= the breadth,
and d = √(L × W
850b
) = the depth.

WROUGHT IRON.

164.

952bd2 = WL,

whence

b = WL
700d2
= the breadth,
and d = √(LW
700b
) the depth.

Fig. 60.

165. Mr. Hodgekinson found, that by arranging the material in a cast-iron beam, as in fig. 60, that the resistance per unit of section was increased over that of a simple rectangular beam, in the ratio of 40 to 23. He makes the general proportion of such girders as follows:—

Length 16
Height 1
Area of top flange 1.0
Area of lower flange 6.1

In this consummate disposition of material, the areas of top and bottom flanges are made inversely proportional to the power of cast-iron to resist compression and extension.

166. Mr. Fairbairn found, that in wrought iron flanged girders, (under which come the various rails, chap. XIII.,) the top web should contain double the area of the lower one. This agrees with the conclusion adopted on page 129, as wrought iron resists more extension than compression.

167. In cast-iron girders, on no account should there be introduced webs, or openings of any kind, either from economic or ornamental motives; as the uniformity of cooling is thereby very much opposed.

168. Mr. Hodgekinson gives, as the result of his experiments, the following formula for dimensioning the cast-iron girder above referred to.

W = 26ad
L
,
Where W is the breaking weight in tons,
a the area of the bottom flange,
d the depth of the girder in inches,
L the length in inches.

As it is not considered safe to load a cast-iron beam with more than one sixth of the breaking load, the formula may be expressed as follows:—

W = 26ad
6L
,

for the weight in tons which may be safely borne, and transforming

a = 6WL
26d

for the area of the lower flange.

Example.—Required the dimensions of a cast-iron beam, of Mr. Hodgekinson’s form, for a span of thirty feet, to support a load of ten tons at the centre.

Span 30 feet, Whence—  
Length 34 feet, Length 34 feet,
Load 10 tons at centre. Span 30 feet,
    Depth 25½ inches,
    Lower flange 32.58 square inches,
    Upper flange 5.34 square inches,
a = 6 × 10 × 12 × 30
26 × 34 × 12
16
= 32.58

and 32.58
6.1
= 5.34.

and the area of the top flange will be

36
6
= 6,

whence the following dimensions:—

Length 30 feet,
Depth 23 inches,
Lower flange 36 square inches,
Upper flange 6 square inches,

OF POSTS.

169. A post may be very well able to resist the compressive strain thrown upon it by any load, but may bulge, or bend, laterally.

The formula by which beams are dimensioned for this requirement, changes with the material, and with the form of section. For rectangular posts of wood, we have the formula below.

W = 2240bd3
L2
,
Where W represents the weight in lbs., which may be safely borne,
b represents the breadth in inches,
d represents the depth in inches,
and L represents the length in feet.

170. The value of the formula for the strength of cast-iron posts, seems to depend more upon the authority consulted than upon the nature of iron. For example, assume the length of a post as twenty feet, and the diameter as ten inches; the load which may be safely borne is, according to six different authorities, as follows:—

A 4,000,000
B 181,100
C 370,000
D 940,000
E 307,242
F 300,000

and assuming the length as ten feet, and diameter as ten inches, we have

A 8,007,500
B 204,500
C 1,442,500
D 3,640,000
E 1,170,000
F 600,000

showing not only a great difference in the unit resistance taken, but also in the effect of the ratio between the length and diameter.

Such being the discrepancy, there will be given no formula; but in place of such, the table following, which is calculated from the rules least opposed to experimental evidence.

TABLE SHOWING THE LOAD IN POUNDS SAFELY BORNE BY CAST-IRON COLUMNS.
HOLLOW CYLINDERS. H AND + SECTIONS.
Diameter in inches. Length or height in feet. Metal thickness. Length or height in feet.
6 8 10 12 15 18 20 22 24 6 8 10 12 15 18 20 22 24
2 6000 5000 4000 3000 2500 1800 1500 1300 1100 ¼ 4000 3000 2400 1800 1400 1100 1000 900 800
3 16000 14000 13000 11000 9000 7000 6000 5000 5000 12000 11000 10000 9000 8000 7000 5000 4000 3000
4 30000 29000 26000 24000 22000 18000 16000 14000 13000 ½ 25000 23000 21000 18000 16000 13000 12000 9000 6000
5 50000 37000 45000 42000 39000 37000 31000 28000 26000 36000 34000 31000 28000 25000 23000 21000 20000 18000
6 59000 57000 55000 52000 49000 44000 41000 38000 36000 ¾ 40000 38000 37000 36000 35000 34000 32000 30000 28000
7 101000 99000 96000 92000 88000 81000 76000 72000 68000 13
16
60000 59000 58000 57000 56000 54000 53000 51000 49000
8 131000 129000 126000 122000 118000 109000 105000 100000 96000 100000 98000 96000 94000 91000 88000 83000 78000 70000
9 169000 167000 164000 160000 156000 146000 141000 136000 131000 1 140000 130000 126000 120000 114000 110000 106000 100000 90000
10 210000 200000 200000 200000 190000 180000 180000 170000 170000 1⅛ 190000 180000 170000 160000 150000 140000 130000 125000 120000
11 250000 250000 240000 240000 240000 230000 220000 220000 210000 230000 220000 210000 200000 190000 180000 170000 160000 150000
12 300000 300000 290000 290000 290000 270000 270000 260000 260000 280000 260000 250000 240000 230000 220000 200000 190000 180000
14 450000 430000 410000 380000 370000 350000 330000 320000 300000 360000 320000 310000 300000 290000 280000 270000 260000 240000
16 520000 500000 480000 460000 440000 420000 400000 370000 350000 2 460000 430000 400000 370000 350000 330000 310000 300000 280000
18 650000 630000 610000 590000 560000 520000 470000 430000 400000 560000 530000 510000 480000 440000 410000 380000 350000 330000
20 800000 760000 740000 690000 650000 590000 540000 490000 450000 3 600000 580000 550000 520000 500000 460000 430000 400000 380000
Diameter in inches. 6 8 10 12 15 18 20 22 24 Metal thickness. 6 8 10 12 15 18 20 22 24
Length or height in feet. Length or height in feet.