CHAPTER III

TUNICATA (CONTINUED)

CLASSIFICATION: LARVACEA—APPENDICULARIANS—STRUCTURE, ETC.—ASCIDIACEA—SIMPLE ASCIDIANS—SPECIFIC CHARACTERS—COMPOUND ASCIDIANS—GEMMATION—MEROSOMATA—HOLOSOMATA—PYROSOMATIDAE—THALIACEA—DOLIOLIDAE—SALPIDAE—GENERAL CONCLUSIONS—PHYLOGENY.

We now turn to the systematic classification of the group; and further details of structure or function, points of interest in the life-history such as budding and the formation of colonies, the habits and occurrence, and other peculiarities such as phosphorescence, will all be noted under the orders, sub-orders, families and genera in which they occur.

CLASS TUNICATA.

The Tunicata or Urochordata are hermaphrodite marine Chordate animals, which show in their development the essential Vertebrate characters, but in which the notochord is restricted to the posterior part of the body, and is in most cases present only during the free-swimming larval stages. The adult animals are usually sessile and degenerate, and may be either solitary or colonial, fixed or free. The nervous system is, in the larva, of the elongated, tubular, dorsal, Vertebrate type, but in most cases it degenerates in the adult to form a small ganglion placed above the pharynx. The body is completely covered with a thick cuticular test ("tunic") which contains a substance similar to cellulose. The alimentary canal has a greatly enlarged respiratory pharynx or branchial sac, which is perforated by two or many more or less modified gill-slits opening into a peribranchial or atrial cavity, which communicates with the exterior by a single dorsal exhalent aperture (rarely two ventral apertures). The ventral heart is simple and tubular, and periodically reverses the direction of the blood-current.

This Class is divided into three Orders:—The Appendicularians, the Ascidians, and the Salpians (see Fig. 27).

Order I. Larvacea (Appendicularians).

Free-swimming pelagic forms, in which the posterior part of the body takes the form of a large locomotory appendage, the "tail," in which there is a skeletal axis, the urochord. A relatively large cuticular test, the "house," may be formed with great rapidity (in an hour or so) as a secretion from a part of the ectoderm; it is, however, merely a temporary structure which is soon cast off and replaced by another. The branchial sac is simply an enlarged pharynx with two ventral ciliated openings (stigmata) leading to the exterior. These may be regarded as the representatives of the primary gill-slits (undivided) of the Ascidian. There are thus a single pair. There is no separate peribranchial, atrial, or cloacal cavity. The nervous system consists of a large dorsally placed ganglion and a long nerve-cord, which stretches backwards over the alimentary canal to reach the tail, along which it runs on the left side (morphological dorsal edge) of the urochord. The anus opens ventrally on the surface of the body, usually in front of the stigmata. No reproduction by gemmation or metamorphosis is known in the life-history.

Structure and Mode of Life.—This is one of the most interesting groups of the Tunicata, as it shows more completely than any of the rest the probable characters of the ancestral forms. It has undergone little or no degeneration, and consequently corresponds more nearly to the tailed, larval condition than to the adult forms of the other groups. It retains, in fact, the originally posterior, chordate, part of the body which is lost in the metamorphosis of all the other Tunicata. Hence the Appendicularians have been described as permanent, or sexually mature, larval forms, and hence also the adult Ascidia may be said to correspond to the trunk alone of the Appendicularian. The Order includes a single group, the Appendiculariida, all the members of which are minute (usually about 5 mm. in total length) and free-swimming (Fig. 28). They occur near the surface of the sea (and exceptionally in deeper water) in most parts of the world, moving in a characteristic vibratory manner by the contractions of the powerful tail (see Fig. 27). They possess the power of forming with great rapidity, from tracts of specially large glandular ectoderm cells, the "oikoplasts," an enormously large (many times the size of the body) investing gelatinous layer, which probably corresponds to the test of other groups, although it is doubtful whether it contains cellulose, and it differs also in having no immigrated cells and in its temporary nature. This structure (Fig. 28) was first described by Von Mertens, and by him named "Haus"; it has recently been more minutely investigated by Lohmann. It is only loosely attached to the body, and is frequently thrown off soon after its formation. Its function is probably protective, and possibly to some extent hydrostatic, and it may also be of use in straining the nutritive particles from the large volumes of water which filter through its complicated passages and perforated folds.^[98] The long, laterally compressed "tail" in the Appendiculariida is attached to the ventral surface of the body (Fig. 30), and is bent downwards and forwards, so that it usually points more or less anteriorly; and is twisted through an angle of 90°, so that the dorsal edge lies to the left. It shows what have been interpreted as traces of metameric segmentation, having its lateral muscle-bands broken up into successive pieces (supposed myotomes, probably only cells), while the nerve-cord presents a series of enlargements formed of groups of nerve-cells from which distributory nerves are given off. In Oikopleura the muscle-band in the tail is formed of ten cells fused on each side. Near the base of the tail there is a distinctly larger elongated ganglion. The urochord in the tail consists of a homogeneous rod surrounded by a sheath containing nuclei.

The anterior (cerebral) ganglion has connected with it an otocyst (Fig. 29), a pigment spot, and a tubular richly ciliated process opening into the branchial sac, and representing the dorsal tubercle and associated parts of an ordinary Ascidian. The tube ends in a plain or coiled cellular mass lying to the right of the ganglion. No neural gland is found.

The branchial aperture or mouth leads into the simple branchial sac or pharynx (Fig. 30, br.s). There are no tentacles. The endostyle is short, is a closed tube both anteriorly and posteriorly (Fig. 29), and has about four longitudinal rows of gland-cells. There is no dorsal lamina, and the peripharyngeal bands run dorsally and posteriorly to unite close in front of the oesophageal opening. The wall of the branchial sac does not show the complex structure usual in Tunicata, and has only two ciliated apertures (Figs. 30, 31, 32, sg). These are homologous with the primary stigmata of the typical Ascidians, and with a pair of the gill-clefts of Vertebrates. They are placed far back on the ventral surface, one on each side of the middle line, and lead into short funnel-shaped tubes which open on the surface of the body behind the anus (Fig. 30, at). These tubes correspond to the right and left atrial involutions, which in an ordinary Ascidian fuse to form the peribranchial cavity. The remainder of the alimentary canal consists of oesophagus, stomach (which may have a glandular diverticulum), intestine and rectum (Fig. 30). The heart, surrounded ventrally by a delicate pericardial membrane, lies below and in front of the stomach, and is formed by the differentiation of the outer ends of epithelial cells into muscular fibrillae. Two specially large glandular cells are placed at the opposite ends of the heart. There are no blood-vessels except the remains of the primary body-cavity (blastocoel). No heart can be seen in some of the smaller species of Oikopleura. Nearly all the species are hermaphrodite, and the large ovary and testis are placed at the posterior end of the body. There is no proper oviduct, the genital products merely breaking through to the exterior at the point marked g.d in Fig. 30. The spermatozoa are generally matured and shed before the ova, and thus self-fertilisation is prevented. The ova are very small, and little is known of the development.

Classification.—There are two Families of Larvacea: First, the Kowalevskiidae, including only the remarkable genus Kowalevskia, Fol, in which the heart and endostyle are absent, and the branchial sac is provided with four rows of ciliated tooth-like processes. The two known species have been found in the Mediterranean and in the Atlantic.

The second family Appendiculariidae comprises about eight genera, amongst which may be mentioned:—(1) Oikopleura, Mertens, and (2) Appendicularia, Fol, in both of which the body is short (1 or 2 mm. in length) and compact (Fig. 30), and the tail relatively long, while the endostyle is straight. (3) Megalocercus, Chun, from deep water in the Mediterranean; M. abyssorum is the largest Appendicularian known, having a total length of 3 cm.—it is of a bright red colour. (4) Fritillaria, Q. and G., in which the body is elongated (Fig. 32) and composed of anterior and posterior regions, the tail relatively short, the endostyle recurved, the stigmata opening far in front of the anus, and an ectodermal hood is formed over the front of the body.

In all nearly forty species of Larvacea are known.

Occurrence.—Although for the most part transparent, and usually almost invisible in sea-water, some Appendicularians may have certain parts of the body (alimentary canal, endostyle, gonads, etc.) brilliantly pigmented (orange, violet, etc.), and may under exceptional circumstances be present in such profusion as to colour tracts of the sea. Appendicularians are widely distributed, having been found in all seas from the Arctic to the Antarctic, both round coasts and in the open ocean. Although a few species have been found at considerable depths in the Mediterranean, still in the Atlantic they are not deep-water animals, and as a group must be regarded as surface-forms. They are fairly abundant to a depth of 100 fathoms, and some few reach 1500. Species of Oikopleura and Fritillaria are frequent round the British coasts, our commonest species being probably O. dioica, Fol, and F. furcata, Moss. Young specimens appear in the plankton about February and March, and larger forms are as a rule found later in the summer. Several instances have been recorded of swarms of especially large forms, provided with massive tests (the "house"), having appeared suddenly on our coast in such abundance as to form an important element in the surface life of the sea.

Order II. Ascidiacea (Ascidians).

Fixed or free-swimming Simple or Compound Ascidians, which in the adult are never provided with a locomotory appendage or tail, and have no trace of a notochord. The free-swimming forms are colonies, the Simple Ascidians being always sedentary and usually fixed. The test is permanent and well developed, and becomes organised by the immigration of cells from the body; as a rule it increases in size with the age of the individual. The branchial sac is large and well developed. Its walls are perforated by numerous slits (stigmata) opening into the peribranchial cavity, which communicates with the exterior by the single atrial aperture. Many of the Ascidiacea, both fixed and free, reproduce by gemmation to form colonies, and in most of them the sexually produced embryo develops into a tailed larva.

The Ascidiacea includes three groups, the Simple Ascidians, the Compound Ascidians, and the free-swimming colonial Pyrosoma, which in some respects connects this Order with the Thaliacea.

Sub-Order 1. Ascidiae Simplices.

Fixed Ascidians, which are solitary, and very rarely reproduce by gemmation; if, as in a few cases, small colonies are formed, the members are not buried in a common investing mass, but each has a distinct test of its own. No strict line of demarcation can be drawn between the Simple and Compound Ascidians; and one of the families of the former group, the Clavelinidae (the "Social" Ascidians of Milne-Edwards), forms a transition from the typical Simple forms which never reproduce by gemmation, to the Compound forms which always do. Over 500 species of Ascidiae Simplices are now known, but there are probably very many more still undescribed. The sub-order may be divided into the following families:—

Fam. 1. Clavelinidae.—Simple Ascidians which reproduce by gemmation to form small colonies (Fig. 33), in which each member, or ascidiozooid, has a distinct test, but all are connected by a common blood-system, and by a prolongation of the "epicardiac tubes" (see p. 83) from the branchial sac. Buds are formed on the stolons (Fig. 33), which are vascular outgrowths from the posterior end of the body, containing prolongations from the ectoderm, mesoderm, and endoderm (the epicardium) of the Ascidiozooid. Branchial sac not folded; internal longitudinal bars usually absent; stigmata straight; tentacles simple. The Clavelinidae are the simplest of the Ascidiae Simplices. They are the forms that come nearest to the Compound Ascidians, and are closely related to the Distomatidae. They are probably the nearest representatives now existing of the ancestral forms from which both Simple and Compound Ascidians are descended.

This family contains amongst others the following three genera:—Ecteinascidia, Herdman, with internal longitudinal bars in the branchial sac; Clavelina, Savigny, with a long body and intestine extending behind the branchial sac (Fig. 33); and Perophora, Wiegmann, with a short compact body and intestine alongside the branchial sac. Clavelina lepadiformis and Perophora listeri are common British species found at a few fathoms depth off various parts of our coast. Both occur round the south end of the Isle of Man. In autumn Clavelina accumulates reserve-material in the ectoderm cells of parts of the stolon, which remain when the rest of the colony dies away, and then form new buds in spring.

Fam. 2. Ascidiidae.—Solitary fixed Ascidians, never forming colonies; with gelatinous or cartilaginous test; branchial aperture usually eight-lobed, atrial aperture usually six-lobed; branchial sac not folded; internal longitudinal bars usually present; stigmata straight or curved; tentacles simple; gonads in or around the intestinal loop. This family is divided into three sections:—

Sub-Fam. 1. Hypobythiinae.—Branchial sac with no internal longitudinal bars, test strengthened with curious symmetrically placed nodules.

The one genus Hypobythius, Moseley, contains two stalked deep-water forms found by the "Challenger;" H. calycodes (Fig. 34, A), from the North Pacific, 2900 fathoms, and H. moseleyi from the South Atlantic, 600 fathoms.

Sub-Fam. 2. Ascidiinae.—Internal longitudinal bars present; stigmata straight. Many genera, of which the following are the more important:—Ciona, Fleming, dorsal languets present; Ascidia, Linnaeus (in part Phallusia, Savigny), dorsal lamina present (Fig. 15, p. 40); Rhodosoma, Ehrenberg, anterior part of test modified to form operculum (Fig. 34, D); Abyssascidia, Herdman, intestine on right side of branchial sac. The type genus of this section, Ascidia, has been described in detail above (Chapter II. p. 39), and Figs. 15 to 26 illustrate its structure and life-history. There are many species. Ciona intestinalis, Linn. (Fig. 40, B), is one of the commonest of British Ascidians, and lives readily in aquaria.

Sub-Fam. 3. Corellinae.—Stigmata curved and forming spirals (Fig. 35). Three genera:—Corella, Alder and Hancock, test gelatinous, body sessile; Corynascidia, Herdman, test gelatinous, body pedunculated (Fig. 34, C), a remarkable deep-sea form with very delicate spirally-coiled vessels in the branchial sac (Fig. 35, A), found in the Pacific (2160 faths.) and the Southern Ocean; Chelyosoma, Brod. and Sowb., upper part of test modified into horny plates (Fig. 34, B).

Corella contains several British species, one of which, C. parallelogramma, O. F. Müll., is one of the commonest and most handsome Ascidians in our coralline zone (about 20 faths.). Through its clear crystalline test the lemon-yellow and carmine pigmentation of the mantle, and even (with a lens) the working of the cilia along the spiral stigmata of the branchial sac (compare Fig. 35, B), can readily be seen. The beating of the heart can be seen just in front of the viscera upon the right side of the branchial sac (compare with Ascidia, Fig. 23).

In the family Ascidiidae the eggs are minute and contain little or no food-yolk, and the tailed larvae (Figs. 26, 42, A) are of the typical form and structure described in Chapter II.

Fam. 3. Cynthiidae.—Solitary fixed Ascidians (Fig. 39), sometimes occurring in aggregations, but never forming colonies; usually with leathery or fibrous, opaque test, which is sometimes encrusted with sand; branchial and atrial apertures usually both four-lobed. Branchial sac longitudinally folded (Fig. 36, A); stigmata straight; tentacles simple or compound (Fig. 37); neural gland dorsal to ganglion; gonads attached to body-wall. This family is divided into three sections:—

Sub-Fam. 1. Styelinae.—Not more than four folds (Fig. 36, B) on each side of branchial sac; tentacles simple (Fig. 37, A). The more important genera are—Styela, Macleay, and Polycarpa, Heller (Fig. 39), with stigmata normal; and Bathyoncus, Herdman, with stigmata absent or modified. There are a very large number of species of both Styela and Polycarpa from all parts of the world, including our own seas. A very abundant British littoral form has been placed in an allied genus under the name Styelopsis grossularia (Fig. 39, A). It is known in some places round our coasts as "the red-currant squirter." This species has only one well-marked fold in the branchial sac (Fig. 36, C). Another exceptional British Styelid is Pelonaia corrugata, Forb. and Goods. (Fig. 39, I), with no branchial folds (Fig. 36, D).

Sub-Fam. 2. Cynthiinae.—More than eight folds in branchial sac (Fig. 36, A); tentacles compound (Fig. 37, B); body sessile or with a short stalk (Fig. 39, F). The chief genus is Cynthia, Savigny, with a large number of species, some of which are British. Rhabdocynthia has echinated calcareous spicules in the mantle (see Fig. 50, D, p. 87).

Forbesella tessellata is a remarkable British species, having the test marked out into plates (Fig. 39, B). It is intermediate in some characters between Styelinae and Cynthiinae.

Sub-Fam. 3. Bolteninae.—More than eight folds in branchial sac; tentacles compound; body pedunculated (Fig. 38, A). The chief genera are—Boltenia, Savigny, with the branchial aperture four-lobed, and the stigmata normal; and Culeolus, Herdman (Fig. 38), with branchial aperture having less than four lobes, and the stigmata absent or modified (Fig. 38, B), the branchial sac showing a wide mesh-work of vessels stiffened by branched calcareous spicules. Culeolus is a deep-sea genus discovered by the "Challenger" expedition; eight or nine species are now known from various parts of the world, ranging in depth from 630 to 2425 fathoms. Most of the species are from the Pacific; only one from the North Atlantic. The curiously curved type of spicule found in the branchial sac and other organs is shown at Fig. 50, C (p. 87).

Amongst the Cynthiidae are found most varied conditions of the reproductive organs. The gonads are sometimes on both, sometimes on only one side of the body, sometimes in one or several branched masses, and sometimes distributed as a large number of minute "polycarps" over the inner surface of the mantle.

The family Cynthiidae is the largest section of the Simple Ascidians. The species range from the size of a pea to that of a large cocoa-nut. They are for the most part opaque, and often richly coloured—reds, yellows and rich browns predominating—and so look very different to the grey gelatinous Ascidiidae, and to the sand-encrusted Molgulidae. They extend from between tide-marks (Styelopsis grossularia), down to the abysses (Styela bythia and S. squamosa at 2600 fathoms). Some genera (Styela and the closely related Dendrodoa), extend far into Arctic seas, but many allied forms (Styela and Polycarpa) are also found in the tropics.

Fam. 4. Molgulidae.—Solitary sessile Ascidians, sometimes not fixed; branchial aperture six-lobed, atrial four-lobed. Test usually encrusted with sand, which is generally attached to branched hair-like processes from the test (Fig. 40, C). Branchial sac longitudinally folded; stigmata more or less curved, usually arranged in spirals (Fig. 41); tentacles compound. The chief genera are—Molgula, Forbes (Fig. 40, C), with distinct folds in the branchial sac (Fig. 41, B), and Eugyra, Ald. and Hanc., with no distinct folds, but merely broad internal longitudinal bars in the branchial sac (Fig. 41, C). In some of the Molgulidae (genus Anurella, Lacaze-Duthiers), the embryo does not become converted into a tailed larva, the development being direct without metamorphosis (see Fig. 42, C). The embryo when hatched gradually assumes the adult structure, and never shows the features characteristic of larval Ascidians, such as the urochord and the median sense-organs. Fig. 42 shows an Ascidiid (A), a Cynthiid (B), and this exceptional Molgulid (C), type of larva, and three forms of Compound Ascidian larvae, the Distomatid (D), the Botryllid (E), and the Diplosomatid (F).

In the Molgulidae the viscera are characteristic in position and appearance. The alimentary canal lies on the left side of the branchial sac, and the intestine forms a long narrow loop directed in the main transversely. The pericardium and heart are on the middle of the right side, and behind them is placed the single sac-like ductless renal organ, generally occupied by one or more concretions. The gonads are in most cases on both sides of the body, in front of the intestine on the left, and in front of the heart on the right; but in Eugyra there is no gonad on the right side, and in some other forms the gonad on the left side is absent. (For Oligotrema, see p. 111, note.)

There are a number of British Molgulidae, the two commonest of which are—Molgula oculata, Forbes, thickly covered with gravel or broken shells, and forming an ovate mass as large as a walnut; and Eugyra glutinans, Möller, a smaller more globular body, the size of an acorn, and covered with fine sand, except at one circular area near the posterior end, where the leaden grey test shows through. Both these species are obtained by dredging in from 10 to 30 fathoms, and lie freely on the bottom. A rather rarer littoral species Molgula citrina, Hancock, found on some parts of our coast (e.g. in the Firth of Forth, at Arran, and at Port Erin), is exceptional in having the test free from sand, and in being fixed like an Ascidia, generally to the lower surfaces of large stones near low tide.

Specific Characters and Dorsal Tubercle.—The chief points in which the various genera and species of Simple Ascidians differ are the details of the branchial sac (see Figs. 22, 35, 36, 38, and 41), the condition of the tentacles (Fig. 37), the dorsal lamina or languets, and the dorsal tubercle, in addition to form, colour, and other external features.

Fig. 43 shows some of the more remarkable forms of dorsal tubercle. Starting with a simple circular opening (1) surrounded by a thickened ciliated ring, the anterior border becomes pushed in to form a crescentic slit (2 and 3). The horns of the crescent then grow longer and may be turned in (4 and 5) or out (6 and 7), and so give rise to the many varieties of horse-shoe (such as 6), perhaps the commonest form of dorsal tubercle in Simple Ascidians. In many Cynthiidae the central part of the horse-shoe remains small, while the horns become long and much coiled so as to constitute two prominent spirals (8, 9, 10). In other exceptional forms again the curved slit becomes straightened out, undulating (11), irregularly bent (12 and 13), elaborately folded (14 and 15), or broken up into pieces (16), so that there come to be several or even a large number (17 and 18) of minute openings in place of the original single aperture.

It cannot be said that any form of dorsal tubercle is characteristic of any of the families or genera of Ascidians, and in the case of some species the organ is liable to great individual variation; but still in most species there is found to be a characteristic shape or appearance of tubercle which is a useful diagnostic feature.

Sub-Order 2. Ascidiae Compositae.

Fixed Ascidians which reproduce by gemmation so as to form colonies (Fig. 44) in which the ascidiozooids are buried in a common investing mass (Fig. 45) and have no separate tests—hence "Synascidiae," a name they often receive from foreign writers.

This is probably a somewhat artificial assemblage formed of those two or three groups of Ascidians which produce colonies, in which the ascidiozooids are so intimately united that they possess a common test or investing mass. This is the only character which distinguishes them from the Clavelinidae, but the property of reproducing by gemmation separates them from the rest of the Ascidiae Simplices. In some cases the atrial apertures of several neighbouring ascidiozooids join to open to the exterior by a common cloacal aperture (Fig. 45, c.c). Such groups of the ascidiozooids of a colony are known as "systems" or coenobia (see Fig. 44, D; also Fig. 53, p. 89).

The Ascidiae Compositae may be divided into seven families, which seem to fall into two well-marked sets:—(1) Merosomata, in which the heart and alimentary and reproductive viscera are placed behind the branchial sac, so as to constitute a more or less extended body divided into at least two regions (Fig. 46, B), and sometimes three (Fig. 46, C)—thorax, abdomen, and post-abdomen; and (2) Holosomata, in which the body of the ascidiozooid is short, compact, and not divided into regions (Fig. 46, A). The latter group comprises the two families Botryllidae and Polystyelidae, which agree both in points of structure and in having the same type of budding, and are probably derived from ancestral Cynthiidae amongst Simple Ascidians; while the Merosomata seem more nearly related to the Clavelinidae.

Gemmation takes place in the Compound Ascidians in a variety of ways, being sometimes very different in its details in closely allied forms. There are, however, two main types of budding, to one or other of which most of the described methods may be referred. These are:—

1. The Stolonial, or "epicardiac" type—seen in the Merosomata, typically in Distomatidae and Polyclinidae, and comparable with the gemmation in Clavelinidae, Pyrosomatidae, and Thaliacea outside this group.

2. The Parietal, or "peribranchial" type—seen in the Holosomata, typically in the Botryllidae.

The remarkable process of gemmation seen in the families Didemnidae and Diplosomatidae, where the bud arises from at least two rudiments, the one stolonial or epicardiac in origin, and the other formed by one or more oesophageal or intestinal outgrowths, has been called "entero-epicardiac," but it may probably be regarded as a modification of the stolonial type.

The marked differences in the appearance of the colonies of Compound Ascidians is largely due to the methods of budding; and even in those of the stolonial type, where the budding is practically the same in essential nature, the results may be very different in superficial appearance, according as the buds are formed on a short stolon close to the parent body, or from the extremity of the post-abdomen (as in the Polyclinidae), or from a long epicardiac tube (as in Colella, Fig. 47), which may extend for some inches from the ascidiozooid. The post-abdomen of the Polyclinidae may be regarded as a stolon invaded by the gonads and the heart (see Fig. 46, C), and traversed by the epicardium in the form of a flattened tube dividing a dorsal blood-sinus containing the gonads from a ventral sinus which has merely the one extremity of the tapering pericardium. The whole of this post-abdomen segments to form the buds, the heart at the extremity being absorbed, and a new one formed from the anterior end of the pericardium.

The epicardium, which supplies the endodermal element to each bud, was first described by E. van Beneden and Julin in the envelopment of Clavelina,^[99] as a structure concerned in the formation of the pericardium and heart—hence its unfortunate name. It grows backwards in the larva, from the posterior wall of the branchial sac, close to the endostyle, as a tube which usually divides into two lateral branches to be united again eventually so as to form the single tubular flattened partition of the stolon in Polyclinidae, Distomatidae, Clavelinidae, etc. In some Compound Ascidians the epicardium is, from its origin, two distinct lateral tubes, which grow back from the inner vesicle of the embryo (later the branchial sac). These unite in the post-abdomen to form the flattened tube, which in its turn forms the inner vesicle of the future buds, and so the endodermal element is handed on from generation to generation. In addition to the epicardium, the stolon contains also a prolongation of the ovary of the parent, or at least a string of migrating germ cells, so that the reproductive elements are also handed on.

It is clear from the recent researches of Hjort, Ritter, Lefevre,^[100] and others, that the development of the bud (blastozooid) and that of the embryo (oozooid) do not proceed along parallel lines. It is evidently impossible to harmonise the facts of gemmation with the germ-layer theory; and attempts to explain budding in Ascidians solely as a process of regeneration by which the organs of the parent or their germ-layers give rise to the corresponding organs in the bud have in many cases failed.